GSTAT Appeal – Section 112: Maintainability, Limitation, Pre-Deposit & FORM GST APL-05

Appeal before GST Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT) Under Section 112: Maintainability, Limitation, Pre-Deposit and FORM GST APL-05

1. Introduction

In this article we will discuss about the appeal filling in the Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal, commonly known as GSTAT, is the second appellate forum under the GST law. It is not a forum where every original GST order can be challenged directly. In the normal statutory scheme, an assessee must first file an appeal before the Appellate Authority under Section 107. Thereafter, if the assessee is aggrieved by the order of the Appellate Authority, appeal may be filed before GSTAT under Section 112 of the CGST Act, 2017.

Section 112(1) clearly provides that any person aggrieved by an order passed against him under Section 107 or Section 108 may appeal to the Appellate Tribunal. Therefore, GSTAT appeal generally lies against: (i) an Order-in-Appeal passed by the first Appellate Authority; or (ii) a revision order passed by the Revisional Authority. Direct appeal to GSTAT against an original adjudication order is normally not maintainable.

I have tried to cover all relevant details in this article. However, if you still have any queries or require further clarification, you may contact me using the details mentioned at the end of this article.

2. When can appeal be filed before GSTAT?

An appeal before GSTAT can be filed where the assessee is aggrieved by an adverse order passed by the first Appellate Authority or by the Revisional Authority. The following are common practical situations where GSTAT appeal may lie:

Section 109(5) provides that appeals against orders of the Appellate Authority or Revisional Authority are heard by the Principal Bench or State Benches; however, where any issue involved relates to place of supply, the matter is to be heard only by the Principal Bench.

3. Orders against which GST appeal is not maintainable

Section 121 of the CGST Act specifically bars appeal against certain decisions or orders. No appeal lies against an order relating to transfer of proceedings from one officer to another, seizure or retention of books of account/registers/documents, sanction for prosecution, or an order passed under Section 80 relating to payment of tax/amount in instalments.

Further, GSTAT has discretion to refuse admission of an appeal where the tax, input tax credit, difference in tax/ITC, fine, fee or penalty involved does not exceed ₹50,000, as provided in Section 112(2). This is not an absolute statutory bar, but a discretionary power of the Tribunal.

4. Limitation period for filing GSTAT appeal

For an assessee, appeal before GSTAT is required to be filed within three months from the date of communication of the order sought to be appealed against. GSTAT may condone delay for a further period of three months, if it is satisfied that there was sufficient cause for not filing the appeal within time. Therefore, in ordinary cases, the practical outer limit is three months plus further three months, subject to condonation by GSTAT.

For departmental appeal/application, the Commissioner may direct an officer subordinate to him to apply to GSTAT within six months from the date on which the order has been passed, and GSTAT may permit filing within a further period of three months on sufficient cause.

Where notice of appeal is received by the opposite party, a memorandum of cross-objections may be filed within 45 days. GSTAT may permit filing of cross-objection within a further period of 45 days, if sufficient cause is shown.

Special timeline for backlog / old GSTAT appeals

For orders communicated before 01.04.2026, the Government has notified 30.06.2026 as the date up to which appeal may be filed before GSTAT. For orders communicated on or after 01.04.2026, the appeal has to be filed within three months from the date of communication of the order. This position flows from Gazetted Notification S.O. 4220(E) dated 17.09.2025, issued under Section 112(1).

5. Mandatory pre-deposit for GSTAT appeal

Before filing appeal under Section 112, the appellant must pay:

1. the full amount of tax, interest, fine, fee and penalty admitted by him; and

2. 10% of the remaining disputed tax, in addition to the amount paid at first appeal stage under Section 107(6), subject to maximum ₹20 crore.

In penalty-only matters, where the order demands penalty without any tax demand, appeal cannot be filed unless 10% of such penalty is paid, in addition to the amount payable at the first appellate stage. Once the required pre-deposit is made, recovery of the balance amount is deemed to be stayed till disposal of the appeal, as per Section 112(9).

6. Form and filing requirement

An appeal to GSTAT is required to be filed electronically in FORM GST APL-05 along with relevant documents. Cross-objection, if any, is filed in FORM GST APL-06. The appeal is treated as filed only when the final acknowledgement indicating the appeal number is issued.

