Introduction
India’s wage regime has undergone a significant transformation over the years, from a fragmented set of laws to a more unified framework. The old wage laws, each addressing different sectors and aspects of wage protection, were effective but often led to confusion and gaps in enforcement. The introduction of the Code on Wages, 2019 was a much-needed reform, aiming to simplify and streamline wage regulations for workers across the country. This blog delves into the evolution of wage protections in India, comparing the old law with the Code on Wages, 2019, to highlight the advancements and challenges that remain.
The Old Wage Laws: Fragmented Yet Protective
Before the advent of the Code on Wages, India’s wage protections were governed by multiple statutes, each addressing specific types of employment or worker groups. The key laws included:
1. The Payment of Wages Act, 1936: This Act focused on ensuring the timely payment of wages to workers in factories, mines, railways, and government establishments. However, its coverage was limited to specific sectors, leaving out large portions of the workforce.
2. The Minimum Wages Act, 1948: This Act allowed state governments to set minimum wages for workers in scheduled employments. While it aimed to guarantee a basic standard of living for workers, the process was often slow, and the wages set were sometimes below subsistence levels.
3. The Equal Remuneration Act, 1976: This legislation prohibited gender-based wage discrimination. It aimed to ensure that men and women received equal pay for equal work, but its implementation faced challenges, particularly in the informal sector.
4. The Payment of Bonus Act, 1965: The Act mandated the payment of an annual bonus to workers in establishments with 20 or more employees. However, the bonus amount was limited to a maximum of 20% of the annual wage, leaving many workers with minimal benefits.
The Code on Wages, 2019: A Unified Approach
In 2019, the Indian government took a significant step towards modernizing the country’s wage laws by introducing the Code on Wages, 2019. This single, unified code replaced the four major wage-related Acts, bringing about several key changes:
1. Wider Coverage and Simplified Definitions
The Code on Wages, 2019 extends its coverage to all workers employed in any establishment, including both formal and informal sectors, with some exceptions based on income levels (workers earning up to ₹24,000 per month are covered, with flexibility for higher-income workers if specified by the government). The Code establishes a more comprehensive and inclusive framework by eliminating the sector-specific focus seen in the old laws.
One of the most notable changes is the harmonization of the definition of “wages”. The Code defines wages broadly, including all elements such as basic pay, dearness allowance, and retaining allowance, but excluding bonuses, overtime, and travel allowances. This unified definition simplifies the calculation of wages and minimizes the potential for disputes over what constitutes “wages.”
2. Minimum Wage and National Floor Wage
Under the previous system, minimum wages were set at the state level, often varying widely between regions. The Code on Wages establishes a national floor wage, which is a baseline wage level set by the central government. States are required to fix minimum wages for various sectors but cannot set wages below the national floor. This move aims to address disparities in wage levels between different states, ensuring that workers across India receive a minimum standard of pay.
Moreover, the Code mandates that minimum wages be reviewed every five years, ensuring that wage rates are periodically updated in line with inflation and changing living costs.
3. Timely Payment of Wages and Deductions
The Code also streamlines the timelines for the payment of wages. The old laws had different payment deadlines depending on the type of establishment. The Code standardizes this, requiring that workers in factories and mines be paid by the seventh day of the following month, while workers in other establishments have up to the tenth day.
Additionally, the Code specifies permissible deductions from wages, ensuring that workers’ take-home pay is not unduly reduced by arbitrary or excessive deductions. This protects workers from unfair wage practices and provides clearer guidance for employers.
4. Equal Remuneration and Gender Equality
The Equal Remuneration Act of 1976, which aimed to eliminate gender-based wage discrimination, is subsumed within the Code on Wages. While the spirit of the law remains intact, the Code strengthens enforcement by integrating gender equality provisions across all employment sectors. This unification helps prevent disparities in pay between men and women performing the same work, making it easier for employers to adhere to non-discriminatory pay practices.
5. Simplified Enforcement and Dispute Resolution
The enforcement mechanism under the Code on Wages is more streamlined compared to the old system. The Inspector-cum-Facilitator, a new role created under the Code, is tasked with ensuring compliance across all wage-related laws. This simplifies the process for both workers and employers, as there is now a single authority responsible for overseeing wage payments and addressing violations.
Additionally, the Code provides a unified process for dispute resolution, allowing workers to approach district-level authorities or labor courts in case of non-compliance or wage disputes.
Challenges and Areas for Improvement
While the Code on Wages, 2019 brings significant improvements, it is not without challenges. Some of the main issues that need attention include:
1. Exclusion of Higher-Earning Workers
The Code excludes workers earning more than ₹24,000 per month from automatic coverage under its provisions, which means that those earning above this threshold do not benefit from the same wage protections unless specifically extended by the government. This creates a two-tier system that might leave high-income workers vulnerable to exploitation in the absence of robust regulations.
2. Implementation Delays
Although the Code provides a national framework, its implementation is largely dependent on state governments. Some states have been slow to adopt the Code’s provisions, particularly in terms of fixing minimum wage rates that align with the national floor wage or enforcing electronic filing requirements for wage records.
3. Awareness and Compliance
Many informal sector workers are unaware of their rights under the new Code, and smaller employers often lack the resources to ensure full compliance. This gap in awareness and capacity means that, while the Code offers broader protections, its impact may be limited unless efforts are made to educate both workers and employers.
Conclusion: A Step Forward, but Not the Final Solution
The Code on Wages, 2019 represents a significant leap forward in terms of wage regulation in India. By consolidating multiple laws into a single framework, it simplifies wage protections, enhances transparency, and provides a more inclusive approach to wage regulation. However, challenges remain, particularly in terms of enforcement, coverage for higher earners, and ensuring that informal sector workers benefit from the Code’s protections.
Ultimately, the success of the Code will depend on its implementation at the state level, regular updates to wage rates, and continued efforts to raise awareness about workers’ rights. If these challenges are addressed, the Code on Wages could usher in a new era of fairer wage practices for millions of workers in India.
Author Bio
