Veena Chaturvedi Vs DCIT (ITAT Mumbai)
ITAT Mumbai held that addition under section 69C of the Income Tax Act treating share transactions as bogus merely on the basis of statement of the broker is unsustainable and bad-in-law.
Facts- Vide the present appeal, the assessee has challenged; firstly, validity of reopening u/s. 147, secondly, addition of Rs.8,29,88,876/- made u/s.68 of the Act disallowing the claim of long term capital gain claimed as exempt by treating the amount received on sale of shares of M/s. Shreenath Commercial & Finance Ltd. as bogus and non-genuine; and lastly, addition of Rs.41,49,444/- on account of alleged unexplained expenditure in the form of commission for taking such bogus accommodation entry.
Conclusion- Held that where the transactions have been made both purchases and sales online and there was no adverse material or information except with some brokers stated in their statement that they have provided accommodation entry in various scrips in one such scrip involved, that does not lead to drawing any adverse inference to treat the share transactions as bogus done through stock exchange.
Once on the same set of facts the Co-ordinate Bench have deleted the said addition, then in the case of the assessee, no different view can be taken. Respectfully following the same, the addition made by the Assessing Officer was deleted including the addition of the alleged commission made under Section 69C of the Income Tax Act was deleted. Thus, the appeal of the assessee was allowed.
FULL TEXT OF THE ORDER OF ITAT MUMBAI
The aforesaid appeal has been filed by the assessee against impugned order dated 19/07/2021 passed by PCIT-Appeals 48, Mumbai for the quantum of assessment passed u/s. 143(3) r.w.s. 147.
2. In various grounds of appeal assessee has challenged; firstly, validity of reopening u/s. 147, secondly, addition of Rs.8,29,88,876/- made u/s.68 of the Act disallowing the claim of long term capital gain claimed as exempt by treating the amount received on sale of shares of M/s. Shreenath Commercial & Finance Ltd. as bogus and non-genuine; and lastly, addition of Rs.41,49,444/- on account of alleged unexplained expenditure in the form of commission for taking such bogus accommodation entry.
3. The brief facts and background of the case are that, the assessee is an individual and promoter of Shreepati Group Builders and Developers, who had filed her return of income for Y. 2013-14 at Rs.63,51,310/- on 28/03/2015. Later on assessee’s case was reopened u/s. 147 by issuance of notice u/s. 148 dated 19/10/2016, on the ground that information has been received from Directorate of Investigation Wing of Kolkata that assessee availed LTCG by showing investment in penny stock company in the scrip of M/s. Shreenath Commercial & Finance Ltd. which was claimed as exempt by the assessee u/s. 10(38) amounting to Rs. 7,28,88,736/-. The relevant ‘reasons’ incorporated in the assessment order reads as under:-
“An information has been received from the Directorate of Investigation that an organized racket of generating bogus entries of LTCG in penny stock have been unearthed as a result of investigation carried out throughout the country. As a result of this investigation, 64811 beneficiaries who have taken bogus entries of LTCG amounting to Rs 38,000 crores have been identified. Smt. Veena Chaturvedi having PAN ADCPC8995K who is assessed in this circle has also availed of such an entry of Rs 8,29,88,876/ The same is reflected in the return of Income for AY 2013-1 4 by way of claim of exemption amounting to Rs. 7,28,88,736/-under section 10(38) of the Income Tax Act, 1961.
The Directorate of Investigation has made available various confessional statements of entities involved in the transactions for generating such bogus claims of LTCG. After appraisal of these tangible material on record, there is enough reason to believe that not only the claim of exemption under section 10(38) by the assessee is prima facie bogus but by making such bogus claim, the assessee has clearly failed to disclose all material facts for determination of income.
In view of the above facts, I have reason to believe that income chargeable to tax of Rs. 7,28,88,736/- has escaped assessment for A.Y. 2013-14 by reason of the failure on the part of the assessee to furnish the correct particulars of facts necessary for assessment within the meaning of section u/s 147 of the IT Act, 1961. The case is therefore required to be reopened u/s. 147 and notice u/s. 148 of the IT Act may be issued accordingly. The notice is being issued after seeking approval for re-opening from the Addl. CIT-Central, Range-2 Mumbai.”
4. In response to the notice, assessee stated that return filed earlier u/s. 139 should be treated as return filed in response to show-cause notice u/s. 148 and after receiving the reasons, assessee has raised objections for the reopening before the ld. AO, which has been rejected by him as per the observation made in para 3 of his order. The assessee had purchased 4,97,500 shares of Shreenath Commercial and Finance Limited at face value of Rs. 20/- per share from 10/03/2011 to 11/03/2011 in the open market on the Online Trading Portal of the Stock Exchange, through a registered Broker, M/s RBK Share Broking Limited. There was a bonus issue in the ratio of 1:1 on 22/03/2011. The assessee thus held 9,95,000 shares of the said company in her Demat account. These 9,95,000 shares were sold after almost 2 years between 16/01/2013 to 21/01/2013 for an aggregate consideration of Rs. 8,29,88,876/-, on which assessee had earned a long-term capital gain of Rs. 7,29,88,736/- claimed as exempt u/s 10(38) of the Act in the return of income for the year under consideration.
