Bhavani Iyer Vs ITO (ITAT Mumbai)
ITAT Mumbai Accepts Audited Books, Restores Profit at 68.19% of Professional Receipts & Upholds Deletion of ₹2.5 Cr Investment Addition; Penalty u/s 271(1)(c) Remanded
Assessee, a scriptwriter with regular tax compliance history, faced a reopening u/s 147 on two grounds— (i) alleged unexplained investment of ₹2.50 crore in a Versova flat, & (ii) professional receipts of ₹1.09 crore treated as income without allowing any expenses due to ex-parte assessment.
Before CIT(A), additional evidence was admitted & a remand report obtained. CIT(A) deleted the ₹2.50 crore addition but estimated expenses at 40%, effectively taxing 85.30% of gross receipts. Both parties went in appeal.
1. Professional Income – Assessee Succeeds
ITAT noted that:
- Assessee maintained proper books, audited u/s 44AB.
- Profit as per books was ₹74,33,640 on receipts of ₹1.09 crore – 68.19% margin.
- Assessee had suo-moto disallowed ₹15,44,465 as personal expenses.
- AO’s remand report did not dispute the expenses.
- CIT(A) neither rejected the books nor gave any basis for estimating 40% expenses.
ITAT held that where books are not rejected, profits declared must be accepted. It restored the income at 68.19% of gross receipts & deleted CIT(A)’s arbitrary enhancement.
2. ₹2.50 Crore ‘Unexplained Investment’ – Revenue Fails
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.




