Advertisement
Advertisement
Skip to content
Follow Us on
Advertisement
TOP STORIES
Income Tax

Addition not justified when third party retracted the statement and Assessee not given Opportunity to Cross Examine

Case Law Details

TaxGuru Citation
2020 taxguru.in 884
Case Name
Asstt. CIT Vs Sabari Switch Gear (P) Ltd. (ITAT Cochin)
Appeal Number
Premium Access
Date of Judgement/Order
Premium Access
Related Assessment Year
2010-2011
Subscribe to download.

Already Upgraded? Log in.

Advertisement

ACIT Vs Sabari Switch Gear (P) Ltd. (ITAT Cochin)

The issue under consideration is whether the addition under section 68 is done by AO is justified in law whenm addition was based on third party statements which were retracted by them and Assessee was not given opportunity to cross examine them and when Addition are based merely on Surmises?

In the present case, assessee carried on trading activities with certain parties from whom assessee claimed to have received loans and advances. AO suspected extending such huge advances to assessee.  Because of low profit margin of parties who had advanced money to assessee. Also, AO took note of statement of one ‘M’ who who managed the affairs of trading parties, wherein he admitted that business activities, books of accounts, etc., in respect of those concerns were performed and maintained by assessee and they were used only for signing authorities and in lieu of signature they got commission from assessee. Accordingly, AO treated loan received by assessee as unexplained credit liable for addition under section 68.The assessee asked for an opportunity of cross examination of the parties whose statements were relied on by the Assessing Officer while framing the assessment, though the said parties retracted the statements, AO rejected that request and passed the order.

ITAT states that, not allowing the assessee to cross examine the parties whose statements were relied upon to make addition in the impugned assessment order is a serious flaw which makes the order null and void in as much as it amounted to violation of principles of natural justice because of which the assesses were adversely affected. In the present case, the entire evidence has to be appreciated in a wholesome manner and even when there is a documentary evidence, the same can be overlooked if there are surrounding circumstances to show that the claim of the assessee is opposed to the normal course of human thinking and conduct or human probabilities. The evidence collected by the lower authorities was not enough to establish their stand that the main transactions carried out by the assessee with the above parties were only paper transactions and only accommodation entries. As discussed earlier, there is no evidence which was brought on record to directly show that these transactions are accommodation entries. Therefore, no addition could be made on account of these alleged transactions in the hands of the assessee by treating them as unexplained credits u/s. 68 of the Act. Hence, transaction shall be accepted to be real as there is no evidence showing otherwise. Therefore, the addition made by the Assessing Officer cannot be sustained and the appeals of the Revenue is dismissed.

FULL TEXT OF THE ITAT JUDGEMENT

These appeals by the Revenue and the Cross Objections by two different assessees are directed against the orders of the CIT(A), both dated 19.07.2018, for the assessment years 2010-2011 and 2011-2012.

2. The common grounds, except for variance in figures, raised by the Revenue in case of both the assessees are as follows:-

“1. The Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) erred in deleting the addition of Rs.7.36 Crores holding that the addition has been made only on suspicion and presumption.

2. The CIT(A) has ignored the statement of Shri Manish Khetan S/o Late Shri Gouri Shankar Khetan deposed before the Dy.Director of Income Tax (Inv) Unit 2(1), Kolkatta on 07.04.2016.

3. The CIT(A) has overlooked the fact the enormous funds have been obtained under the head “Loans & Advances” by the assessee from the Kolkatta based paper concerns, which had remained in the books of the assessee for period ranging from one to three years and on the basis of the principle of preponderance of probability these funds are to be treated as unexplained cash credits u/s 68 of the I.T.Act, 1961.”

3. The Cross Objections filed by the assessees, which are in support of the orders of the Assessing Officer, in both the appeals are as follows:-

“1. The Commissioner of Income Tax Appeals (III) Kochi has erred in rejecting the following technical grounds , on irrelevant and flimsy grounds.

2. The CIT has erred in rejecting the Appellant’s ground of Appear on the question of Jurisdiction of the ACIT , Central Circle, Kollam , without even assigning Jurisdiction to him by the Director General or Principal Commissioner of Income Tax , Chennai by an order u/s 127 of the 1. T Act. Neither objection from the Appellant was sought for the transfer of Jurisdiction from ACIT, Corporate Circle , Chennai to ACIT , Central Circle, Kollam, nor an order U/s 127 of the 1. T Act was passed to that effect. So the ACIT , Kollam has passed the order U / s 143 (3) W.r.s 147 without jurisdiction.

 The Commissioner of Income Tax should have noted that the Appellant has filed their objection u/s 124  (3) before the ACIT, Kollam, vide their letter dtd 16/10/2017 , which was not even dealt with by the ACIT Kollam in the order of assessment passed by him.

