Transrail Lighting Limited Vs Commissioner of Central Excise & ST (CESTAT Ahmedabad)
CESTAT Ahmedabad held that value of bought out items supplied along with manufactured goods cannot be included in the assessable value of the manufactured goods.
Facts- The issue involved in the present case is as to whether the value of bought out items supplied as such along with manufactured goods is liable to be included in the assessable value of manufactured goods cleared on payment of excise duty.
Conclusion- Held that value of bought out items supplied along with manufactured goods cannot be included in the assessable value of the manufactured goods. Therefore, the issue is no longer res-integra. Since we have decided the matter on merits, the other issues raised by the appellant are not taken up. Accordingly, the impugned orders are set-aside and the appeals are allowed with consequential relief.
FULL TEXT OF THE CESTAT AHMEDABAD ORDER
The issue involved in the present case is as to whether the value of bought out items supplied as such along with manufactured goods is liable to be included in the assessable value of manufactured goods cleared on payment of excise duty.
2. The brief facts of the case are that the appellant are engaged in the manufacture of ‘lattice mast’ (also referred to as High Mast/Pole) falling under Chapter 73 of the first schedule to the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985 which are cleared on payment of excise duty. The appellant are registered with Service Tax department for providing taxable services under the category of Erection & Commissioning. Lattice mast manufactured by the appellant are cleared in the domestic market on payment of excise duty as well as are cleared for export. In some cases, the customers who buy lattice mast manufactured by the appellant for their convenience, also place orders on the appellant for supply of Winches, NN Wire Rope, Electric Motor, Control Panel, Eight fixture etc. (hereinafter referred to as the “bought out items) to be used by the customers for erection/commissioning of High Mast Tower. In some cases, the customers also place purchase orders on the appellants for supply of bought out items only. The appellant purchase the bought out items either from the manufacturer or the traders. The appellants do not take Cenvat credit of excise duty paid on such bought out items as they are not used for manufacture of their finished goods. The appellant are paying VAT/CST on such sales. However, in few cases where customer requires appellant to supply Arm Brackets which are to be fixed on poles, value of such Arm Brackets is included in the assessable value and excise duty is paid as they are part and parcel of the manufactured pole. Periodical show cause notices were issued to the appellant proposing demand of differential duty on the ground that value of the bought out items purchased is includible in the assessable value of the so called High Mast Tower cleared by the appellant. The Adjudicating Authority, confirmed demand against the appellant and penalties have been imposed therefore, these appeals are filed by the appellant.
3. Shri Anand Nainawati, learned Counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant submits that the appellant are engaged in the manufacture of Lattice Mast (only pole) and they do not have facility to manufacture any other item so as to manufacture not High Mast Lighting Tower (complete lighting system emerging in immovable position). The bought-out items are not assembled by the Appellant along with the lattice mast. Lattice mast and bought-out items are assembled at the time of erection of High Mast Lighting Tower at the site by the customers. There are number of cases in which the Appellants have only sold the lattice mast to the customers and have not sold the bought-out items. In fact, in some cases, the customers place purchase order on the Appellants for supply of bought-out items alone and not for the lattice mast. Further, there is no evidence on record to show that in all cases wherever the appellants have sold lattice mast, the Appellants have also sold bought-out items to their customers. The customers never placed purchase order on the Appellants for supply of High Mast Lighting Tower. He submits that bought-out items may be essential part for High Mast Lighting Tower but the same are not parts /components of the lattice mast manufactured by the appellants. Lattice mast is complete in itself even without bought-out items. Therefore, the value of the bought-out items need not be added to the assessable value of the lattice mast manufactured and cleared by the appellants. He submits that it is settled legal position that even though bought out items are essential for functioning of machine used along with the manufactured items however, the value of the bought out items is not includible in the value of lattice mast. He placed reliance on the following judgments:-
(a) Neycer India Limited vs. CCE – 2005 (192) ELT 620 (Tri. Chennai)- Affirmed by Hon’ble Supreme Court reported at CCE vs. Neycer India Limited – 2015 (320) ELT 28 (S.C.)
(b) CCE Vs Unitech Power Transmission Limited – 2018 (364) ELT 1048 (Tri. Mumbai)
(c) Kores (India) Limited vs. CC – 2014 (303) ELT 83 (Tri. Mumbai)
(d) CCE Vs Ingersoll Rand (India) Ltd 1999 (105) ELT 549 (SC)
(e) Sur Iron & Steel Co. (P) Limited vs. CCE – 2018 (363) ELT 373 (Tri. Kolkata)
(f) CCE vs. Thermax Limited – 2009 (235) ELT 737 (Tri.Mumbai)
(g) CCE VS Sterlite Industries (I) Limited vs. 2006 (195) ELT 231 (Tri.Mumbai)
(h) CCE vs. Ravi Krishna Castings Limited – 2004 (176) ELT 556 (Tri. Bang.)
