Case Law Details
Oriental Trimex Limited Vs Commissioner of Customs (Import) (CESTAT Delhi)
CESTAT Delhi, ruled in favor of Oriental Trimex Limited in their case against the Commissioner of Customs (Import). The pivotal decision allows interest on the auction sale proceeds from the date the Customs Department received the amount until the date of disbursal.
Analysis:- The issue in question was whether the imported rough marble blocks were rightfully subject to confiscation under Section 111(d) and liable to a redemption fine. The Tribunal scrutinized several aspects, including whether the goods were imported without the required import license, the reasons behind the goods remaining uncleared, and the legality of the Revenue’s action to auction the goods pending the disposal of appeals. The Tribunal upheld the argument of the appellant, pointing out that they were not given an opportunity to pay the redemption fine or trade the goods after the outcome of their appeal.
The Tribunal’s ruling was based on the precedent set by the Delhi High Court in a similar case, which ruled that since the goods were not available, redemption fine cannot be adjusted against the sale proceeds. Hence, the Tribunal ordered that the sale proceeds from the auction be given to the appellant after adjusting the amount of the penalty. Furthermore, the Tribunal ruled that the appellant is entitled to interest on the auction sale proceeds from the date the Customs Department received the amount until the date of its disbursal.
Conclusion:- The CESTAT Delhi’s ruling in the Oriental Trimex Limited vs Commissioner of Customs (Import) case brings to light the vital issue of rights of importers during the auction of their goods by the Customs Department. This decision has set a significant precedent, providing much-needed clarity for importers on their entitlements related to auction sale proceeds and serves as a guide to ensure justice and fairness in the auction process. It reaffirms that legal rights of importers can’t be compromised, even during financial crunch situations.
Please become a Premium member. If you are already a Premium member, login here to access the full content.
