From Compliance to Collaboration: India’s Drive for Tax Transparency and Balanced Treaty Negotiations
Introduction: As international economies become more interconnected, tax treaties play a pivotal role in shaping global financial interactions. India, striving to keep up with the pace of global standards and practices, has taken proactive steps towards tax transparency and negotiating balanced tax treaties. This analysis dives into India’s endeavors to harmonize its domestic regulations with global norms, challenges, and potential opportunities in enhancing its tax treaty network.
Tax treaties are crucial agreements between countries that allocate taxing rights and prevent double taxation of cross-border income. They provide certainty and stability for taxpayers and tax administrations while fostering trade, investment, and economic development. However, tax treaties can also be exploited for tax evasion and avoidance by multinational enterprises (MNEs), posing challenges to global tax fairness. This article examines India’s compliance with global standards and best practices on tax transparency, exchange of information, base erosion and profit shifting (BEPS), and dispute resolution. It also explores the challenges and opportunities for India in enhancing its tax treaty network and negotiating fair and balanced agreements with other countries.
India has taken significant steps to align its domestic laws and practices with global standards and best practices. An important initiative is India’s participation in the Multilateral Convention to Implement Tax Treaty-Related Measures to Prevent BEPS (MLI). By signing and ratifying the MLI, India can swiftly implement BEPS-related measures across a substantial number of bilateral tax treaties. The MLI covers various aspects, such as preventing treaty abuse, neutralizing the effects of hybrid mismatch arrangements, improving dispute resolution mechanisms, and modifying bilateral tax treaties through a multilateral instrument. India’s commitment to the MLI demonstrates its proactive approach to combating tax avoidance and ensuring transparency in international tax matters.
India has also implemented the minimum standards developed under the Base Erosion and Profit Shifting (BEPS) Project led by the OECD and G20. These minimum standards cover areas such as harmful tax practices, country-by-country reporting, treaty shopping, and dispute resolution. By implementing these standards, India aims to prevent tax avoidance and ensure a level playing field for taxpayers.
India’s membership in the Global Forum on Transparency and Exchange of Information for Tax Purposes has further strengthened its commitment to tax transparency. The Global Forum conducts peer reviews to assess the compliance of its members with international standards on transparency and the exchange of information for tax purposes. India has undergone peer reviews on both exchanges of information on request (EOIR) and automatic exchange of information (AEOI). It has achieved a commendable “largely compliant” rating on EOIR, indicating its efforts to facilitate the exchange of information with other countries. Moreover, India has successfully implemented AEOI with over 90 jurisdictions, further demonstrating its commitment to transparency and cooperation in combating tax evasion and promoting global tax fairness.
While India has made progress in international tax cooperation, there are opportunities to enhance its tax treaty network. Expanding the tax treaty network is crucial for India to promote foreign investments and improve access to foreign markets. Currently, India has a relatively low number of tax treaties compared to other major economies. To address this, India could consider prioritizing the expansion of its treaty network, particularly with countries and regions where it has strategic and economic interests, such as Africa and Latin America. A broader tax treaty network would not only facilitate cross-border trade and investment but also provide a framework for resolving tax disputes and exchanging information, promoting greater certainty for taxpayers and tax administrations.
Renegotiating existing tax treaties is another critical aspect of enhancing India’s tax treaty network. Some countries, such as Mauritius, Singapore, and Cyprus, have been used for treaty shopping and round-tripping of funds. Treaty shopping involves routing investments through intermediary jurisdictions to benefit from more favourable tax treaty provisions. Round-tripping refers to the movement of funds from India to a foreign jurisdiction and then back to India, often with the aim of taking advantage of treaty benefits. To address these challenges, India has taken steps to amend its tax treaties with these countries by including limitation of benefits (LOB) clauses. These clauses restrict the availability of treaty benefits to bona fide residents of the contracting states. While these amendments aim to curb abuse, it is essential to monitor their implementation and effectiveness to avoid undue compliance burdens or uncertainty for genuine taxpayers.
Treaty disputes and controversies have also emerged between India and some of its treaty partners. These disputes often revolve around the interpretation and application of treaty provisions, such as the definition of royalty, fees for technical services, and capital gains. To address these issues, it is crucial for India to improve communication, consultation, and effective use of the mutual agreement procedure (MAP) and arbitration mechanisms provided by tax treaties. The MAP allows competent authorities of treaty partners to resolve disputes arising from the interpretation or application of tax treaties. Additionally, utilizing arbitration mechanisms can provide a fair and timely resolution to tax disputes, ensuring a more balanced and amicable outcome.
India has an opportunity to actively participate in discussions and negotiations within the Inclusive Framework on BEPS. This platform enables countries to collaborate on implementing the BEPS Project and developing new global tax rules. One significant area of focus for the Inclusive Framework is the tax challenges posed by digitalization. As the digital economy continues to grow, questions arise regarding the allocation of taxing rights in a globalized and digitalized world. India has a strong interest in ensuring a fair distribution of taxing rights, particularly to market jurisdictions where value is created by users and consumers. By actively participating in the Inclusive Framework, India can contribute to the development of consensus-based solutions that reflect the changing dynamics of the digital economy.
India’s compliance with global standards and best practices in tax transparency, exchange of information, BEPS, and dispute resolution is commendable. By participating in international initiatives such as the MLI, implementing BEPS minimum standards, and actively engaging in the Global Forum and Inclusive Framework, India demonstrates its commitment to combating tax avoidance, promoting transparency, and ensuring a fair and balanced international tax system.
To further enhance its tax treaty network, India can focus on expanding the network, renegotiating existing tax treaties, and effectively resolving disputes. Active participation in the Inclusive Framework on BEPS allows India to shape global tax rules, addressing the challenges posed by digitalization. Through these efforts, India can strengthen its position in international tax cooperation, foster global tax fairness, and create a conducive environment for trade, investment, and economic growth.
Conclusion: India’s efforts to comply with global tax standards and foster transparency are noteworthy. Its commitment to international cooperation has placed it on the path towards creating a balanced tax treaty network. Yet, opportunities abound, particularly in expanding and renegotiating tax treaties and effectively resolving disputes. As digitalization redefines global economic landscapes, India’s active involvement in shaping the new norms will be pivotal. Achieving these aims could strengthen India’s international tax cooperation, foster global tax fairness, and pave the way for sustainable economic growth.
Author Bio
