Ira Sharma Vs DCIT (ITAT Delhi)
Set-Off of LTCL & STCL Against LTCG Cannot Be Denied Merely Because Tax Rates Differ—CPC & CIT(A) Misread Section 70; Entire Adjustment u/s 143(1) Deleted
The Assessee filed return declaring ₹1,04,31,185, after setting off:
- B/f LTCL: ₹7,09,283,
- Current year STCL (shares): ₹10,56,001,
- STCL (mutual funds): ₹7,50,902,
against current-year LTCG from NCDs and mutual funds.
CPC issued a 143(1) proposal alleging that losses could not be set off, and despite the Assessee’s reply dated 27.01.2024, disallowed all set-off, computing income at ₹1,29,47,370. CIT(A) upheld the adjustment on the reasoning that losses and gains were not from the “same computation” as tax rates were different.
Before ITAT, the Assessee argued that Section 70(2) & 70(3) permit:
- STCL – set off against STCG and LTCG,
- LTCL – set off against LTCG,
and the phrase “similar computation” refers to the same head of income—Capital Gains, not identical tax rates. The Assessee relied on Mac Charles India Ltd (ITAT Bangalore) and Keshav S. Phansalkar (ITAT Mumbai).
Tribunal’s Findings
The ITAT held:
1. Section 70 uses “similar computation” to refer only to the head ‘Income from Capital Gains’,
not the tax rate of resulting gains or losses.
2. There is no legislative bar on setting off STCL/LTCL against LTCG merely because the LTCG may be taxed at a lower rate.
3. Co-ordinate bench rulings (Mac Charles; Keshav Phansalkar) confirm that even losses relating to assets taxed at concessional rates can be set off against other capital gains.
4. Revenue’s stand is flawed because, in this case, the losses were from assets taxed at a higher rate than the LTCG—therefore, there is not even a revenue loss.
5. CPC and CIT(A) misinterpreted Section 70; the adjustment u/s 143(1) was beyond the narrow scope of “prima facie adjustments.”
Accordingly, the Tribunal directed the AO to allow in full:
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.



