Sindhumati Ramavtar Pathak Vs ACIT (ITAT Mumbai)
Sunrise Asian LTCG Held Genuine: ITAT Mumbai Deletes s.68 & s.69C Additions Despite Penny-Stock Allegations
ITAT Mumbai (F Bench) in Sindhumati Ramavtar Pathak vs ACIT (ITA No. 4914/Mum/2025, AY 2015-16, order dated 24.12.2025) has allowed the assessee’s appeal, deleting additions made u/s 68 (sale proceeds) and u/s 69C (alleged commission) in respect of Long-Term Capital Gains on sale of shares of Sunrise Asian Ltd.
The Assessee, a senior citizen widow and regular investor, purchased shares of Conart Trader’s Ltd. in 2011 through banking channels, which later amalgamated with Sunrise Asian Ltd. pursuant to a Bombay HC-approved scheme. Shares were dematerialised in 2013 and sold after more than 30 months through a recognised stock exchange with STT paid, and sale proceeds received through bank. AO treated the transaction as a pre-arranged penny-stock accommodation entry, taxing the entire sale proceeds u/s 68 and estimating commission u/s 69C. NFAC sustained the s.68 addition.
Reversing NFAC, ITAT held that the Assessee discharged the onus by producing purchase documents, bank statements, demat records, contract notes and STT proof; part of the shares continued to be held. No evidence of price rigging or manipulation by the Assessee was brought on record; no adverse SEBI finding existed against her. Mere reliance on investigation reports, price rise, human probability or third-party statements without corroboration is insufficient.
The Tribunal followed a consistent line of decisions on the same scrip (Sunrise Asian Ltd.), including Gujarat HC in Divyaben Prafulchandra Parmar and several Mumbai ITAT rulings, holding that long-held investments sold on-market cannot be branded bogus in absence of direct evidence. Once the substantive addition u/s 68 failed, the commission addition u/s 69C also collapsed.
FULL TEXT OF THE ORDER OF ITAT MUMBAI
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.





