Brahm Precision Materials Pvt. Ltd Vs CIT(A) (ITAT Pune)
Foreign Venture Flopped, But Not the Tax Claim – ITAT Says Business Loss, Not Capital
Assessee, a manufacturer of aluminium die-casting and auto components, faced multiple additions by AO, which were mostly confirmed by NFAC/CIT(A). Assessee filed two appeals before ITAT. The appeal for AY 2020-21 was late by 445 days, but ITAT condoned the delay after finding genuine and reasonable cause. Since the issues in both years were common, ITAT passed a consolidated order.
Issue 1 – Foreign Investment Written Off (₹97.61 lakh in AY 2018-19 & ₹9.56 crore in AY 2020-21)
Assessee’s Case:
- It formed a 100% Wholly Owned Subsidiary (WOS) in USA – Brahm Corporation.
- WOS acquired 80% stake in Littler Diecast Corp. (LDC, USA) to expand markets and increase exports.
- Business loans were taken from US bank; MD gave personal guarantee.
- Assessee provided services to USA entities & earned:
- Export sales & service income (Crores of rupees) in AY 2017-18 & 2018-19.
- Due to recession, quality issues & bankruptcy, WOS/LDC collapsed.
- Investment was made for commercial expediency & business expansion, not for earning dividend.
- Hence write-off is business loss, not capital loss.
AO & CIT(A):
- Treated it as capital investment, hence capital loss.
- Not allowable as business expenditure.
ITAT’s Analysis/Decision
- Detailed facts show investment was for expansion and generating revenue.
- Assessee actually earned export income because of this structure.
- The purpose was integral to core business.
- Cited Supreme Court & High Court rulings (Colgate Palmolive, Ace Designers, Patnaik & Co., Investa Industrial).
- Principle: If investment is made for commercial/business purposes, loss is revenue loss.
- Allowed as business loss. Disallowance deleted.
Issue 2 – ₹99,23,830 Treated as Unexplained Cash Credit (Sec. 68)
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.



