Advertisement
Advertisement
Skip to content
Follow Us on
Advertisement
TOP STORIES
Fema / RBI

SARFAESI Act applicable to even Cooperative Banks: SC

Case Law Details

TaxGuru Citation
2020 taxguru.in 759
Case Name
Pandurang Ganpati Chaugule Vs Vishwasrao Patil Murgud Sahakari (Supreme Court of India)
Appeal Number
Premium Access
Date of Judgement/Order
Premium Access
Subscribe to download.

Already Upgraded? Log in.

Advertisement

Pandurang Ganpati Chaugule Vs Vishwasrao Patil Murgud Sahakari (Supreme Court)

(1) (a) The co-operative banks registered under the State legislation and multi-State level co-operative societies registered under the MSCS Act, 2002 with respect to ‘banking’ are governed by the legislation relatable to Entry 45 of List I of the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution of India.

(b) The co-operative banks run by the co-operative societies registered under the State legislation with respect to the aspects of ‘incorporation, regulation and winding up’, in particular, with respect to the matters which are outside the purview of Entry 45 of List I of the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution of India, are governed by the said legislation relatable to Entry 32 of List II of the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution of India.

(2) The co-operative banks involved in the activities related to banking are covered within the meaning of ‘Banking Company’ defined under Section 5(c) read with Section 56(a) of the Banking Regulation Act, 1949, which is a legislation relatable to Entry 45 of List I. It governs the aspect of ‘banking’ of co-operative banks run by the co-operative societies. The co-operative banks cannot carry on any activity without compliance of the provisions of the Banking Regulation Act, 1949 and any other legislation applicable to such banks relatable to ‘Banking’ in Entry 45 of List I and the RBI Act relatable to Entry 38 of List I of the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution of India.

(3)(a) The co-operative banks under the State legislation and multi-State co-operative banks are ‘banks’ under section 2(1)(c) of Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002. The recovery is an essential part of banking; as such, the recovery procedure prescribed under section 13 of the SARFAESI Act, a legislation relatable to Entry 45 List I of the Seventh Schedule to the Constitution of India, is applicable.

(3)(b) The Parliament has legislative competence under Entry 45 of List I of the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution of India to provide additional procedures for recovery under section 13 of the Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 with respect to co‑operative banks. The provisions of Section 2(1)(c)(iva), of Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002, adding “ex abundanti cautela”, ‘a multi-State co-operative bank’ is not ultra wires as well as the notification dated 28.1.2003 issued with respect to the co­operative banks registered under the State legislation.

FULL TEXT OF THE SUPREME COURT JUDGEMENT

1. The matters have been referred in view of conflicting decisions in Greater Bombay Coop. Bank Ltd. v. United Yarn Tex (P) Ltd. and Ors.1, Delhi Cloth & General Mills Co. Ltd. v. Union of India and Ors.2, T. Velayudhan Achari and Anr. v. Union of India and Ors.2, and Union of India and Anr. v. Delhi High Court Bar Association and Ors:4. The question relates to the scope of the legislative field covered by Entry 45 of List I viz. ‘Banking’ and Entry 32 of List II of the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution of India, consequentially power of the Parliament to legislate. The moot question is the applicability of the Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 (for short, ‘the SARFAESI Act’) to the co-operative banks.

1. The Parliament’s competence to amend Section 2(c) of the SARFAESI Act by adding sub-clause ‘(iva) – a multi-State co-operative  bank’ has also been questioned. The issue arises whether the definition of ‘banking company’ contained in Section 5(c) of the Banking Regulation Act, 1949 (for short, ‘the BR Act, 1949’) covers co­operative banks registered under the State law and also multi-State co-operative societies under the Multi-State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002 (for short, ‘the MSCS Act’). Consequently, (i) whether co­operative banks at State and multi-State level are co-operative banks within the purview of the SARFAESI Act ? and (ii) whether provisions of the SARFAESI Act apply to the co-operative banks registered under the MSCS Act ?

2. Section 56(c)(i)(cci) is contained in Part V of the BR Act, 1949, and was brought into force on 1.3.1966. It defines ‘co-operative bank’ to mean a ‘state co-operative bank,’ a ‘central co-operative bank,’ and a ‘primary co-operative bank.’ By the notification issued in 2003, the co-operative bank was brought within the class of banks entitled to seek recourse to the provisions of the SARFAESI Act. Section 2(1)(c) (iva) was inserted into the SARFAESI Act, w.e.f. 15.1.2013. Before that, the co-operative bank and the multi-State co-operative bank took recourse to the SARFAESI Act under the notification issued in 2003.

