Reassessment invalid if no fresh tangible material made available by petitioner

Ball Aerosol Packaging India Private Limited Vs ACIT (Gujarat High Court) In this case what emerges from the record is that no fresh tangible material distinct from what was made available by the petitioner during the assessment proceedings is emerging and specific queries which have been raised with regard to issues now raised have already been explained by the petitioner and the assessing authority having accepted the replies and explanation, no addition is made and as such, a case is made out by the petitioner calling for our interference, since reopening of assessment appears to be on the ...