CA Satish Sarda

CA Satish SardaWe can blame it on abbreviation , but TDS ( Tax Deducted at Source ) rhymes with TEDIOUS, as if reflecting the plight of Tax Payers and Tax practitioners.

This is the most convenient way of collecting Income Tax by creating legal obligation on person making certain payments. Tax Payers has not only to bear the compliance cost , but has to remain update about ever changing provisions also. And any failure in doing this honorary job may invite interest, penalty, prosecution (STICKS). This is very much against the basic principles that if Tax Payers are giving their services free of cost to the Government they should be treated reasonably and fairly. In fact they should be rewarded by giving proper recognition and respect (CARROTS).

carrotstick

Image courtesy of Stuart Miles at FreeDigitalPhotos.net

let us understand the basic provision relating to TDS:

Who has to deduct and deposit TDS:

A) Any person paying any amount in nature of Salary, Interest on Securities, Dividend, Winnings from lottery ,Crossword, Horse races, Insurance Commission, Commission /Remuneration on sale of lottery tickets ,Transfer of Immovable Property will have to deduct TDS.

B) Any person other than Individual and HUF who are not subject to tax audit in preceding financial year paying Interest, Contractors, Commission or Brokerage, Rent, Professional /Technical service fees will have to deduct TDS.

In both the cases liability to TDS will arise subject to applicable threshold limit .

Threshold limit and applicable rates can be ascertained from Income Tax Website.

In which cases tax has to be collected at source( TCS).

1) A ‘’Seller’’ shall collect tax from the ‘’Buyer’’ in following cases:

Sale of Alcoholic liquor for human consumption, Indian made foreign liquor, Tendu Leaves, Timber ,any other forest produce, Scrap, Minerals being coal or lignite or iron ore.

2) A person who grants a lease or a license or enters into a contract or otherwise ,transfers any right or interest in any parking lot or toll plaza or mine or quarry , to another person for the use of such parking lot or toll plaza or mine or quarry, for the purpose of business , shall collect tax at source.

3) In case of sale of jewellery/bullion w.e.f.1st July 2012. (if sale consideration of bullion exceeds Rs.200000 or Jewellery Rs.500000.or Out of sale consideration any amount is received in cash.)

When to deduct and deposit :

Within 7 days from the end of the month in which income/any sum paid or credited whichever is earlier. If payee’s account is credited in last month of accounting year i.e. March, then on or before 30th April.

What are the other compliances under TDS provision:

The person responsible to deduct or collect tax has to obtain the TAN (Tax Deduction and Collection Account Number) In form No.49B.

Quarterly statements in Form No.24Q (Salary),26Q (Non Salary), 27Q (payment to Non-resident ) and 27EQ (TCS) have to be filed within due dates.( e-filing compulsory )

The Person has to issue TDS/TCS Certificates within time in Form No.16(Salary),16A(Non Salary),and 27D (TCS).

What are the consequences if TDS/TCS provisions are not complied :

Person will be :

Treated as Assessee in default for not deducting or not depositing after deduction.

Liable to interest for non-depositing of tax or late payment of tax

Liable for payment of late fess of Rs.200 per day maximum up to amount of TDS for late submission of quarterly TDS statements.(for example a delay of 3 months will result into a late fee of Rs.18000)

Liable for Penalty for delay in payment, non deduction, late or non issue of TDS Certificate, late filing of TDS statements etc.

Liable to prosecution if fails to pay tax after deduction.

And last but not the least if TDS not deducted expenses may be disallowed. For example if you have made a payment of Rs.500000/- to a contractor without deducting the TDS of 1% i.e.Rs.5000/-only , the whole expenditure of Rs.500000 may be disallowed. ( which may increase your tax liability by Rs.150000 ).

Relaxation given w.e.f Ist July 2012 : The payer shall not be deemed to be an assessee in default if the resident recipient has included such income in his Income tax return . Also the payer will have to submit a certificate in Form No.26A to this effect from a Chartered Accountant.

Non deduction or deduction at lower rate of TDS: A Person other than a company or Firm may give a declaration in Form15G/15H for non deduction of TDS.( on Interest/Dividend). Also a recipient of income may apply in Form no.13 to assessing officer for lower rate of TDS.

