Devaraj Ilavarasan Vs ITO (ITAT Chennai)
Assessee originally filed ROI showing turnover of ₹10.76 crore & income of ₹9.26 lakh, but without audit report. He later filed a revised return on 01.08.2019 declaring turnover of ₹13.76 crore along with audit report. AO treated the revised return as non est, rejected books & completed best judgment assessment u/s 144. AO estimated 8% profit on turnover & also added ₹60,00,000 as alleged unexplained investment based on survey u/s 133A conducted in the “D. Devaraj group”. CIT(A)/NFAC confirmed the additions.
Before ITAT, assessee argued that (i) estimation of 8% is wholly arbitrary, (ii) AO failed to consider past financial history, (iii) in identical cases of assessee’s father (Shri D. Devaraj) & mother (Smt. Ellammal)—both arising from the same survey of 07.02.2018—the ITAT had already restricted profit estimation to 4%, and the assessee cannot be placed in a worse position than similarly-situated family members, and (iv) the ₹60 lakh investment addition was unjustified because the source was explained in the revised return.
Tribunal noted that AO adopted 8% without citing comparables, industry norms, past margins or defects in accounts. Crucially, Tribunal accepted that in the cases of the assessee’s parents—arising from identical search/survey material—the very same Bench had fixed reasonable profit at 4%, holding 8% excessive.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.