The prescribed filing fee is ₹1,000 for every ₹1 lakh of tax, ITC, difference in tax/ITC, fine, fee or penalty involved, subject to minimum ₹5,000 and maximum ₹25,000. Where the order does not involve any demand of tax, interest, fine, fee or penalty, the fee is ₹5,000.

7. Documents generally required for GSTAT appeal

A properly prepared GSTAT appeal should generally include:

• Order-in-Appeal or revision order appealed against;
• Original adjudication order;
• Show cause notice and relied-upon documents;
• Reply filed before the adjudicating authority;
• Appeal memo filed before the first appellate authority;
• Statement of facts;
• Grounds of appeal;
• Prayer clause;
• Proof of mandatory pre-deposit;
• Proof of filing fee;
• Authorisation, vakalatnama or letter of authority;
• Index and complete paper book;
• Copies of relevant judgments, circulars, notifications and reconciliation statements, wherever relied upon.

Where the order appealed against is not uploaded on the common portal, the appellant is required to submit or upload a self-certified copy of the order within the prescribed timeline; delay in uploading such copy may affect the date of filing of appeal.

8. Meaning and scope of revision order under Section 108

A revision order under Section 108 is an order passed by a Revisional Authority to revise an earlier decision or order passed by a subordinate GST officer. Such revision may be made where the earlier order is considered erroneous in so far as it is prejudicial to the interest of revenue, illegal or improper, passed without considering material facts, or affected by an observation of the Comptroller and Auditor General of India. Before passing an adverse revision order, the Revisional Authority must give the person concerned an opportunity of being heard and may make further inquiry as necessary.

The Revisional Authority may enhance, modify or annul the earlier decision or order. For example, if a proper officer drops a demand, but the Commissioner later finds that material facts were ignored and the order is prejudicial to revenue, revision proceedings may be initiated under Section 108.

Notification No. 05/2020-Central Tax dated 13.01.2020 authorises the Principal Commissioner or Commissioner of Central Tax as Revisional Authority for decisions or orders passed by Additional/Joint Commissioner, and authorises Additional/Joint Commissioner as Revisional Authority for decisions or orders passed by Deputy Commissioner, Assistant Commissioner or Superintendent. CBIC Circular No. 250/07/2025-GST dated 24.06.2025 also clarifies the revisional authority position in respect of orders passed by Common Adjudicating Authorities.

9. When revision under Section 108 cannot be exercised

Section 108(2) places important restrictions on revisional power. Revision cannot be exercised where the order has already been subject to appeal under Sections 107, 112, 117 or 118; where the period for departmental appeal under Section 107(2) has not expired; where more than three years have expired from the order sought to be revised; where the order has already been taken up for revision earlier; or where the order itself was passed in exercise of revisionary power.

However, where an issue was not raised and decided in appeal, the Revisional Authority may revise that separate point within the prescribed statutory period. Every revision order is final and binding subject to further remedies before GSTAT, High Court or Supreme Court, as provided under the Act.

10. Common matters on which GST appeals are filed

GST appeal is not filed merely on a “topic”; it is filed against an adverse order or decision. However, in practice, GST appeals commonly arise from the following issues:

11. Practical conclusion

A GSTAT appeal is maintainable when there is an adverse Order-in-Appeal under Section 107 or an adverse revision order under Section 108, the matter is not barred by Section 121, the appeal is within limitation or delay is condonable, the statutory pre-deposit under Section 112(8) has been paid, and the appeal is filed in FORM GST APL-05 with complete supporting documents.

For practical compliance, the safest approach is to file the GSTAT appeal within three months from the communication of the Order-in-Appeal or revision order. For backlog matters where the order was communicated before 01.04.2026, the appeal should be filed on or before 30.06.2026, without waiting for the last date.

*******

For any query, clarification, or assistance in relation to Income Tax or GST matters—particularly notices, assessments, litigation, legal proceedings, or tax demands—you may contact us without hesitation at the details mentioned below: Mobile: +91-9818640458 Email: varunmukeshgupta96@gmail.com