5. Before the ld. AO in response to show-cause notice to prove the genuineness of the transaction, assessee had submitted following details and submissions which are summarized hereunder:-
a. The shares were not acquired through any preferential allotment;
b. Impugned shares were purchased and sold online on the Recognized Stock Exchange;
c. The payment of purchase was made and consideration for sale was received through banking channels;
d. The transaction of sale and purchase of shares was effected through a reputed Registered Broker;
e. STT was duly paid on the impugned transactions
f. The assessee or her family has no connection of whatsoever nature with the Promoters of the company, Shreenath Commercial and Finance Limited.
6. Besides this, assessee also submitted following evidences in support of the said transaction:-
a. Copy of contract note for purchase and sale of shares of the company
b. Copy of Demat Account reflecting receipt and transfer of shares of the company
c. Extract of ledger account of Share Broker in assessee’s books of accounts
d. Bank Statement reflecting payment on purchase and receipt of consideration on sale of shares of the company.
7. The ld. AO after detailed discussion has treated the entire long term capital gain of Rs.8,29,88,876/- as bogus and added u/s. 68. First of all, he has referred to the information received from Investigation wing that assessee has taken accommodation entry in the form of bogus LTCG. The sale data as per AIR information about selling of the shares of M/s. Shreenath Commercial & Finance Ltd. mentions that assessee had sold 9,95,000 scrips between 16/01/2013 to 21/01/2013 for Rs. 8,29,88,876/- at a rate ranging between Rs.79/- to Rs.86/- per share. The assessee had purchased shares before the issue of bonus share on 22/03/2011 and the shares started rising from August 2012 to February 2013. According to the AO, this sudden rise of the scrip in a short period without any financial credibility itself shows that it was a penny stock. Thereafter, he has discussed some general outcome of the investigation carried out by the Kolkata Investigation Wing. He has also produced statement of assessee’s husband, Shri Rajendra Chaturvedi, who had bought and sold these shares on behalf of the assessee. The relevant statement has been incorporated in the impugned assessment order. In his statement, Shri Rajendra Chaturvedi have stated that he had purchased and sold shares online through a reputed broker for which already relevant documents have been furnished. He also admitted that he is regular investor but he had not done any due diligence before the purchase of shares of this Company or its performance in the market. He stated that he had purchased the shares on his own decision so as to give him profit and he was not involved with any of the person or entities which were alleged to be providing accommodation entry. Further, he has also stated that he was not aware of any purchase parties who had purchased the shares of M/s. Shree Nath Commercial & Finance Ltd from him and his family members, as the transaction was done through stock exchange.
7.1 The AO had also noted financials of the company M/s. Shree Nath Commercial & Finance Ltd. for the F.Y.20 10-11 to 20 14-15 and noted that sales turnover was ranging between Rs.14.26 Crores in F.Y.2011-12 and in F.Y.2010-11 it was Rs. 28.75 Crores and in 20 12-13 it was Rs.7.66 Crores and the operating profit was in negative. He has also noted about raising of the funds by this Company by way of preferential allotments, etc. He also observed that the prices of the shares have seen phenomenal rise and was constantly traded near the circuit limit so as to avail maximum price raise without hitting and triggering the circuit limit.
7.2 Another important point noted by the ld. AO that, certain enquiries were also done in the case of exit providers who had purchased the shares of M/s. Shree Nath Commercial & Finance Ltd from the Chaturvedi family. The details of these six entities have been reproduced in the assessment order and one such company which he has drawn adverse inference is with regard to Moryo Industries Ltd and other entities also and he noted that SEBI vide its Interim Order dated 04/12/2014 in the case of Moryo Industries Ltd has noted that M/s. Moryo group who had been providing funds to the various companies buying the shares from the allottees, related to one Shri Giriraj Kishore Agarwal who was the common promoter of various entities including M/s. Shree Nath Commercial & Finance Ltd. These entities have received funds from M/s. Moryo Industries Ltd in the form of investment on loans and advances and these funds have been transferred with other entities providing exchange to the allottees. One important fact which he has relied upon and gathered those information, rather his observations are flowing from the Interim order dated 04/12/2014 of the SEBI, who has banned these exit providers vide its Interim order in the case of M/s. Moryo Industries Ltd.
7.3 Thereafter, AO has again noted that certain share brokers were investigated by the Director of Investigation and few of them have admitted that, besides other scrips they have also provided accommodation entry of bogus capital gain in the shares of M/s. Shree Nath Commercial & Finance Ltd. The details and the statements of these brokers have been discussed in detail by the AO. Finally, after detailed discussion he has treated the entire quantum of sale as bogus credit and added it as income under Section 68.
8. Apart from that he has also added alleged commission on estimate basis which assessee has given for getting the accommodation entry.
9. In sum and substance, the ld. AO has treated this as bogus transaction based on the following points:-
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.




