DCIT Vs Jagathrakshakan Srinisha (ITAT Chennai)
CIT(A)’s Jewellery Reconciliation Upheld—Unexplained Investment u/s 69 Deleted Except ₹72.45 Lakh Treated as Business Income; Section 115BBE & 270A Penalty Also Cancelled
In this case, Revenue challenged the detailed & fact-based relief granted by CIT(A) in respect of additions made during search proceedings, where AO had treated jewellery valued at ₹14.60 crore as unexplained investment in the hands of Assessee, Ms. Jagathrakshakan Srinisha. The jewellery had been found not in her premises but in the premises of her parents & of one Mr. Selvakumar; nevertheless, AO presumed ownership & made a sweeping addition u/s 69.
CIT(A), after a meticulous reconciliation of the jewellery seized & by examining panchanamas, family members’ assessments, valuation reports & past disclosures, concluded that substantial portions belonged to other family members—₹5.92 crore belonged to her parents & ₹1 crore to her brother & sister-in-law—whose assessments had already taken those assets into account. CIT(A) further accepted the Assessee’s explanation that 1,875 grams of jewellery valued at ₹52.50 lakh represented VDIS-declared assets, noting that exact item-wise identity need not match after decades of remodelling. In addition, gifts aggregating 8,663.30 grams from Assessee’s mother to her daughters were accepted as genuine & already supported by the mother’s assessment records, leaving no basis for taxing them again. CIT(A) also telescoped ₹4 crore out of Assessee’s total drawings of ₹4.52 crore over earlier assessment years, reasonably accepting that these withdrawals explained the source of investment in jewellery & that AO had not shown that any of the jewellery had actually been purchased in the year of search. Only an amount of ₹72.45 lakh was sustained, not as unexplained investment, but only as unaccounted business income.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.




