sc92's Posts - Page 5

High frequency & volume in share deals with short holding period is trading activity

Pine Tree Finserve Pvt. Ltd. vs. CIT (Bombay HC): IT Appeal No.- 2242 OF 2013

Bombay HC in the above cited case held that when the assessee’s volume of purchasing and selling shares is quite high with higher frequency of buying and selling with holding 75 days or less then its prima facie indicate that it is engaged in trading of shares unless assessee provide a sound reasoning that why transactions should not be...

Read More

Reimbursement of seconded employees’ salaries to seconding company not subject to TDS

DCIT Vs. Mahanagar Gas Ltd. (ITAT Mumbai)

The ITAT Mumbai in the above cited case held that reimbursement of secondment expensed by assessee to the company seconding its employees to assessee is not subject to TDS as the employer-employee relationship for all legal purposes subsist between seconding company and seconded employees for which seconding company is liable ...

Read More

Recognition of income on accrual basis to be considered from view point of a prudent assessee

CIT Vs. M.s Neon Solutions P. Ltd. (Bombay High Court), IT Appeal No. 2251 & 2360 of 2013, 05.04.2016

The Hon'ble Bombay High Court in the above cited case held that even in mercantile system of accounting an item would be regarded as accrued income only if there is certainty of receiving it and not when it has been waived. Earning of the income, whether actual or notional, has to be seen from the viewpoint of a prudent assessee....

Read More

Eligible business profits to be computed as per law & not as per treatment by assessee in its books

M/s. Kumarakom Lake Resort Pvt. Ltd. Vs ACIT (ITAT Cochin)

The ITAT Bench Cochin held that the assessee would be entitled to deduction u/s 80 IB(7) if its incomes are derived from eligible business irrespective of the manner in which the entries in the books of account are maintained....

Read More

Surplus investment in mutual funds cannot render principle of Mutuality inapplicable

CIT-3 Vs. M/s. Air Cargo Agents Association of India (Bombay high Court)

The Hon’ble Bombay High Court in the above cited case held that merely because a part of surplus was invested in mutual funds it cannot mean that it would render the principle of mutuality inapplicable more so when the invested money has to be utilized for the furtherance of association’s objectives...

Read More

Satisfaction of need, rendition & benefit test is to be from assessee’s business point of view

GE Money Financial Services Pvt. Ltd. Vs. ACIT (Delhi ITAT)

The ITAT Delhi in the above cited case held that the need , rendition and benefit test for services availed by the assessee from associated enterprises should be applied having regard to the assessee’s business and not in a generic manner. TPO should have given due thought to the requirements ,benefits and manner of rendition of servic...

Read More

Revenue sharing arrangements are liable to service tax: AAR

In Re M/s Choice Estates and Constructions Ltd (Authority for Advance Rulings)

AAR held that a revenue sharing arrangement by creating a partnering person shall be liable to service tax if the partners are providing taxable service to one another in execution of partnering purpose even if the purpose of creating partnering person is non-taxable. ...

Read More

AMP expenditure without agreement with AE is not an international transaction

Loreal India P. Ltd. vs. DCIT (ITAT Mumbai)

The ITAT Mumbai in the above cited case held that Advertising, Promotion and Marketing expenses (AMP) cannot be considered as international transaction unless there exist an agreement between the assessee and its AE to share/reimburse the AMP expenditure incurred by the assessee in India....

Read More

HC not to admit writ petition if assessee already participated in reassessment proceedings

M/s. Amaya Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. vs. Income Tax Officer (Bombay High Court)

HC held that when assessee participated in reassessment proceedings by furnishing the required documents and challenges the reopening subsequently before the high court by filing a writ petition then it would be not be appropriate for the high court to exercise its exclusive jurisdiction because the assessee has already chosen AO to exe...

Read More

All surrounding circumstances to a transaction is to be examined by AO in deciding genuineness of a claim

M/s. Maruti Impex vs JCIT (ITAT Mumbai)

The ITAT Mumbai in the above cited case held that the surrounding circumstances and human probabilities attached to a transaction should be examined by considering the transactions as a whole. Therefore, AO cannot decide the geniuses only finding some unusual things but also bound to examine the things which are indicating that the claim...

Read More