Case Law Details
Oriental Structural Engineers Pvt Limited Vs Secretary To Government Public Works (D) Department (Supreme Court of India)
Introduction: In a recent case involving Oriental Structural Engineers Pvt Limited versus the Secretary to Government Public Works (D) Department, the Supreme Court of India has provided significant relief to Oriental Structural Engineers. The court upheld an arbitration tribunal’s award that allows the refund or deduction of overpaid tax. This article provides a detailed analysis of the case, including the background, the interpretation of the award, and the Supreme Court’s decision.
1. Background of the Case: Provide an overview of the dispute and the parties involved in the arbitration process. Explain the nature of the contractual or tax-related issues under consideration.
2. Interpretation of Dispute No. 18: Explain the specific dispute numbered as 18 in the award, which deals with the construction of sub-clause 70.8. Describe the arguments and contentions made by both parties regarding this dispute.
3. Arbitrator’s Award in Favor of the Appellant: Detail the decision made by the arbitrator, which favored Oriental Structural Engineers. Explain how the arbitrator’s interpretation of the law and tax-related matters led to this award.
Please become a Premium member. If you are already a Premium member, login here to access the full content.
