Dinesh Gulshanlal Gupta Vs ITO (ITAT Ahmedabad)
No Statement of Facts? No Problem! – ITAT Says ‘Don’t Kill the Appeal for a Missing Paragraph- Appeal cannot be dismissed merely for not filing Statement of Facts – Matter remanded for fresh adjudication- ITAT Ahmedabad
Assessee filed returns for AY 2016-17 & 2019-20 declaring ~₹3 lakh income. Investigation Wing seized ledger of Darshanam Group showing assessee allegedly gave cash loans of ₹1.50 crore. AO treated ₹75 lakh (AY 2016-17) & ₹25 lakh (AY 2019-20) as unexplained cash advances u/s 69A r.w.s. 115BBE. Assessee denied the transactions but AO made additions.
Appeal filed before CIT(A), but Statement of Facts (SOF) was not attached to Form 35.
CIT(A)’s Action
- Issued deficiency notice, but assessee didn’t cure within time.
- CIT(A) dismissed the appeal as “non-maintainable” solely for not filing SOF.
- Thus, additions were confirmed without examining merits.
Before ITAT
- Assessee argued: non-filing of SOF is a procedural defect, not a ground for dismissal.
- DR fairly conceded that appeal should not have been dismissed & may be remanded.
ITAT’s Findings
- Appeal was filed in time, in prescribed form, with grounds of appeal.
- SOF is procedural, not mandatory for maintainability.
- Section 250(6) mandates CIT(A) to pass a reasoned order on merits.
- CIT(A) has wide powers – cannot dismiss appeal on technicalities.
- Once appeal is validly instituted, CIT(A) must adjudicate on merits.
- CIT(A)’s dismissal set aside.
- Matter remanded back to CIT(A) to decide afresh on merits after giving opportunity of hearing.
- ITAT made it clear no view on merits of addition is expressed.
Procedural lapse (like non-filing of Statement of Facts) cannot defeat substantive right of appeal. CIT(A) is bound to decide on merits; dismissal at threshold violates Section 250(6).
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.


