Huntsman Investment [Netherlands] BV Vs ADIT (ITAT Delhi)
Why This Case Matters
The question at the heart of this judgment is deceptively simple: when an Indian subsidiary buys back shares from its Dutch parent company, do the resulting capital gains stay taxable in India — or does the India–Netherlands tax treaty return exclusive taxing rights to the Netherlands?
The answer turned out to be complex enough to divide a bench, trigger a Third Member reference under Section 255(4) of the Income Tax Act, and generate three distinct judicial opinions before a final 2:1 majority emerged in favour of the assessee.
At the centre of the case is one phrase: ‘corporate organisation, reorganisation, amalgamation, division or similar transaction’ — as it appears in the second proviso to Article 13(5) of the India–Netherlands DTAA. That phrase is the gateway to a provision that protects intra-group share transfers from source-state taxation. The question is whether a partial buy-back of 24% of an Indian subsidiary’s shares by its Dutch parent qualifies as such a transaction.
The case is also procedurally significant. It demonstrates the Section 255(4) Third Member mechanism in operation; shows how dictionary selection, parallel treaty analysis, and professional guidance from the ICAI can tip a finely balanced legal question; and draws a clean line between an ‘exit’ transaction (which does not qualify) and a ‘continuity’ transaction (which does).
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.




