JCIT Vs ACP Tollways Private Limited (ITAT Lucknow)
ITAT Quashes PCIT Order for Violating Natural Justice by Withholding Evidence; Genuine Purchases Ignored: ITAT Voids PCIT’s Revision for Misuse of Powers; PCIT’s 263 Order Quashed for Withholding Adverse Material & Ignoring Evidence on Genuine Purchases
In this case, assessment u/s 143(3) r.w.s. 144B was completed for A.Y. 2020-21 & a minor disallowance of Health & Education Cess was made. Later, PCIT invoked revisionary jurisdiction u/s 263 alleging that Assessee purchased iron ore fines of ₹3.94 crore from M/s B B Medicare Pvt. Ltd., which was allegedly a “shell company” as per a SEBI list & did not possess a valid licence for trading iron ore. PCIT concluded that AO failed to make proper enquiry & set aside the assessment.
Assessee strongly objected, arguing:
- All purchase details, bills, bank statements, transit passes, quantitative records, MCA master data & licence details were furnished both before AO & PCIT.
- PCIT relied on external information (SEBI list, licence suspension data, MCA website, location details, etc.) but never provided this material to the Assessee for rebuttal despite specific request.
- CIT wrongly assumed the company was from Kolkata whereas MCA records showed it was in Odisha.
- Assessee produced evidence that licence was valid during relevant period (06.08.2018 – 05.08.2023), contrary to PCIT’s observation of suspension.
- AO had examined purchases, accepted books, quantitative records & sales. No defect was found.
Tribunal observed:
- PCIT used external information behind Assessee’s back, violating principles of natural justice & doctrine of audi alteram partem.
- PCIT did not confront Assessee with alleged adverse material & did not consider evidences already filed.
- Reliance placed on SC in Amitabh Bachchan & Chhattisgarh High Court in Sun & Sun Inframetric (2024) 460 ITR 258 holding that any material used against Assessee must be shared, otherwise 263 fails.
- Even on merits, Assessee’s evidences (payments, invoices, transportation, licence validity) were ignored.
- PCIT’s conclusion was based only on presumption & external data, not proper enquiry.
Therefore, Tribunal held that 263 order suffered from violation of natural justice & misuse of powers, & quashed the revisionary order in entirety. Thus, the appeal of the Assessee was allowed, & the 263 order was set aside as bad in law.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.

