Mehul Hasukh Shah Vs ITO (ITAT Mumbai)
Penny-Stock Allegation Collapses: ITAT Mumbai Deletes Addition as Mehul Shah Proves 1996 Purchase & Business-Income Treatment; Reopening Based on Incorrect LTCG Information Invalid; Long-Held Penny-Stock Shares Treated as Genuine — ITAT Mumbai Quashes Additions; Incorrect Bogus-LTCG Trigger Cannot Justify Reopening; Assessee Proved Genuine 1996 Shareholding
Assessee, Mehul Hasukh Shah, filed return for AY 2016-17 declaring ₹4,90,760. Reassessment was initiated u/s 147 on the sole allegation—based on Investigation Wing report—that Assessee generated bogus LTCG from 5,000 shares of Safal Securities Ltd. (SSL), a scrip listed as penny stock. AO held that SSL was used for accommodation entries & treated the sale proceeds of ₹32,888 as unexplained cash credit u/s 68 r.w.s. 115BBE, even though Assessee had not claimed any LTCG exemption u/s 10(38).
Before CIT(A), Assessee argued that he never reported any LTCG; SSL shares were held as stock-in-trade & profits were offered as business income. CIT(A), however, upheld AO’s conclusions without verifying documents.
Before Tribunal, Assessee produced key evidence showing:
- SSL shares were originally purchased in 1996, when SSL was “Arrow Securities Ltd.”
- Transfer letter dated 01.10.1996 clearly conveyed ownership of 10,000 shares.
- Purchase was made through banking channels; demat was not mandatory in 1996.
- SSL shares were consistently reflected as stock-in-trade in P&L & balance sheet
- For AY 2016-17, Assessee sold only 5,000 shares, with the remaining 15,000 shares still shown in closing stock.
Tribunal held that:
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.


