In re Uwas Recycler LLP (CAAR Mumbai)
CAAR held that goods ‘mill processed non-alloy ferrous waste metal goods wound in coil’ does not appear to be waste or scrap, and therefore, not classifiable under sub heading 72044900. These goods merit classification under subheading 72099000.
FULL TEXT OF THE ORDER OF CUSTOMS AUTHORITY FOR ADVANCE RULING, MUMBAI
M/s Uwas Recycler LLP filed an application on 14.06.2021, seeking an advance ruling for the classification of mill processed non-alloy ferrous waste metal goods wound in a coil.
2. The applicant is a limited liability partnership company primarily engaged as a merchant importer. The applicant intends to import mill processed non-alloy ferrous waste metal goods wound in coil from South Africa. The applicant has elaborated on the origin of the goods and their characteristics as follows:-
The said goods are re-rollable waste and are obtained as a result of the manufacturing of cold-rolled coils from hot-rolled coils. In a single stand cold rolling mill manufacturing, a hot-rolled coil is wound onto the entry reel and allowed to pass between 4HI or 6HI steel rolls for desired thickness. The hydraulic force is gradually applied so that the immediate application of the required force does not break the coil instantly. In such cases, some length of coil remains devoid of desired thickness because of limited application force and is therefore neither a hot-rolled nor a cold-rolled coil, having a non-uniform thickness at indefinite intervals. Such a coil has variable tensile strength and elongation properties. These coils are thus generated at an initial stage, and are cut at ends and wound in coil form, which is nothing but mill waste and do not serve the purpose for which they are meant. These coils thus so obtained, are used by unorganized steel manufacturers to re-roll them to get the desired configuration. The waste so generated have the following characteristics: a) non-uniform gauges at indefinite intervals. b) weight of the coils ranges from 200-800 Kgs, c) length of the coils varies from 15 to 20 meters, d) the product obtained is neither hot-rolled nor cold-rolled as tensile strength and elongation are different in the same coil. The applicant has submitted a test report of a certified and accredited lab that carried out a detailed inspection of the samples provided by the applicant and elaborated the specific parameters. It is further stated that such goods do not satisfy parameters for cold-rolled coil as prescribed under IS-513:2008. Thus, it is neither a hot-rolled coil nor a cold-rolled coil. Section note 8(a) (ii) of Section XV describes waste and scrap as metal goods definitely not usable as such because of breakage, cutting-up, wear or other reasons. The product satisfies the above definition owing to its non-uniform thickness at indefinite intervals, its tensile strength and elongation. The impugned product is a re-rollable scrap and is classifiable under tariff 72044900 as other waste and as per notification no. 02/2021-Customs, the basic customs duty on this product is 2.5%.
3. The applicant has further stated that this product is not a prime product and is used only by secondary steel manufacturers who in turn re-roll this waste in the desired configuration. The chartered engineer certificate to this end is also submitted. The chartered engineer visited one of the units of unorganised steel manufacturer of steel hinges. The chartered engineer has explained the re-rolling process undertaken at the said unit as follows:-
The manufacturing process of steel hinges requires a uniform cut length of steel strips, which are obtained from strips of non-uniform thickness. These non-uniform strips are cut from re-rollable steel coil of non-uniform thickness at different intervals. The desired thickness is achieved by passing the cut strips between rolls with a continuous flow of water-soluble oil.
4. In the CAAR – I form, the applicant has declared that they would import under the jurisdiction of the Principal Commissioner/ Commissioner of Customs, Indore.
Accordingly, their application was forwarded to the jurisdictional customs authorities for comments. The comments received are summarised as follows:-
The imported mill processed non-alloy ferrous waste will be further sold to unorganized steel manufacturers for re-rolling. The applicant seeks classification of the proposed import product under tariff heading 7204 of the Customs Tariff Act, 1975. The classification sought by the applicant for “mill processed non-alloy ferrous waste metals goods wound in coil” falls under Section XV which covers “Base metals and articles of base metals”. The description of the particular heading, i.e., 7204 is “Ferrous waste and scrap; remelting scrap ingots of iron or steel”. 72044900 is the subheading for “Other waste and scrap”. The justification for classifying the product under the said heading is that it is a re-rollable waste and arising out of the process of converting hot-rolled coil into cold-rolled coil. The hot-rolled coil is passed through a hydraulic press to change into desired/reduced thickness by gradually applying hydraulic force until the desired thickness is achieved/ received. Since the force is applied gradually which results in different thicknesses of output at different intervals until the desired thickness is achieved/ received and once the desired thickness is derived the coil length up to that stage is cut down and separated. The remaining cut coil has non-uniform gauges, different lengths, weight, thickness and can’t be used as prime material. Unorganized steel sector manufacturers use this uneven coil for sundry items and uniform thickness is achieved by re-rolling it again. Hence, this waste coil is classified as “re-rollable waste”. This waste comes in coil form for easy handling. It can’t be classified as a remelting scrap which attracts nil duty since the changes introduced in the Finance Bill, 2021 and it is used for re-rolling by unorganized sector and attracts 2.5% duty. As regards the further uses of the re-rollable waste coil a chartered engineer certificate is enclosed by the applicant which is self-explanatory. Further as per para 13.3 of IS 2549:1994 (Code for classification of processed ferrous scrap), which reads as, “It shall consist of crop and (front and back end cutting) of semi-finished or fmished products suitable for re-rolling of maximum and minimum sizes agreed upon between buyer and sellers”. Accordingly, goods to be imported are classifiable under heading 72.04.
