Case Law Details
In re Float Glass Centre (GST AAR Tamil Nadu)
Introduction: The determination of the correct classification of goods is crucial for taxation purposes, especially under GST. In the case of ‘Clear Float Glass,’ the GST AAR Tamil Nadu examined its classification under the Customs Tariff Act, 1975.
Detailed Analysis: The applicant, Float Glass Centre, argued for the classification of ‘Clear Float Glass’ under CTH 7005 1090, emphasizing its manufacturing process and properties. However, the AAR analyzed the manufacturing process, specifically the presence of an absorbent layer, reflecting or non-reflecting, essential for classification under CTH 7005 10.
The discussion delved into the manufacturing process of Float Glass, the role of tin, and the absence of additional coatings that would qualify as an absorbent layer as per the explanatory notes of the HSN. The ruling highlighted that while tin is present in the glass due to the manufacturing process, it does not serve the purpose of an intentional absorbent, reflecting, or non-reflecting layer.
Furthermore, the AAR dismissed reliance on past rulings and orders, emphasizing the specific nature of each case and the binding nature of rulings only to the applicant. It also addressed the trader-importer dynamic, emphasizing the consistency required in classification for trading purposes.
Please become a Premium member. If you are already a Premium member, login here to access the full content.
Author Bio
