ACIT Vs Parul Diamond (ITAT Mumbai)
Bogus Purchase Saga Ends With 6% GP — Once Sales Accepted, Only Profit Element Taxable -ITAT Mumbai Rejects 100% Disallowance
Revenue challenged restriction of addition to 6% of alleged bogus purchases of Rs. 6,66,602 from Mohit Enterprises, stated to be a Bhawarlal Jain accommodation entry concern, while Assessee (a diamond trader) filed CO seeking full deletion and attacking reopening u/s 148.
Assessee had filed purchase bills, sales register, stock book, bank statements, export realisation certificates, confirmation from supplier, and an affidavit of proprietor of Mohit Enterprises. AO however disallowed 100% purchases relying on Investigation Wing findings that the supplier was a shell entity of Jain group.
CIT(A) held purchases to be non-genuine but followed Sai Diamond (sister concern in same line of business) and restricted addition to 6% GP, as sales were accepted and no contrary material was brought by AO.
ITAT noted that—
- AO had issued s.133(6) notice & supplier confirmed purchases.
- When sales are accepted & basic evidences exist, entire disallowance is unjustified.
- Consistency with Sai Diamond warranted 6% addition only.
Accordingly, both Revenue’s appeal & Assessee’s cross-objection were dismissed, thereby sustaining GP addition of only Rs. 39,996 and rejecting plea for 100% disallowance as well as CO claims.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.






