Case Law Details
R. B. Forging (P) Ltd. (Unit-I) Vs CCE (CESTAT Chandigarh)
Introduction: The case of R. B. Forging (P) Ltd. (Unit-I) Vs CCE at CESTAT Chandigarh pertains to the levying of Central Excise Duty on tool and die charges related to the export of Rough Forgings. The controversy revolves around whether these charges should form part of the assessable value and thus be liable to Central Excise Duty.
Analysis: The appellant, engaged in manufacturing Rough Forgings, Tractor Parts, and MV Parts, contested the imposition of excise duty on tool and die charges. They argued that the charges were associated with the export of goods, which should not be subject to excise duty. The Commissioner (Appeals) distinguished between different types of exports but was ultimately against the export policy, as exported goods are not subject to central excise duty.
The Tribunal found that the charges received on account of tools and dies were for the export of goods and, therefore, should not be subject to central excise duty. They further noted that the lower authority had failed to calculate the duty even after a prolonged period, and the decision relied upon by the department was not applicable to the present case, as it pertained to domestic sales.
Conclusion: The CESTAT Chandigarh’s judgment in the case of R. B. Forging (P) Ltd. Vs CCE clarifies the legal position regarding excise duty on tool and die charges in the context of exports. It sets a precedent by emphasizing the export policy and revenue-neutral nature of such transactions. The impugned order was set aside, allowing the appeal of the appellant, and providing a significant decision concerning the export of goods and the associated charges.
Please become a Premium member. If you are already a Premium member, login here to access the full content.