3. Writ petitions were filed questioning vires of the notification dated 28.1.2003 issued under Section 2(1)(c)(v) of the SARFAESI Act and the insertion of Section 2(1)(c)(iva) to the SARFAESI Act in 2013. The backdrop history of litigation indicates that in Narendra Kantilal Shah v. Joint Registrar, Co-operative Societies’, a Full Bench of the Bombay High Court opined that term ‘banking company’ also means co-operative bank within the meaning of Section 2(d) of the RDB Act, 1993. Hence, with effect from the date of constitution of Debts Recovery Tribunal under RDB Act, 1993, the courts and authorities under the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960, as also the MSCS Act would cease to have jurisdiction to entertain the applications submitted by the co-operative banks for recovery of their dues. The decision in Narendra Kantilal Shah (supra) was set aside by this Court in Greater Bombay Coop. Bank Ltd. (supra). This Court opined that the co-operative banks established under the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960 and Andhra Pradesh Co-operative Societies Act, 1964, transacting the business of banking do not fall within the meaning of ‘banking company’ as defined in Section 5(c) of the BR Act, 1949. Therefore, the provisions of the Recovery of Debts Due to Banks and Financial Institutions Act, 1993, now renamed as The Recovery of Debts and Bankruptcy Act, 1993 (for short, ‘the RDB Act, 1993’), by invoking the doctrine of incorporation do not apply to the recovery of dues by co-operative banks from their members. The field of co-operative societies cannot be said to have been covered by the Central legislation by reference to Entry 45 of List I of the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution of India. Co-operative banks constituted under the Co-operative Societies Acts enacted by the respective States would be covered by ‘co-operative societies’ by Entry 32 of List II of the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution of India. In the year 2004, the Banking Regulation (Amendment) and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 2004, was passed by the Union of India, amending various provisions contained in the BR Act, 1949 retrospectively, w.e.f. 1.3.1966. On the same anvil, the question posed is whether provisions can be applied to recovery provisions carved out in the SARFAESI Act.

4. Writ Petition No.2672 of 2007 was filed by Khaja Industries, challenging the invocation of the SARFAESI Act by Jalgaon Peoples Co-operative Bank. The Bombay High Court dismissed the same. The recourse to the proceedings under the SARFAESI Act was upheld. In Rama Steel v. Union of Indian, the decision in Khaja Industries was followed. Against the decision of Bombay High Court, appeals have been filed.

5. On 13.8.2008, Pandurang Ganpati Chougule – appellant, questioned the action of Vishwasrao Patil Murgud Sahakari Bank Limited under the SARFAESI Act before the Civil Judge in Spl. Civil Suit No.226 of 2007. Deciding the preliminary issue, the Trial Court held that it did not have the jurisdiction to decide the suit. The first appeal preferred was dismissed. Against that, the appeal has been preferred before this Court. A separate writ petition under Article 32 of the Constitution of India has also been filed, questioning the invocation of the SARFAESI Act by issuing notices under Section 13 by co-operative banks. During the pendency of the matters, the Central Government brought into force the Enforcement of Security Deposit and Debts Law (Amendment) Act, 2012 (Act 1 of 2013), amending the definition of Section 2(1)(c) of the SARFAESI Act; the amendment has also been questioned in the writ petition filed in this Court.

6. In Administrator, Shri Dhakari Group Co-operative Cotton Seal & v. Union of India, (Special Civil Application No.930 of 2001), the Gujarat High Court struck down the notification dated 28.1.2003, relying upon Greater Bombay Coop. Bank Ltd. (supra), same has also been questioned in the appeal. Later on, Gujarat High Court in Neel Oil Industries v. Union of India’, rejected the challenge to the Constitutional validity of clause (iva) ‘multi-State co-operative bank’ inserted by way of Amendment Act, 2013.

7. On 30.7.2015, the matter was referred to a larger Bench. After that, on 26.2.2016, a three-Judge Bench referred the matter to a larger Bench, due to conflicting decisions mentioned earlier of the three-Judge Bench of this Court.

ARGUMENTS:

8. Shri Devansh A. Mohta, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellants, raised the following arguments:

(a) The scope of banking under Entry 45 of List I is to be interpreted in light of the definition of expression ‘banking’ in terms of Section 5(b) of the BR Act, 1949. He has referred to Rustom Cavasjee Cooper v. Union of India’ in which this Court held that ‘banking’ under Entry 45 did not include ‘banker’ or ‘bank.’ Banking is an activity. Entry pertains to the activity of banking alone. Section 5(b) read with Section 6(1) of the BR Act, 1949, recognizes two kinds of activities that a bank may undertake: (1) the banking business, i.e., ‘core banking business’; and (2) any other business as provided in Section 6(1). He has also referred to the decision in Mahaluxmi Bank Ltd. v. Registrar of Companies, West Bengal’ in which the court considered the meaning of ‘banking,’ and held that the essence of banking was the relationship brought into existence, i.e., the core of banking.

(a) As to the scope of Entry 45 List I, he has further referred to the decision in ICICI Bank Limited v. Official Liquidator of APS Star Industries Limited and Ors.’, wherein it was emphasised that even if a company was doing different businesses in addition to clause (a) to (o) of Section 6(1), it would remain a banking company as long as it was performing the core banking functions under Section 5(b). The core banking function is the sine qua non for being regulated by the BR Act, 1949. Therefore, ‘banking’ in Entry 45 of List I is essentially meant to be confined to ‘core banking business’. At the time when the Constitution of India was promulgated, a well-defined and well-established meaning of the expression ‘banking’ prevailed in the form of the definition of ‘banking’ under Section 5(b) of the BR Act, 1949. The same expression was borrowed by the Framers of the Constitution of India, and same meaning was to be given to the expression ‘banking’ in the Entry as defined in the BR Act, 1949 as observed by this Court in The State of Madras v. Gannon Dunkerley & Co., (Madras) Ltd.’ and Diamond Sugar Mills Ltd. and Anr. v. State of Uttar Pradesh and Ann’ .

(b) There is a difference between ‘entity’ and ‘activity’. Section 6(1) and 6(2) of the BR Act, 1949, enable only a banking entity to perform certain additional business/functions. The performance of additional business/functions does not confer any status of a banking company upon such an entity. He also referred to Sections 32 and 33 of the State Bank of India Act, 1955 (for short, ‘the SBI Act’). Section 32 recognises that the State Bank of India can carry ‘agency business’ on behalf of Reserve Bank of India, that is not a banking business performed by the State Bank of India as apparent from the perusal of Section 33, which categorically enables the State Bank of India to carry on banking business under Section 5(b) and other forms of business under Section 6(1) of the BR Act, 1949. Thus, it was submitted that every activity performed by a bank is not a banking activity.

(c) That Entry 43 of List I of the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution of India confers upon the Parliament the competence to pass law pertaining to ‘incorporation, regulation and winding up’ of a trading corporation, more particularly a banking corporation. However, ‘co-operative societies’ are expressly excluded from the purview of the Parliament’s competence being a State subject under Entry 32 of List II. He argued that the legislative history of the BR Act, 1949, made a difference between ‘entity’ and ‘activity.’ The expression ‘banking’ was defined in Chapter X-A of the Companies Act (VII of 1913). Sections 277F to 277N were inserted vide Amendment Act No.22 of 1936. After that, the BR Act, 1949, was enforced, providing a comprehensive definition of ‘banking’ to bring within its scope all institutions which receive deposits repayable on demand or otherwise for lending or investment. At that time, the relevant entries of the Government of India Act, 1935, which dealt with the subject of banking as well as trading corporation, were in List I (Federal Legislative List). Entry 38 and Entry 33 were in relation to ‘banking’ and ‘corporation’ respectively. In the Constitution of India, Entry 38 and Entry 33 have been substituted. Entry 38 is substituted as Entry 45 of List I and Entry 33 has been bifurcated into Entry 43, and 44 of List I. Until 1965 before the amendment was inserted in the BR Act, 1949, it dealt with ‘banking companies.’ The word ‘companies’ was omitted in the year 1965. The function of the State Bank of India was governed by a separate statute such as the State Bank of India Act, 1955. In the year 1965, the Central Government passed the Banking Laws [Application of Cooperative Societies Act, 1965 (Act No.23 of 1965)]. He has referred to the Statement of Objects and Reasons, which brings out that the BR Act, 1949, was only to regulate the banking business relatable to Entry 45 and not to regulate the co­operative societies.

(d) Section 2(10) of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960, is related to the management and business of co-operative societies. Under Section 91 of the Maharashtra Act, any dispute touching the constitution, management or business is required to be referred to a co-operative court.

(e) Similarly, Section 3(f) of the MSCS Act defines ‘co-operative bank’ to mean a multi-State co-operative society, which undertakes the banking business. Under Section 84(2) of the MSCS Act, a dispute can be raised. The power of Parliament is confined to specific provisions of the BR Act, 1949 (a legislation referable to Entry 45 of List I), and the Reserve Bank of India Act (a legislation referable to Entry 38 of List I). The Parliament lacks legislative competence to regulate any other business, function, or facets of co-operative societies. It could have extended the provisions of said Act only. The Parliament cannot regulate these co-operative societies like a company performing banking functions or a banking corporation.

(f) The object of the SARFAESI Act is to regulate securitisation and reconstruction of financial assets and enforcement of security interests. The business of securitisation is not a banking business. Under Section 2(1)(1) of the SARFAESI Act, a ‘financial asset’ means debt or receivable and includes inter alia any financial asset. Section 2(1)(ha) defines ‘debt’ to mean the same as defined in clause (g) of Section 2 of the RDB Act, 1993. Financial assistance to members is another form of business that is not a banking business. Therefore, an attempt to regulate the assets of a co-operative bank by bringing them within the purview of the SARFAESI Act is contrary to the original intent of the extending provisions of the BR Act, 1949 and that would amount to exercising control over the entities which are beyond the purview of competence of Parliament.

(g) The Parliament lacks legislative competence to regulate financial assets related to the non-banking activity of a co-operative society as they are expressly excluded from the purview of Entry 43 of List I. The regulation cannot be based upon an interpretation of only Entry 45 without any regard to Entry 43. The legislative action would be inconsistent with the limitation inherent in the federal scheme of distribution of legislative powers between the Union and the State. It would amount to regulation of co-operative society which subject matter is covered under Entry 32 of List II and also confer upon them a status of a banking corporation or a banking company. It would render an entity falling under Entry 32 of List II subject to the control of the Parliament, which would be contrary not only to the text but also to the constitutional intendment as opined in I.T.C. Ltd. v. Agriculture Produce Market Committee and Ors.’

(h) Notification No.105(E) dated 28.1.2003 is ultra wires as the Parliament has included only two classes of entities, i.e., banking company and banking corporation within its purview. The definition of ‘bank’ under Section 2(1)(c)(v) means ‘such other bank which the Central Government may by notification, specify for this Act.’ The power of the Central Government is confined to the entity of the kind referred under Clauses (i) to (iv) and not beyond that, i.e., a banking company or a banking corporation only and not co-operative societies/banks. The co-operative bank is neither a banking company nor a banking corporation; thus, it falls outside the purview of Section 2(1)(c)(v) of the SARFAESI Act. The notification is ultra vires and violative of not only the parent statute but also the Constitution of India. For this purpose, learned counsel relied upon Hinsa Virodhak Sangh v. Mirzapur Moti Kuresh Jamat and Ors.14. Recovery of debts due is essential for the bank, i.e., entity and not for the banking business, i.e., activity. In Greater Bombay Coop. Bank Ltd. (supra), the argument based upon the banking business of the co-operative bank to be covered by Entry 45, was  rejected. Therefore, recovery of dues was held to be outside the purview of Entry 45 of List I. The Central legislation seeking to  regulate banks can only bring within its purview entities falling in Entry 43, i.e., banking corporation and banking companies. Thus, the Parliament is not competent to enact a law concerning the subject matter of Entry 32 of List II.

(i) The amendment incorporated is a colourable exercise. The notification dated 28.1.2003 is ultra vires in view of the decisions in K.C. Gajapati Narayan Deo and Ors. v. State of Orissa’ and State of Tamil Nadu and Ors. v. K. Shyam Sunder and Ors”. Once entities are excluded by Entry 43, the Union of India cannot control it by an indirect method. The Multi-State Co-operative Bank is a primary co­operative bank that is, in turn, a co-operative society. In Apex Cooperative Bank of Urban Bank of Maharashtra & Goa Ltd. v. Maharashtra State Cooperative Bank Ltd. and Ors.’, it was observed that co-operative societies are in the purview of the State List.

(j) The MSCS Act is relatable to Entry 44. This Court is not required to pronounce upon the validity of the said Act. The source of legislative authority to regulate such banks would be Entry 43. The purpose of Act No.23 of 1965 was to regulate the banking business of certain co-operative societies. They do not cease to be co-operative societies as held in Virendra Pal Singh and Ors. v. District Assistant Registrar, Cooperative Societies, Etah, and Ann’. There is a difference in the Entries 43, 44 and 32 as held in S. Dhanoa v. Municipal Corporation, Delhi and Ors.19, Daman Singh and Ors. v. State of Punjab and Ors.’, and Dalco Engineering Private Limited v. Satish Prabhakar Padhye and Ors.21. The decision in Greater Bombay Coop. Bank Ltd. (supra) laid down the law correctly.

(k) There has to be harmonious construction of the Entries in List I and List II. Any argument of alarm relating to an adverse effect on the banking sector would be of no consequence or relevance to the question of construction of the constitutional entry as held in T.C. Ltd. (supra).

9. Shri Vijay Kumar, learned counsel appearing on behalf of petitioners, submitted that Parliament is not competent to enact laws concerning co-operative societies/banks. Banking business for a co­operative society is merely an incidental/ancillary business. A co­operative society doing business remains a co-operative society and is covered under Entry 32 of List II. He has placed reliance on Iqbal Naseer Usmani v. Central Bank of India and Ors. 22.There is complete mechanism provided under the State Co-operative Societies Acts and MSCS Act; thus, the amendment to the SARFAESI Act and the notification deserve to be struck down.

10. Shri Vishwas Shah, learned counsel appearing on behalf of appellants, has argued that it is not necessary to question the 1965 Amendment made to the BR Act, 1949. The validity of the notification and the provisions of the SARFAESI Act have to be tested on their The co-operative banks differ from other banks. Entities are basically co-operative societies, and it incidentally trenches on banking. The dominant legislation on the subject is State legislation under Entry 32. The co-operative banks are different from banking companies to the extent that they advance loans to their members only. The banking companies/corporations deal with the public. The co-operative banks do not carry the business as defined in the BR Act, 1949. The Doctrine of Pith and Substance has to be applied, co‑operative society engaged in banking does not cease to be a co­operative society. In Entry 45 of List I, ‘banking’ does not include co­operative banks. He relied upon Gannon Dunkerley & Co. (Madras) Ltd. (supra) and I.T.C. Ltd. (supra).

11. Shri Satpal Singh, learned counsel, has re-emphasised that amendment made by inserting the definition of ‘multi-State co­operative bank’ is colourable legislation and deserves to be struck The Co-operative Acts are comprehensive. The meaning of the expression ‘bank’ could not have been enlarged.

12. Per contra, Shri Shekhar Naphade, learned senior counsel, appearing on behalf of Cosmos Bank, raised the following arguments: (a) Section 2(1) (c) of the SARFAESI Act defines ‘bank’ to mean ‘banking company’ as defined in Section 5(c) of the BR Act, 1949. Thus, the definition of ‘bank’ contained in Section 5(c) of the BR Act, 1949 stands incorporated in Section 2(d) of the SARFAESI Act, that came into existence on 21.6.2002; hence, it is necessary to examine Section 5(c) of the BR Act, 1949, as it stood on 21.6.2002. It is covered by way of incorporation, w.e.f. 1.3.1966. Section 56(a) became part of Statute since 1.3.1966, the reference to a ‘banking company’ or a ‘company’ shall be construed as a reference to a co‑ operative bank. Section 56(a) becomes part of Section 5(c) of the BR Act, 1949, and stands incorporated in Section 5(c) of the BR Act, 1949. Thus, a reference to the banking company has to be read as a reference to the co-operative bank. Section 56(a) becomes part of Section 5(c) of the BR Act, 1949. Although Section 56(a) is located in a separate place, its impact on Section 5(c) results in a co-operative bank both on State level as well as multi-State level becoming part of a banking company. Therefore, the SARFAESI Act covers in its purview co-operative banks and multi-State co-operative banks.

The insertion of a ‘multi-State co-operative bank’ in Section 2(1) (c)(iva) is ex majori cautela as multi-State co-operative bank comes under the ambit of ‘banking company’ mentioned in Section 2(1)(c) and as defined in Section 2(d) of the SARFAESI Act. In Daman Singh (supra), this Court held that expression ‘corporation’ occurring under Article 31A(1)(3) of the Constitution of India is required to be given a broad interpretation and takes within its compass a registered co­operative society.

(c) He relied on The Majoor Sahakari Bank Ltd. v. N.N. Majmudar and Anr.23in which the Bombay High Court observed that co-operative society doing business of banking is a company. The question mentioned above arose as the Government of Bombay issued a notification and directed that all the provisions of the Bombay Industrial Disputes Act shall apply to the business of banking companies registered under any of the enactments relating to the companies for the time being in force.

(d) Article 246 distributes legislative powers between the Union and the State regarding three lists in the Seventh Schedule. Under Article 246(1), the Parliament has exclusive power to make laws in respect of 97 matters enumerated in List I notwithstanding anything contained in clauses (2) and (3). As per Article 246(3), the State legislature has legislative powers to make laws with respect to 66 matters enumerated in List II. The exclusive power of the State legislature to legislate with respect to any of the matters enumerated in List II has to be exercised subject to Article 246(1), i.e., the exclusive power of the Parliament to legislate concerning matters enumerated in List I. As a consequence if there is a conflict in an Entry in List I and an Entry in List II, which is not capable of reconciliation, the power of Parliament to legislate concerning matters enumerated in List I must supersede pro tanto the power of the State legislature. Both the Parliament and the State legislatures have concurrent power of legislation for 47 matters enumerated in List III.

(e) Reliance has been placed on Virendra Pal Singh (supra), in which the Court examined the powers of the State legislature relating to the service conditions of employees. The Court held that the State legislature was competent to legislate concerning employees of the bank. This Court did not deal with the banking business of the co­operative societies. He argued that regulating the non-banking affairs of society and regulating the banking business of society are two different things. Entry 32 of List II deals with regulation of non‑banking affairs of the co-operative society, on the other hand, Entry 45 of List I deals with banking; hence, any legislation dealing with regulation of banking will be traceable to Entry 45 of List I and only the Parliament will be competent to legislate. The SARFAESI Act does not deal with incorporation, regulation, and winding up of the corporation, company, or co-operative societies. It does not regulate the working of a corporation, company, or co-operative society. It only provides for the recovery of dues of banks, including co-operative banks, the procedure for recovery, the authority competent to recover the loan, and the judicial forum to deal with disputes arising out of recovery. Thus, the Act does not touch upon Entry 32 of List II. The decision in Greater Bombay Coop. Bank Ltd. (supra) requires reconsideration and clarification. There is no in-depth consideration of its provisions and, more particularly, Section 56 of the BR Act, 1949.

(f) The ratio of the judgement is material. The obiter relates to the finding of court on an issue that arises in the matter but is not required to be decided for the final decision of the case. Thus, the finding of an issue is considered as an obiter. In contrast to ratio and obiter, the opinion of the court on an issue that does not arise is a casual or passing observation. The question in Greater Bombay Coop. Bank Ltd. (supra) was whether the court and authorities constituted under the State Co-operative Societies Act and the MSCS Act continue to have jurisdiction to consider applications/disputes submitted before them by State level and multi-State co-operative banks for recovery of debts due to them. The question was of the applicability of the RDB Act, 1993 to debts due to co-operative banks constituted under the MCS Act, 1960, the MSCS Act, and the APCS Act, 1964. The question whether the State legislature was competent to legislate law concerning co-operative societies transacting business of banking in the light of Entry 32 of List II of the Seventh Schedule, did not arise in the matter; hence, any observation made by this Court, concerning the said issue, cannot be considered as the ratio of the judgment in Greater Bombay Coop. Bank Ltd. (supra).

(g) He relied upon the decision of a Division Bench of the Bombay High Court in The Shamrao Vithal Co-operative Bank Ltd., Mumbai, and Anr. v. M/s. Star Glass Works, Mumbai and Ors.’ in which meaning of incorporation by reference was considered. The same has to be taken to a logical end. The Parliament has provided an additional remedy to co-operative banks to recover their dues by recourse to the Co-operative Societies Act. The Court did not consider the said aspect in Greater Bombay Coop. Bank Ltd. (supra). The distinction between co-operative banks serving the members and the corporate bank doing commercial transactions would make no difference. The activity remains banking merely by the fact that co­-operative banks are co-operative societies doing banking business; it does not make the banking activity carried out by them incidental one. It remains their activity. It was observed that the definition of ‘banking company’ in Section 5(c) had not been altered by Act No.23 of The incorporation, by reference, has the effect of changing the definition of ‘banking company.’ Even if in the RDB Act, 1993, the co‑operative bank is not included right from the beginning, nothing came in the way of Parliament to enact a law that provides for an additional remedy to co-operative banks.

