Ambajee Jewellers Vs PCIT (ITAT Jabalpur)
263 partly sustained: PCIT can’t revise accepted purchases, but denovo enquiry upheld on others
Jabalpur ITAT partly allowed the Assessee’s appeal against revision u/s 263, holding that the PCIT overreached on purchases already accepted in first appeal, but was justified in directing denovo enquiry on remaining issues.
The case was selected for scrutiny on abnormal cash deposits during demonetisation. The AO completed assessment u/s 143(3) making an addition of ₹2.12 crore (bogus sales). The PCIT invoked section 263 alleging inadequate enquiry on (i) purchases where bills were allegedly not produced (including sister concerns/unregistered dealers) and (ii) profit mismatch between audited P&L (₹44.83 lakh) and income offered (₹34.14 lakh), and set aside the assessment for denovo consideration.
The Tribunal held that revision cannot disturb matters already settled in first appeal: where sales were accepted/held explained in the seller’s hands (e.g., purchases corresponding to Ajay Rawat’s sales, quashed by CIT(A)), they cannot be treated unexplained in the purchaser’s hands; to that extent, PCIT’s assumption of jurisdiction was invalid.
However, for other purchases (including from M/s Ambaji Hallmark Gold) where acceptance was not demonstrated, and on the unreconciled profit difference, the ITAT found no infirmity in PCIT’s action—holding that the AO did not carry enquiry to its logical conclusion. The Tribunal clarified that on remand, the AO must apply independent mind afresh and decide under appropriate provisions without being influenced by PCIT’s remarks. It also rejected the plea that 263 was vitiated merely because it followed an audit objection, relying on CIT v. P.V.S. Beedies Pvt. Ltd. (SC).
Accordingly, the revision was quashed in part (accepted purchases) and upheld in part (remaining purchases & profit mismatch); the appeal was partly allowed
FULL TEXT OF THE ORDER OF ITAT JABALPUR
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.
Author Info
- Employment Agreement Dispute Arbitrable Despite Pending NCLT Mismanagement Case: Karnataka High Court November 19, 2026
- Supreme Court Restores Dredging Arbitration Award Reduced by 50% November 19, 2026
- Karnataka HC Orders Completion of Two-Decade-Old Award Execution Within Six Months November 19, 2026
Join TaxGuru's Network for the latest updates on Income Tax, GST, Company Law, Corporate Laws and other related subjects.

15 December 2026 Advance-Tax Instalment: Income-tax Act, 2025 Computation & Payment Controls
November 19, 2026
Foreign Ship Seafarer’s ₹48.86 Lakh Salary Not Taxable in India: ITAT Jaipur
November 19, 2026
Cash Deposits and Flat Cancellation Gain Remanded by Mumbai ITAT
November 19, 2026
Gujarat HC Quashes Reassessment for Non-Disclosure of Evidence and Improper Fresh Notice
November 19, 2026
Five-Day Section 148A(b) Notice Invalid: Karnataka High Court
November 19, 2026
ITAT Cochin Upholds DIN Authentication and Jewellery Profit Assessment
November 19, 2026Subscribe Our Newsletter
Join the professionals, businesses and finance teams who rely on TaxGuru's morning digest of notifications, judgments and analysis. Curated by editors, free forever.
