No addition in case of unabated assessment which had attained finality on search date if no incriminating material found during search

Anurag Dalmia Vs DCIT (ITAT Delhi)

In the case of the unabated assessment which had attained finality on the date of search, which are reckoned as unabated assessments, no addition over and above the originally assessed income can be made sans any incriminating material found or unearthed during the course of search. The principle reiterated time and again is that something should be found as a result of search which is incriminating in nature so as to implicate the assessee and acquire jurisdiction to make the addition, because for the completed assessment, or in other words, assessment which are not abated, the Assessing Officer is required to make re­assessment u/s.153A which is only possible when any incriminating material has been found during the course of search. If the Revenue has any information in its possession prior to the date of search and no corroborative evidence was found during the course of search so as to link the information already in hand with the material found during the course of search, then such an information for making any kind of addition ostensibly is outside the purview of Section 153A as per the binding judicial precedents of the Hon’ble Jurisdictional High Court. We again reiterate that if the Income Tax Department had any material information in its possession received from any external source and in wake of such an information search u/s 132 has been carried out and nothing incriminating has been found having live-link nexus with the said information already in hand, then the Revenue has other courses open to implicate the assessee or carry out further inquiry under the other provisions of the Act, but definitely not u/s.153A.

Thus, we hold that despite there being incriminating material in the possession of the Revenue which may implicate assessee, but same cannot be used within the scope of Section 153A when nothing has been found from the search, especially when assessee too has denied any such involvement and there is no material gathered during the search to rebut such a denial by the assessee. Accordingly, the addition made by the Assessing Officer for sum of Rs.28,24,48,860/- is deleted.

Here in this case as per the Assessing Officer still certain information are yet to be received and the material and information available with the department needs to be corroborated and needs to be further inquired into. Under these circumstances also in our opinion same cannot be done within the scope of Section 153A as we have already held that nothing has been found from the assessee during the course of search, which can preempt any post search inquiry. Albeit in abated assessments AO may have power to conduct further inquiry but not in case of unabated assessments.

Please become a Premium member. If you are already a Premium member, login here to access the full content.