5. The application was heard on 05.08.2021 in virtual mode. No one appeared on behalf of the Principal Commissioner/Commissioner of Customs, Indore. The applicant was represented by Shri Sunil Deshpande, authorised representative, who has taken me through their application. The end cuttings which would be imported by the applicant are wound on a coil. The length of such sheet doesn’t exceed 10-15 metres. He also clarified that the sheet is of variable thickness, but do not exceed 3mm He also explained that the test report submitted along with the CAAR-I application by the applicant is not of the consignment to be imported, but of the material already available in their warehouse.
6. The applicant vide letter dated 09.08.2021 made additional submissions. It was informed that UWAS RECYCLERS LLP has been allotted PAN no. AAGFU9198K and import-export code AAGFU9198K. The quotation of Paragon Steel Supplies Co.Ltd. appended with the CAAR-I form was to prove genuineness and to get clarification on tariff classification, and it is just for the illustration purpose. They intend to import said product from different countries regularly depending upon market situation and competitive prices. The applicant clarified that goods to be imported will be a re-rollable waste having a non-uniform thickness at indefinite intervals and weight varying from 200-800 kg. They prefer to import the above-mentioned goods over local purchases because of easier norms and procedures of supplier companies for compliance and competitive pricing. The lab report appended with the CAAR-I foiiii was of Choksi Laboratories Limited to get technical specifications of the goods to be imported.
7. The applicant was requested to clarify the following vide email dated 10.08.2021. The following reply was received on 17.08.2021:-
Q1. What is the composition of the product? Whether it is ferrous, iron, non-alloy steel, stainless steel or any other alloy steel?
A: Our product is namely mill processed non-alloy ferrous waste wound in Coil.
Q2. Whether imported are goods cold-rolled or hot-rolled? Is any further work carried out on the rolled product?
A: The product to be imported by us for which advance ruling is applied is neither a cold-rolled nor a hot-rolled. This waste gets generated in the process of manufacturing of cold-rolled coil from hot-rolled coil. The portion of the coil that does not become a fmal product because of not being properly rolled (because of non-uniform force) is generated at both ends of the main coil (fmal product). This portion is being cut/ separated and disposed of as a re-rollable waste as it is.
Q3. Whether all the goods imported in the form of the coil?
A: Yes, generally re-rollable waste that gets generated at the time of cold rolling in the cold rolling mill is in a form of small coils. Companies dispose of this material “as and where basis”.
Q4. What are the physical parameters of the goods – width, thickness and length?
A: The above re-rollable waste which is proposed to be imported by us namely mill processed non-alloy ferrous waste wound in the coil has the following physical parameters:-
Thickness- Our product does not contain any specific thickness and thus a particular thickness cannot be specified. Our product contains numerous thicknesses ranging from 0.30 mm to 4mm in each and every coil to be imported.
Width- each and every coil has a different width which may range from 900mm to 1400mm.
Length- The average weight varies from 200 to 800 kgs. Correspondingly, average length varies from 10 to 20 meters.
Q5. What is the Carbon content by weight?
A: The carbon content of our product to be imported varies from 0.04-0.30%.
Q6. Whether imported goods are clad, coated or plated? If yes, then with which metal/element?
A: The above re-rollable waste which is to be imported by us has no cladding or plating.
8. I have considered all the materials placed before me for the subject product. I have gone through the submissions made by the applicant during the personal hearing and reply received from the jurisdictional Principal Commissioner/ Commissioner. The goods for which advance ruling is sought are mill processed non-alloy ferrous and cuttings wound in a coil. The applicant has given an explanation for the origin of such waste as a gradual application of force during cold rolling of a hot-rolled coil. Hot rolling means rolling at a temperature between the point of rapid recrystallisation and that of the beginning of fusion. The temperature range depends on various factors such as the composition of the metal/alloy. Generally, the final temperature achieved in hot rolling is about 900 °C. Cold rolling, on the other hand, is carried out over hot-rolled strip/sheet at ambient temperatures, i.e., below the recrystallisation temperature. Hot rolling and cold rolling are mechanical processes involved in the production of flat products.
9. Applying General Rule of Interpretation 1 “…. for legal purposes, classification shall be determined according to the terms of the headings and any relative Section or Chapter Notes and, provided such headings or Notes do not otherwise require…”. In the HSN classification system, section XV covers the base metals and articles of base metal, and chapter 72 pertains to goods of iron and steel. Chapter note 1(k) of Chapter 72 assigns the following expression to flat-rolled products- “Rolled products of solid rectangular (other than square) cross-section, which do not conform to the definition at (if) above in the form of
