Kusum Sahgal Vs ACIT (ITAT Delhi)
Joint Ownership Not a Bar for 54F—Assessee Owning Only Fractional Shares Eligible for Full Deduction; AO & CIT(A) Orders Set Aside
Assessee filed return declaring Rs.66.14 crores & claimed long-term capital gains exemption u/s 54F on investment of Rs.21.28 crores in a residential unit at “The Camellias”, DLF, Gurgaon, arising from sale of shares of Quality Needles Pvt Ltd. AO denied deduction u/s 54F on the ground that Assessee jointly owned more than one residential property on the date of transfer & further disallowed share-transfer expenses. CIT(A) deleted the share-transfer expense disallowance but upheld denial of exemption u/s 54F.
Before Tribunal, Assessee contended that her earlier assets consisted of (i) a commercial unit at Rajendra Place, (ii) agricultural land at Mehrauli governed by DLR Act which did not constitute residential ownership, & (iii) only one residential property jointly owned at Jaypee Greens. It was argued that fractional co-ownership does not amount to “owning a residential house” for the purposes of the proviso to s.54F(1). Reliance was placed on Madras High Court ruling in Dr. P.K. Vasanthi Rangarajan & ITAT decisions including Raman Chawla, Sheriar Phirozsha Irani, Mukesh Vakharia & Zainul Abedin Ghaswala.
Department contended that even joint ownership attracts the bar in the proviso. However, Tribunal noted that no contrary judgment of jurisdictional High Court supports the Revenue & by rule of judicial preference, favourable non-jurisdictional High Court view should be applied where conflict exists, as held in Vegetable Products.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.




