DCIT Vs Flipkart India Pvt Ltd (ITAT Bangalore)
Marketing Intangibles Theory Rejected Again; ₹6,006 Cr & ₹4,016 Cr Additions Deleted—ESOP Cross-Charge Also Allowed
Profit Foregone Is Not Capital Expenditure—Intangibles Theory Rejected Once More & ESOP Cross-Charge Is Employee Cost—Allowed u/s 37; No TDS u/s 195
ITA Nos.1394 & 1395/Bang/2025 – AYs 2020-21 & 2021-22 – Order dated 04.12.2025
Revenue filed appeals challenging CIT(A)’s deletion of massive additions made by AO on two counts:
(1) Alleged creation of marketing intangibles—AO treated discounts/losses (goods sold below cost) as capital expenditure for creation of brand value, capitalised them & added ₹6,006 Cr (AY 2020-21) & ₹4,016 Cr (AY 2021-22) after depreciation adjustments.
(2) ESOP cross-charge disallowance of ₹147 Cr (AY 2020-21) & ₹159 Cr (AY 2021-22), claiming it to be contingent liability & liable for TDS u/s 195.
CIT(A) deleted both additions relying on earlier years’ Tribunal decisions in Flipkart’s favour. Revenue appealed.
Tribunal examined entire record, including detailed reasoning extracted across pages 6–16, & held:
1. Marketing Intangibles Allegation Has No Legal Basis
- AO presumed that selling goods below cost to unrelated retailers creates brand/goodwill.
- Tribunal reiterated earlier ruling (AYs 2015-16 & 2017-18) that foregone profit is not expenditure, cannot be deemed to create intangibles, & cannot be taxed without specific deeming provision.
- AO never invoked s.145(3); hence book results cannot be discarded.
- Tribunal reaffirmed that what could have been earned cannot be taxed—relying on Calcutta Discount Co, A. Raman & Co, A. Khader Basha, etc.
Accordingly, additions on “marketing intangibles” were rightly deleted by CIT(A).
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.


