Late Shri Ram Kishore Seth Vs ITO (ITAT Delhi)
Residential Units vs Residential House: ITAT Draws the Line- Multiple Kitchens, No 54F: Tribunal Says Assessee Owned More Than One House
1. Background
- Appeal filed by Legal Heir of Late Shri Ram Kishore Seth against NFAC order dated 16.01.2024.
- Scrutiny under CASS for cash deposits during demonetisation & capital gains / deduction u/s 54F.
2. Issue 1 – Deduction u/s 54F on JDA Property
Assessee’s Claim
- Original house at ND-63, Pitampura demolished & reconstructed under JDA (3 floors).
- Builder retained 2nd floor + 25% parking; Assessee retained 1st & 3rd floors.
- Claimed ₹1,22,45,121 exemption u/s 54F relying on CIT vs Geeta Duggal.
AO’s Findings
- Assessee owned multiple independent house properties (Karol Bagh units + Pitampura units).
- After amendment to s.54F, phrase used is “a residential house”; ownership of multiple houses disqualifies the claim.
CIT(A) & ITAT Findings
- Assessee was earning rental income from:
- Karol Bagh UGF
- Karol Bagh 1st Floor
- Karol Bagh 4th Floor
- Pitampura 1st Floor
- Pitampura 3rd Floor
- These are independent residential units, each having separate kitchens.
- Therefore assessee owned more than one residential house on the date of transfer → basic eligibility u/s 54F fails.
- Geeta Duggal ratio applies only where multiple units constitute one house; not applicable when assessee already owns several independent properties.

Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.





