Ambrosia Realty Vs ITO (ITAT Ahmedabad)
Project Completion Method Accepted- Addition on Suppression of Profit Deleted- ITAT Ahmedabad; Ahmedabad ITAT considered dispute regarding revenue recognition method in real estate transactions.
Assessee, a partnership firm engaged in real estate development, was executing project “Earth Ambrosia”. It followed Project Completion Method (PCM) & disclosed profit of ₹1.08 crore. AO, however, held that revenue recognition ought to be on Percentage Completion Method (POCM) basis as per ICAI’s 2012 Guidance Note, working out revenue of ₹3.32 crore. The difference of ₹2.24 crore was added as suppressed profit. CIT(A) confirmed the addition.
Assessee’s Stand:
- PCM was consistently followed & had been accepted in earlier scrutiny assessment.
- As per AS-9 (Revenue Recognition), income should be recognized only when significant risks & rewards of ownership are transferred – in this case, on execution of sale deed or handing over of possession.
- Guidance Note itself clarifies that PCM is correct where risks & rewards are not transferred at booking stage.
- Buyers could cancel bookings at any time without penalty & consideration was negotiable, hence no transfer of risks & rewards initially.
- Revenue already offered in subsequent years; applying POCM in impugned year would result in double taxation.
Tribunal examined ICAI’s Guidance Note in detail & observed:
- Real estate revenue recognition is governed by AS-9 unless project is in substance a construction contract, in which case AS-7 & POCM apply.
- Transfer of risks & rewards is to be determined by terms of agreement, not merely by existence of booking contracts.
- POCM applies only when project outcome can be reasonably estimated and when agreement indicates transfer of risks & rewards at inception.
- In present case, Revenue failed to show that agreements transferred risks & rewards at booking stage. AO simply relied on parameters like 25% cost incurred, 25% project area sold & 10% collection received – which merely indicate certainty but not transfer of risks.
- Hence, PCM followed by Assessee was valid & justified.
Tribunal held that addition of ₹2.24 crore was unsustainable & directed deletion of the same.Tribunal allowed appeal of Assessee, holding that PCM was the correct method of revenue recognition for the project as risks & rewards were transferred only at the stage of sale deed/possession & addition on basis of POCM was unjustified
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.






