The Karnataka State Tax Practitioners Association has recently submitted an extensive request to the Honourable Minister of Finance, Smt Nirmala Sitaraman. The request primarily focuses on providing amnesty to all the GST assesses for the years 2017-18 to 2019-20, with the goal of avoiding interest, penalties, and ensuring the rights to Seamless ITC. This article delves into the critical details of this appeal, highlighting the major points raised and the potential impact on the tax environment in India.
Analysis
Background
The introduction of the GST Act in 2017 was a significant transformation in India’s indirect tax landscape. However, the transition has been challenging for many assesses, particularly with new intricacies that require time and expertise to understand.
Key Requests
The appeal by the Karnataka State Tax Practitioners Association includes several major requests:
1. One-time Opportunity for ITC: The assesses are seeking a one-time chance to receive ITC if they possess proper invoices.
2. Waiver of Interest and Penalties: For the mentioned fiscal years, they are requesting a complete waiver of interest and penalties.
3. Adherence to Existing Circulars: In particular, the association has requested adherence to Circular No. 123/42/2019-GST.
4. Additional Concessions and Changes: Other points include rate rationalisation, reduced interest rates, late fee adjustments, and more.
Potential Impact
If accepted, these proposals could significantly affect the business environment in Karnataka and potentially across India. It may set precedents for other states and provide a roadmap for dealing with transitional challenges within the new GST regime.
Conclusion
The appeal by the Karnataka State Tax Practitioners Association reflects the ongoing struggle to align with the GST framework that began in 2017. It brings to light the practical difficulties faced by businesses and tax practitioners in adapting to the new system.
The request for amnesty, if granted, could provide relief to many businesses and may also contribute to improving the overall tax compliance and governance related to GST. However, the final decision lies with the central government, and it will be interesting to watch how this appeal is addressed, considering the broader implications for the nation’s tax regime.
*****
KARNATAKA STATE TAX PRACTITIONERS ASSOCIATION (R)
Smt Nirmala Sitaraman,
Honourable Minister of Finance
Government of India, New Delhi.
Date:14th Aug 2023
Respected Madam,
Sub: Request for providing an amnesty to all the GST assesses for the years 2017-18 to 2019-20 so that all interest and Penalties will not be levied and rights of the assess to Seamless ITC is available.
GST Act was introduced in the year 2017 as a revolution of indirect tax since independence, on principles of ONE NATION ONE TAX. As it is a new law it takes some time to all the assesses who are new to the new system to understand all the intricacies and follow the same flawlessly. Hence breathing time for all the stake holders is a demand which is within natural justice and principles.
Further the Honouralbe Government had promised that in the earlier years of GST they will consider the fact that this is going to be a new law and hence a very lenient view will be taken for the mistakes of the assesses.
Further the Government had promised seamless flow of Input Tax Credit throughout the country to all the assesses.
Now it is time for the Government to stand with the assesses who are under threat of loss of ITC because of some suppliers who have not filed GSTR 1. As promised the GSTN did not provide the opportunity to the purchases to file GSTR 2. Hence, the assesses are now sandwiched between the erring supplier and Govt. officers who are insisting that all the purchases must be reflected in GTR 2A. This they are doing in spite of the Circular No 123 /42/2019-GST DT: 11/11/2019 which is binding on them and against which they cannot and should not go and proposing to levy tax penalty and interest. The pleas of the assesses that all their purchases have original invoices, all payment are made by cheques, inventory accounts are maintained and they are to give ITC credit have fallen of deaf years.
In spite of issue of Notification No. 183 DT: 27/12/2022 many dealers are not able to get the certificates as the more than 6 years have passed and parties are cooperating and not issuing certificates.
As there is no facility for revising the GSTR 3B some of the assesses who have without proper knowledge and experience have filed the monthly returns incorrectly are now have to pay heavy prices for their ignorance.
In view of the above facts which are all over the India, we the members of the Karnataka Tax Practitioners Association, Bangaluru appeal to your honour to please
1. Provide one time opportunity to all the dealers to get the ITC if they are possessing the proper and original invoices.
2. Instruct all the officers to not to insist on all the purchases to be on the list of GSTR 2A and adhere to the Circular No. 123/42/2019 DT: 11/11/2019.
3. Waive interest and penalties for three years i.e., for 2017-18,18-19 and 19-20.
4. To stop taking the cases for audit for the year 2017-18 to 19-20 and accept all the returns for those years.
5. Allow ITC in all cases where in the Registration cancellation is revoked and restored.
6. Allow the ITC wherein sec 16 (4) of CGST Act 2017 is violated the light of the Andhra Pradesh High Court decision which has gone against the assesses.
We are sure your honour will consider our request positively and take a positive step towards reducing the problems of all assesses across India.
Thank you.
Yours faithfully,
For Karnataka State Tax Practitioners Association, Bengaluru,
Annexure
1. Implement QRQP Scheme for Small RTP who are not getting supplies amount in time.
2. Reduce Interest rate to 12% for Bonafide Registered Tax Persons with upper cap equal to tax payable
3. Late fee for
- Nil Return 10/- per day Upper cap 1000/-
- Tax Return 20/- per day with Upper Cap 2000/-
4. One Time Karasamadhana Scheme Under GST to Wave of Interest, Penalty & Late fee
5. Three Years Time line to utilise ITC & Claim Refund
6. One Revision Option before filing subsequent period return.
7. Mandate E Invoice or E Way bill for Every transactions as the case may be to get Seamless flow of ITC with Real time confirmation from consignee to avoid mismatch.
8. E Invoice or E Way bill to be Enabled to get by SMS for Paper less transactions by generating UQC
9. Rate Rationalisation based on
i. Value Example Footwear, Rent, etc
<500/-1%, <1000/- -10%
<5000/- 20% , >5000/–30%
ii. Utility
Essential -1%, Non Essential -10%
Luxury -20%, Pollutants, Unhealthy -30%
10. RCM to be minimised to specified Sectors
any reply for appeal??