So it can be seen that Person who are liable to TDS are expected to be vigilant at all time. Income Tax department is very actively and vigorously enforcing the compliance of these provisions by way of notices, demands, scrutiny, Surveys, Raids etc. This is resulting into huge demands towards tax ,Interest ,Penalties and even prosecution.

To conclude we can say if you comply properly Government gives you ‘Anda’ ( means nothing ) , and if you don’t you get ‘ Danda ‘ ( Penalties ). Choice is yours…!!!!

We hope after Delhi Results Hon Finance Minister will understand the value of Tax Payer’s vote also. People have voted this government in anticipation of ‘’Achhe Din ‘’. So let us see whether we get some respite from draconian and harsh provisions in taxation system in forthcoming Budget.

Disclaimer: TDS provisions have been discussed in brief only. Please refer to Income tax Act and Rules for correct and detail understanding.

(Author is a  Past Chairman-Nagpur Branch Of ICAI)

Read Other Articles of CA Satish Sarda

More Under Income Tax

Posted Under

Category : Income Tax (26750)
Type : Articles (16240) Featured (4128)
Tags : CA Satish Sarda (18) TDS (978) TDS Provisions (17)

0 responses to “TDS Under Income Tax: Tedious Job With No Carrots Only Sticks..!!!”

  1. CA Ankur Agrawal says:

    We can avoid 234E demand by some tax planning. If you have some notice of tds which include 234E demand, then you ca clear that demand by making some alterations in return, for better clarification you can contact me at ca.ankur30@gmail.com

  2. m. f. haque says:

    i fully support the views expressed by mr.senthil and mr. aravindan.

  3. G S Krishnan says:

    Once TDS is deducted and paid to the credit of PAN of the deductee, there is no need of filing TDS return. It was once suggested to do away with issuing TDS certificates by the deductor. Due to IT advancement in all area, the headache of filing TDS return can be removed. In case of sale of property exceeding Rs.50 lakhs, the purchaser has to deduct TDS @ 1% on the sale consideration but no return need to be filed.

  4. Tanmoy says:

    I have selected wrong Financial year while filling form26QB, Now form16B is available for download.How can I get financial year / Assessment year get corrected in these forms ?please advise.

  5. A.Senthil says:

    CA Sathish Sarda sir, your point of view is perfect. In this situation I want to share my view also. TDS is deducted for the help of Government and ETDS work and Charges are bourned by the Deductor for this ETDS work. So the ultimate beneficiaries are, the Central Govt and Deductees. If Penalty u/s 234E imposed on the default by the deductor, he further suffered. So Incometax Department must see this fact and kindly remove or postpone the penalty u/s 234E and first properly inform and educate the Deductors in this regard. Because TDS Money properly deposited to the central govt, and only ETDS returns are delayed. Further there is acceptable shortage in ETDS return preparers and filers also. This is because of low income and high tension work on ETDS. All are causes for delay in ETDS filing. So deductors strongly oppose penalty u/s 234E and Department must reconsider their penalty u/s 234E and may postpone the same. In the same time the Deductors must understand the problems of No-filing of ETDS returns. Because there must be a acceptable rule to file the ETDS returns. Deductors must realize their important part of work in this regard and must take due care to file ETDS in time. Particularly the Government Deductors must give due attention in this regard. If this TDS provisions goes like this way all are will hesitate to deduct TDS and they may deduct and pay in the year end.

  6. P Aravindhan says:

    Can we not provide certain specific suggestions on TDS administration such as
    a] Waiver of 234E at least till FY2014-15
    b] ETDS returns filing charges to NSDL should be waived
    c] Computation of interest, penalty, fee etc to be waived during downtime of TRACES/fixing of bugs and glitches by TRACES
    d] More powers to jurisdictional ITO [TDS] for rectification in TRACES- Better training of ITO TDS in TRACES
    e] An advisory Committee for TRACES drawn from various streams, so that TRACES would operate in a transparent manner duly considering the bonafide interests of Deductors also.

    CBDT being more citizen friendly, something may happen, if we make out a proper proposal. ICAI can also take initiative.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *