ITO Vs Pacifica Developers Pvt Ltd (ITAT Ahemdabad)
ITAT Ahmedabad held that as the ownership of the land on which development rights were conferred remain vested with the landowners hence the assessee did not get the right over the income as per accrual accounting system as provided under the provisions of section 145 of the Act. Therefore, the assessee cannot be made subject to tax on the reasoning that the income has accrued to it upon the transfer of development rights.
Facts- The only issue raised by the Revenue is that the learned CIT-A erred in deleting the addition made by the AO for Rs. 1,81,02,740.00 on account of income accrued to the assessee in the trading of development right after admitting additional evidence in contravention to rule 46A of Income Tax Rules.
Conclusion- Held that the purpose of the development right was to develop the plots of lands which was conferred to UMIPL. In fact, the ownership of land on which development rights were conferred remain vested with the landowners and likewise, the assessee was also under the obligation to ensure that the ownership of the lands is transferred to the actual buyers. It is because the ownership of the land was never shifted by the landowners either to the assessee or the developer being UMIPL. Thus, in such a situation, until the project is developed and transferred to the actual owners, it cannot be said that the landowners and the assessee upon transferring of the development right have no role to play in the execution of the development process of the plots. As such they were accountable. Therefore, in our considered view the assessee did not get the right over the income as per accrual accounting system as provided under the provisions of section 145 of the Act. Therefore, the assessee cannot be made subject to tax on the reasoning that the income has accrued to it upon the transfer of development rights in the given set of facts and circumstances.
FULL TEXT OF THE ORDER OF ITAT AHMEDABAD
The captioned two appeals have been filed at the instance of the Revenue against the separate orders of Learned Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals)-4, Ahmedabad, arising in the matter of assessment order passed under s. 143(3) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (here-in-after referred to as “the Act”) relevant to the Assessment Years 2013-2014 & 2014-15.
First, we take up ITA No. 60/AHD/2019, an appeal by the assessee for the AY 2013-14.
2. The Revenue has raised the following grounds of appeal:
(a) The Ld.CIT(A), has erred in law and on facts in accepting the additional evidence when conditions of rule 46A were not found satisfied.
(b)The Ld.CIT(A), has erred in law and on facts in accepting the contents of revised Joint Development agreements (JDs) which has been entered after the passing o f assessment order of 2012-14 & which only notarized as opposed to original JDAs which were notarized as well as registered with sub-registrar & which were not even put up before Assessing Officer during proceedings of AY 2014-15 which got time barred after the date of such revised JDAs.
(c) The Ld.CIT(A) has erred in law and on facts in accepting the rates to be taken as per sq. yard as per revised un-registered Joint Development agreement (JDAs) even though entire submissions during assessment showed the rated were sq. meter.
(d) The Ld.CIT(A), has erred in law and on facts in holding that income should be recognized on execution of final sale deeds to final customers by Unique Mercantile India Pvt. Ltd (UMIPL) to whom assessee had transferred development rights by JDAs dated 30/07/2012 & from whom more than 38.4% (Rs.24,36,73,162/-) out of total receivable amount of Rs.63,37,09,200/-had been received in AY 2013 itself.
(e) The Ld.CIT(A), has erred in law and on facts in holding that income should not be computed phase-wise (i.e phase-I & II) as assessee had received about 66.7% (Rs.24,36,73,162/-) out of total receipts of Rs.36,34,00,800/- of phase-I had been received by assessee from UMIPL in AY 2013-14 itself.
(f) On the facts and circumstances of the case, Ld.CIT(A) ought to have upheld the order of the Assessing Officer.
(g) It is, therefore, prayed that the order of Ld.CIT(A) may be set aside and that of the Assessing Officer be restored.
2.1. The only issue raised by the Revenue is that the learned CIT-A erred in deleting the addition made by the AO for Rs. 1,81,02,740.00 on account of income accrued to the assessee in the trading of development right after admitting additional evidence in contravention to rule 46A of Income Tax Rules.
3. The necessary facts arising from the order of the authorities below are that the assessee in the present case is a private limited company and engaged in the business of land development. The assessee, amongst other transactions of land development, in the year under consideration vide MOU dated 4th of June 2012 has acquired right for the development of plot as detailed below:
i. Right for the development of plot from M/s Kesar Buildcon Pvt. Ltd. and other co-owners in respect of the land admeasuring 4,08,929 square meters equivalent to 4,89,038 square yards. The development right was purchased by the assessee at ₹800 per square meters/668.95 per square yard aggregating to ₹ 32,71,43,200.00 only. The assessee against such development right has made the payment of ₹ 31,30,28,000.00 to the landowners which was shown in the balance sheet. The assessee also incurred cost on the stamp duty of Rs. 32,71,600.00 which was claimed in the profit and loss account in the year under consideration. The assessee over and above the cost of Rs. 800 per square meters of land was also required to share the profit to be generated by it from the development of the land to the tune of 50% with the landowner.
ii. Right for the development of plot from M/s Shri Atul N. Joshi admeasuring 19,931 square meters equivalent to 23,833 square yards. The development right was purchased by the assessee at ₹1060 per square meters/886.45 per square yard aggregating to ₹ 2,11,26,860.00 only. The assessee against such development right has made the payment of ₹ 29,72,000.00 to the landowners which was claimed in the profit and loss account in the year under consideration. The assessee over and above the cost of Rs. 1060 per square meters of land was also required to share the profit to be generated by it from the development of the land to the tune of 50% with the landowner.
3.1. However, the assessee by virtue of the MOU dated 26-07-2012 has transferred/assigned the development right acquired by it as discussed above to the company namely Unique Mercantile India private Ltd (UMIPL for short) against the consideration of Rs. 1200 per square yard. This MOU was made between the assessee, UMIPL and original landowners. As per the MOU, the development rights were to be transferred by the assessee in 2 phases i.e. first phase for 302834 square yards and second phase for 210082 square yards aggregating to 512916 square yards. As such, the amount of consideration was to be received by the assessee from UMIPL for Rs. 61,54,99,200.00 against the transfer of the development rights.
3.2. Based on the above details, the AO was of the view that the assessee has traded the development rights and the income thereon has accrued to it under mercantile system of accounting but the same has not been disclosed in the income tax return. Thus, the AO sought an explanation from the assessee by issuing notice under section 142(1) of the Act dated 24 February 2016.
3.3. The assessee in response to such notice vide letter dated 8th of March 2016 submitted as under:
i. That the profit on the transfer of the development right has not been crystallized in the year under consideration. As per the assessee, the cost including marketing expenses was to be incurred on the development projects as evident from clause 27 of the MOU.
ii. The last payment to be received by the assessee from the development of the project of the 1st phase was 1st of August 2013 which is a date falling after the year under consideration. As such, the amount of Rs. 11,97,27,638 relating to the 1st phase of the project was to be received in the subsequent financial year.
iii. That there were certain obligations as evident from page 6 of para 3.3 of the MOU which were to be fulfilled by the assessee with respect to the development project. Likewise, there was termination clause 7 of the MOU which was forcible on the occurrence of certain events. Thus, the income does not accrue or arise to the assessee merely on entering in the MOU with the party i.e. UMIPL.
iv. Likewise, the payment for the 2nd phase of the project was documented only after 1 September 2013 i.e. in the next financial year.
v. As per clause 4 of the agreement, the income was to be distributed on the sale of the land. The amount received by UMIPL was first to allocate towards the cost of land and the remaining amount was to be utilized for the development of the project.
vi. There was a clear understanding in the MOU that the assessee, besides the agreed land cost, has to share the profit to the extent of 50% which shall be worked out after the related expenses of the project. Accordingly, there was no certainty of profit from the project which is to be shared between the assessee and the landowners.
vii. As such, UMIPL after the development of the plot makes sale to the ultimate buyer wherein the assessee will be a confirming party in the sale transaction. Therefore, it is not possible to reach the conclusion that the income of the assessee has accrued to it until and unless the plots are developed and sold by UMIPL.