(i) Emerson Network Power India P. Ltd vs. CCE – 2004 (176) ELT 168 (Tri. Mumbai)
3.1 Without prejudice to above submissions he further submits that in any event of the matter, the so called High Mast Tower is emerged at the site of the customers, the appellant are not manufacturer of High Mast Tower. The show cause notices have been issued without any jurisdiction therefore, the impugned orders are not sustainable and demand raised in the aforesaid show cause notices are liable to be set-aside. The proceedings have been initiated assuming that appellants are manufacturing High Mast Tower. Though incorrect, however even if this assumption is taken to logical end even then admitted factual position is that the High Mast Tower had emerged at the site of the customers at various different locations which are not necessarily fall within the jurisdiction of the Commissioner, Silvasa. Therefore, he submits that Commissioner Silvasa has no jurisdiction to examine the correctness of the excise duty paid on the High Mast Tower.
3.2 Without prejudice, he further submits that High Mast Tower had emerged as an immovable property at the site of the customers. The High Mast Tower is permanently attached to the earth and has to be dismantled for removal and what would emerge on such dismantling would only be individual parts and not complete High Mast Tower. Hence, no duty is liable to be paid on the same. This submission is fully supported by the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Triveni Engineering & Industries Vs. CCE-2000 (120) ELT 273 (SC). In view of the above judgment, even if the activity has amounted to manufacture, no excise duty can be charged on the same. This legal position has also been accepted by the CBEC vide Board Circular No. 58/1/2002-CX dated 15.01.2002.
3.3 Learned Counsel further submits that merely for the reason that the appellants have given warranty in respect of the bought out items cleared by them does not mean that the same is part of the lattice mast cleared by the appellants. Without prejudice to the above, he further submits that if demand is confirmed in the present case on the bought out items, the credit of the duty paid on bought-out items is available to the appellants. Without prejudice, he also submits that the benefit of cum duty price is available to the appellants.
3.4 Learned Counsel further submits that in the present case extended period of limitation is not invokable since the appellants had neither wilfully suppressed the fact nor mis-stated the fact with intent to evade payment of duty. Therefore, demand beyond normal period of limitation is time barred.
3.5 He further submits that the fact regarding trading of bought out items by the appellant is known to the department. The appellant submits that they export their goods through merchant exporter. Merchant exporter issues CT-1 certificate to the appellant on which excise duty is shown on the lattice mast as well as accessory on lattice mast. On this basis, the merchant exporter executed bond to the department in respect of export clearances. However, at the time of export, excise duty is paid only on the lattice mast and not on the accessories. This is clear from the ARE-1 filed with the department. Since, the merchant exporter issued CT-1 for higher excise duty element, therefore, later-on, the merchant exporter requested the appellant to get the non-utilisation certificate for the remaining amount of CT-1 amount. As per the instructions of the merchant exporter, the appellant requested the Superintendent, Central Excise, Range-V, Silvassa to issue non-utilisation certificate. The correspondence in this regard have been annexed with the appeal memo. From the said documents it is clear that the fact of payment of excise duty only on lattice mast and not on the bought out items was well within the knowledge of the department. Therefore, the demand for the extended period is incorrect. He placed reliance on the following judgments:-
(a) CCE vs. Punjab Chem & Pharm – 2001 (135) ELT 227 (T)
(b) Asia Automotive Limited vs. CCE-1999 (113) ELT 841
(c) Nadiad Silicate & Chem vs. CCE-1995 (80) ELT 891
(d) Haryana Co-op. Sugar vs. State-1997 (107) STC 103
4. Shri Ghanasyam Soni, learned Addl. Commissioner (AR) appearing on behalf of the Revenue reiterates the findings of the impugned order.
5. We have carefully considered the submissions made by both the sides and perused the record. We find that there is no dispute on the fact that appellant are manufacturing lattice mast and during the course of manufacture no bought out items are used in the manufacture. The bought out items which is subject matter of the present dispute are purchased and thereafter sold as trading activity by the appellant. Even though the bought out items are supplied by the appellant as trading activity but the same is not part and parcel of the manufacture of lattice mast. At the most, this bought out items are used for completing and erection and installation of High Mast Tower. There is clear distinction between lattice mast manufactured by the appellant and High Mast Tower erected and installed at the site of the customers. The appellant have provided the details of use of the bought out items at the site which is as under:-
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.