4. The Commissioner of Income Tax has erred in rejecting the contentions of the Appellant on the ground that the A.O has considered the objection. of the Appellant made against the re-opening of the assessment on the basis of the reasons recorded for re-opening the assessment. The CIT should have noted that the main objection of the Appellant was that the assessment was re-opened only on the basis of suspicion regarding the credits in the books of accounts of the Appellant and therefore the re-opening was against the directions. of the CBDT vide circular No. 40 of 2016 dtd 09/12/2016.

5. Based on the above objection of the Appellant, the order should have been quashed by the CIT Appeals on the ratio of the Supreme Court decision in the case of GKN Drive Shafts (India) Ltd Vs. ITO & Ors 259 ITR 19 and of the Madras High Court decision in Jayant Natrajan Vs ACIT 300 CTR (Mad) 225.

 6. The Appellant craves leave to adduce additional grounds at the time of hearing.”

4. There was a short delay in filing these cross objections, as follows:-

(i) M/s.Sabari Switch Gear Pvt. Ltd. for Asst.Years 2010-2011 & 2011-2012 – 8 days.

(ii) M/s.Sabari Millennium Impex Pvt. Ltd. for Asst.Years 2010-2011 & 2011-2012 – 8 days.

5. However, at the time of hearing before us, the learned Counsel for the assessee has not pressed the cross objections filed by the assessee. Accordingly, the same are dismissed as not pressed.

6. Coming to the Revenue’s appeals, the facts are identical in the case of both the assessees and for both the assessment years, except for variance in figures, hence, we reproduce the facts relating to M/s.Sabari Switch Gear Pvt. Ltd. for assessment year 2010-2011, as under:-

7.1 These grounds of appeal of the appellant relate to additions made u/s 68 of the I.T.Act.

7.2 The AO has passed identical orders for A.Y. 2010-2011 and 2011-12, contents of which are reproduced as under:

2. The assessee company, as mentioned earlier, is primarily a trader in export incentives received under Vishesh Krishi Gram Udyog Yojana (VKGUy), DP EB (Duty Entitlement Pass Book) and the like. The export incentives received by the Cashew exporters, Marine exporters who are mainly based in Kollam are purchased by the assessee and sold to importers based ‘outside the State. Shri P Sunil Kumar also conducts the same kind’ of business through his Companies as Managing Director. The businesses are

 i. M/s Sabari Quality Foods as proprietor

ii. M/s Sabari Enterprises P Ltd as Managing Director

iii. M/s. Sabari Millenium Exporters P Ltd as Managing Director and

iv. M/s. Sabari Switchgear P Ltd as Managing Director

 3. Among the major purchasers of export incentives as per the books of accounts of Sabari Quality Foods, Sabari ‘Millenium Exporter P Ltd and Sabari Switchgear P Ltd are

i. Basanth Impex, a proprietorship of Shri Manish Khetan with its address as ,Old China Bazar Street, Kolkotta.

ii. Shyam International, a proprietorship of Shri Manish Khetan with its address as, Old China Bazar Street, Kolkotta.

iii. Sree Chao Impex, a proprietorship of Shri Manish Khetan with its address as Old China Bazar Street, Kolkotta.

M/s Ajay Iron and Steel P Ltd , Fortune Chambers, 6 Lyons Range, Mezzanine Fllor, Kolkatta.

v. Vani Exporters, CLIVE ghat Street, room No.7, 2nd Floor, Kolkatta

vi. Mayur Impex, p-68B, Block -2, Scheme – VII M, CIT Road, Kolkatta

4. The seized materials as per annexure marked SKPIKLMIDS 1 to 23 clearly show lot of trade activity between the assessee and his companies namely, M/s.Sabari Enterprises P Ltd, M/s. Sabari Millenium Exports P Ltd. M/s. Sabari SwitchGear P Ltd , and Basanth Impex, Shyam International, Sree Chao Impex, Ajay Iron and Steel P Ltd. Vani Exports and Mayur Impex. The total turnover of the aforementioned businesses and their turnover with each of businesses ofSabari Group (Sabari Quality Foods.

i. Basanth Impex & Shree Chao Impex

Want to Read the Complete Judgment?

You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.

Read on with Premium
Goes straight to payment. GST invoice included.

One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.

Advertisement

Author Info

Prapti Raut
Name: Prapti Raut
Qualification: Student - CA/CS/CMA
Location: MUMBAI, Maharashtra
Articles Published: 474

Join TaxGuru's Network for the latest updates on Income Tax, GST, Company Law, Corporate Laws and other related subjects.