Royal Chains Pvt Ltd Vs DCIT (ITAT Mumbai)
Gold Stock Additions Collapse: ITAT Says Reconciliation + Confirmations = No 69A- Survey Statements Not Gospel—Documentary Evidence Saves Assessee from Rs.6.67 Cr Additions
In these cross-appeals, Tribunal dealt with CSR donation u/s 80G, additions u/s 69A on alleged excess gold stock & Assessee’s claim of short-term capital loss on sale of a factory building. Tribunal noted that CSR expenditure is disallowed u/s 37 Explanation 2 while computing business income, but this does not bar deduction u/s 80G while computing total income, subject to conditions of s.80G. Since authorities below had not verified eligibility, Tribunal restored the matter to AO for quantification & directed that deduction be allowed to the extent permitted.
On the major issue of additions u/s 69A aggregating approx Rs.6.67 crore for alleged unexplained stock of 24KT, 22KT & 18KT gold found during survey u/s 133A, Tribunal approved CIT(A)’s detailed factual findings. CIT(A), after examining survey statements, invoices, job-work records, purchase registers, export dispatch details & confirmations received u/s 133(6), held that stock differences arose only because invoices & entries were pending at the time of survey & all transactions were later fully reconciled. Documents placed on record showed that suppliers (including Abhushan Creations Pvt Ltd) confirmed sales, payments were through banking channels & the gold was duly recorded in audited books & GST filings. Tribunal held that AO ignored crucial third-party confirmations, misread survey statements & made additions solely on assumptions. CIT(A)’s deletion of additions of Rs.2,12,52,000 & Rs.4,53,63,627 was therefore upheld.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.