3.4. In view of the above the assessee contended that income has not accrued to it and therefore, no addition to the total income of the assessee is called for.
3.5. However, the AO was not satisfied with the contention of the assessee based on the following reasons:
i. The assessee by virtue of the MOU dated 26th of July 2012 has transferred the development right to the company namely UMIPL at a consideration of ₹1200 per square yard. As there was no mention of profit sharing between the assessee and UMIPL as submitted by the assessee, the assessee was to receive a fixed amount of consideration being Rs. 1200 per square yard from UMIPL and it was required to pay Rs. 800 per square yard and 1060 per square yard to the landowners. As such, the profit element of the assessee was almost fixed and there was no need to share the profit in the amount received by the assessee from UMIPL. The assessee also received the payment from M/s UMIPL in pursuance to the memorandum of understanding. In the year under consideration, the assessee received a sum of ₹ 24,36,73,162 which evidence that the MOU was acted between the parties. Admittedly, there was termination clause in the MOU but that was to be invoked in the event of non-payment by UMIPL but that did not happen in the year under consideration. In the event of non-payment by UMIPL, the assessee could have claimed the bad debts. Furthermore, the development work was to be carried out by UMIPL and not by the assessee. As such, the assessee was not under the obligation to incur any expense relating to the project.
ii. Likewise, the NA certificate was obtained by the landowner dated 6 June 2012 and 20 January 2013 which evidences that the MOU was made operative for the development of the plot and sale thereof.
iii. The developer, unique mercantile private Ltd has already developed 12 plots of phase 1 which were duly registered by way of conveyance deed. The assessee against the sale of plots has also received the money from UMIPL. In other words, the land was handed over by the assessee to UMIPL for the development which is evident from plot sold by the developer in the year under consideration.
iv. As per the AO, the consideration pertaining to the 1st phase amounting to ₹36,34,00,800.00 has been received by the assessee dated 6 August 2013 which evidences that this much amount has accrued to the assessee in the year under consideration. Thus, the amount mentioned in the MOU is not a presumptive amount but the actual amount which was to be received by the assessee.
v. The amount of consideration to be received by the assessee and the amount to be paid by the assessee to the landowners was fixed. Yet the assessee has not disclosed any income in the assessment year 2014-15 and 2015-16 despite it has shown receipt of ₹ 6,25,05,600 and 6,02,79,600 respectively. Thus, the income of the assessee was determinative and certain to accrue.
vi. There was no element of cost to be incurred by the assessee in the trading of development rights. Upon transfer of development right, it was the obligation of the developer being UMIPL to develop the piece of plot and make a sale of it. Thus, once the assessee has transferred the development right there remains no ambiguity that the assessee got the right of having earned the income in dispute.
vii. Furthermore, the assessee has claimed the expenses of stamp duty on the purchase of development right for ₹32,71,600 which was claimed as revenue expenses. Likewise, the assessee has also claimed the expenses of Rs. 29,72,000.00 on ad-hoc basis which is representing the payment made by the assessee against the purchase of development rights from Shri Atul N Joshi. Thus, the assessee on one hand is claiming expenses relating to the project but on the other hand without showing corresponding income which is contrary to the provisions of prevailing business practice and accounting principles.
4. In view of the above, the AO calculated the income of the assessee from the trading of development rights for the assessment year in dispute for the 1st phase of the project and the subsequent assessment year i.e. 2013-14 and 201415. The income calculated by the AO for the year under consideration stands as under:
As per mercantile system of accounting the assessee has accrue income of 1 Phase of development right. In the 1st Phase the assessee has transferred development right o f 3,02,834 sq. yards of land. Hence it has accrued income of the 1 Phase only. The assessee has purchased development right of land admeasurin land of 428860 sq. mtrs at Rs. 34,82,70,060/-(2,11,26,860+ 32,71,43,200). Out the above sum the assessee has paid Rs. 29,72,000/- and has claimed the same P & L account. The income from the trading o f development right is determined under:
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.