13. Shri Jaideep Gupta, learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of the Reserve Bank of India, raised the following arguments:

(a) The matter is covered by Entry 45 of List I of the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution of India. For the very reason, the Parliament has the right to legislate in respect of the banking business as defined in Section 5(b) of the BR Act, 1949.

(a) Banking operations would inter alia include accepting of loans and deposits, the grant of loans and recovery of debts due to the bank. There can be little doubt that the Parliament can enact a law about the conduct of the business by a bank. Recovery of dues is an essential function of a banking institution. Entry 45 of List I would mean legislation regarding all aspects of banking, including ancillary or subsidiary matters relating to that. The SARFAESI Act falls within the ambit of Entry 45 of List I.

(b) The Parliament can enact a law in respect of matters contained in Entry 45 of List I, even if the bank in question is a co-operative society. Entry 45 of List I makes no difference whether an entity carrying business of banking is a company or statutory corporation or a co-operative society.

(c) The 1965 amendment to the BR Act, 1949, brought within its ken co-operative banks, is not under challenge and has never been successfully questioned. The Parliament has the power to legislate concerning matters referred to in the SARFAESI Act under Entry 45 of List I, even if the entity which carries out the activity of banking, is a co-operative society. It is permissible for the Parliament to include multi-State co-operative banks within the definition of ‘bank.’ Similarly, the Government could have notified co-operative banks under the purview of Section 2(1)(c)(v) of the SARFAESI Act, more so, in view of the definition in clause (cci) of Section 56 of the BR Act, 1949.

(d) The argument of the appellant that Section 2(1)(c) of the SARFAESI Act refers to an entity and not the activity, therefore, it cannot be justified under Entry 45 of List I, is misconceived. Section 2(1)(c) is only a definition provision. The subject matter of legislation is securitisation, reconstruction of financial assets and enforcement of security interest of banks or financial institutions. The subject matter of legislation is not based on the entity.

(e) The SARFAESI Act is not a legislation relating to incorporation, regulation, and winding up of the co-operative societies or multi-State co-operative society engaged in banking. The same is traceable to Entry 45 of List I, i.e., the activity of banking.

(f) The Statement of Objects and Reasons of the SARFAESI Act indicates that it relates to the business of banking and matters incidental to it. It confers the power upon the bank and financial institutions to take possession of security and sell them to overcome the slow pacing of recovery of default loans and mounting levels of non-performing assets of banks and financial institutions. It was based on the recommendation of the Narasimham Committee I and II and the Andhyarujina Committee formed by the Central Government to examine the banking sector reforms. The legislation in question, thus, relates to the business of banking.

(g) The argument of the appellant that ‘such other banks’ cannot include co-operative banks, is also without basis, and the Parliament has the power to legislate. Certain observations made in Greater Bombay Coop. Bank Ltd. (supra) are incorrect and required to be overruled. The questions which arose in the said case were different.

14. Shri Vijay Hansaria, learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of Maharashtra State Co-operative Bank, reiterated the aforesaid arguments and additionally urged that the Maharashtra State Co­operative Bank has 41 branches in the State of Maharashtra. As on 31.3.2015, it had deposits of Rs.9,992 crores and has granted loans and advances to the extent of Rs.12,006 crores and has working capital to the extent of Rs.20,947 crores. There are total 2115 members including 1818 co-operative institutions, 296 individuals and individual societies and 1 State Government and the number of total shares held by them is 45,67,280 (35,66,104 are held by co­operative institutions, 1176 are held by individuals and individual societies, and 10,00,000 are held by the State Government). The MSC Bank advances various terms loans and working capital loans to co­operative processing units like Sugar Factories, Private Sugar Mills, Spinning Mills, Oil Mills, Marketing Co-operatives, Educational Institutions, and other co-operative Industrial Units. It is the apex institution of all District Central Co-operative Banks, Urban Co‑operative Banks, and Primary Agricultural Co-operative Societies. It has a network of co-operative banks and the agricultural co-operative societies in the State of Maharashtra on 31.3.2015 as under:

Want to Read the Complete Judgment?

You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.

Read on with Premium
Goes straight to payment. GST invoice included.

One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.

Advertisement

Join TaxGuru's Network for the latest updates on Income Tax, GST, Company Law, Corporate Laws and other related subjects.