Advertisement
Advertisement
Skip to content
Follow Us on
Advertisement
TOP STORIES
Income Tax

No Plot, No Profit, Still Taxed :When AO Shoots the Wrong Person: Middleman Dragged into 56(2)(ix) Tax Trap

Case Law Details

TaxGuru Citation
2025 taxguru.in 9449
Case Name
Saroj Devi Haldiya Vs ITO (ITAT Jaipur)
Appeal Number
Premium Access
Date of Judgement/Order
Premium Access
Related Assessment Year
2015-16
Subscribe to download.

Already Upgraded? Log in.

Advertisement

Saroj Devi Haldiya Vs ITO (ITAT Jaipur)

No Plot, No Profit, Still Taxed :When AO Shoots the Wrong Person: Middleman Dragged into 56(2)(ix) Tax Trap; Two-Day Show Cause, Zero Natural Justice: ITAT Called to Restore Fair Play!

Background

  • Assessee filed return declaring ₹13.37 lakh.
  • Reassessment u/s 147/144B completed at ₹88.72 lakh.
  • Major addition: ₹75,00,000 u/s 56(2)(ix) (forfeited advance).
  • Other disallowances: ₹34,647 (u/s 57) & ₹83,453 (capital loss restriction).
  • CIT(A), NFAC dismissed the appeal ex-parte, stating no proper submissions were filed.

Key Facts of the Transaction

  • Plot originally allotted to Medical Design India Pvt Ltd in 1987.
  • Allotment cancelled in 2006; appeal pending before RIICO.
  • Assessee agreed to purchase plot from Medical Design India (agreement 10.12.2014) & paid ₹75 lakh.
  • Simultaneously acting only as middleman for Dr. Anil Tambi/Jagdish Health Care Pvt Ltd.
  • Since Medical Design India failed to get clearance within 3 months, ₹75 lakh paid by assessee was forfeited there.
  • Later Dr. Tambi’s company reimbursed ₹75 lakh to assessee (24.02.2015).
  • Assessee never owned the plot & never received any advance for transfer of capital asset.

Assessee’s Legal Arguments Before ITAT

(A) Reopening u/s 147 invalid

  • AO relied only on Investigation Wing report – borrowed satisfaction.
  • No independent enquiry; reasons recorded do not show “reason to believe”.
  • Approval u/s 151 was mechanical.

(B) Objections to 148 not disposed properly

  • AO violated GKN Driveshaft (SC) – passed non-speaking order.

(C) Violation of Natural Justice

  • Show-cause notice dated 03.09.2021 giving only two effective working days.
  • CBDT guidelines & multiple HC/SC rulings require minimum 7 days.
  • Hence, assessment order void ab initio.

(D) Incorrect addition u/s 56(2)(ix)

  • Assessee never received any “advance” for transfer of capital asset.
  • It was mere reimbursement of earlier payment made on behalf of Dr. Tambi.
  • Real beneficiary of forfeited amount is Medical Design India Pvt Ltd, not assessee.
  • Therefore, section 56(2)(ix) not applicable.

CIT(A) Order Criticized

  • CIT(A) passed ex-parte order.
  • Failed to consider written submissions/statement/evidence.
  • Merely repeated AO’s findings without independent reasoning.

Relief Sought

  • Quash reassessment notice u/s 148.
  • Alternatively, delete ₹75 lakh addition.
  • Delete disallowances u/s 57 & capital loss restriction.
  • Drop penalty proceedings 271(1)(c).

Essence of the Case

  • A pure middleman reimbursement transaction has been wrongly treated as advance forfeited from sale of capital asset & taxed u/s 56(2)(ix).
  • Assessee never owned the property & never derived any benefit.
  • Reopening & assessment both suffer from borrowed satisfaction + violation of natural justice.

FULL TEXT OF THE ORDER OF ITAT JAIPUR

Want to Read the Complete Judgment?

You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.

Read on with Premium
Goes straight to payment. GST invoice included.

One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.

Advertisement

Author Info

CA Vijayakumar Shetty
Qualification: CA in Practice
Company: Shetty & Co, Chartered Accountants, Mangalore
Location: Mangalore, Karnataka
Articles Published: 7,723

Join TaxGuru's Network for the latest updates on Income Tax, GST, Company Law, Corporate Laws and other related subjects.