Michael Graves Design Group Inc Vs DCIT (ITAT Delhi)
ITAT Delhi held that passing of project-specific architectural drawings and designs with measurements did not amount to making available technical knowledge, know-how, or processes. Since ‘make available’ clause is not satisfied, services rendered to the AOP does not fall within the purview of FIS under Article 12(4)(b) of the India-USA DTAA.
Facts- The assessee is a privately held multi-faceted and multi-discipline firm headquartered in Princeton, New Jersey, USA. The firm provides design services for its clients all over the world, including India. The assessee is a tax resident of the USA. During AYs 2014–15 and 2015–16, the assessee provided certain services to one of its clients in India, AOP, under an agreement. The assessee received Rs. 4,67,60,000 in AY 2014–15 and Rs. 57,12,000 in AY 2015–16 in consideration of rendering services to AOP. The assessee’s case for both the AYs 2014–15 and 2015–16 was selected for scrutiny, and statutory notices along with questionnaires were issued and served upon the assessee.
During assessment proceedings, the assessee was asked to show cause why, in view of Article 12(4) of the India-USA DTAA, the consideration received for services rendered by the assessee should not be treated as income from Fees from Included Services (FIS). The agreement entered into by the assessee and the AOP with respect to the provision of services very clearly brings out the fact that the services provided by the assessee are of a purely technical nature and that it makes available the technology, the skill, and the experience to the parties i.e. the members of the AOP.
AO concluded that the assistance provided by the assessee makes available the technology to the clients and thus the consideration received by the assessee is to be treated as FIS.
Conclusion- In our humble opinion, the Revenue has missed an important fact that the designs, drawings, layouts, etc. provided to AOP by the assessee are project-specific and specifically made for the construction of the “Statue of Liberty”. Therefore, even if the ownership of such drawings, etc., were transferred to the AOP, the same could not be used for any other purpose by the AOP. The clause of ownership states that sub-consultants’ (i.e., the assessee’s) working papers shall belong to the sub-consultant, which means that the know-how shall remain with the assessee itself.
Held that the consideration received by the assessee for services rendered to the AOP does not fall within the purview of FIS under Article 12(4)(b) of the India-USA DTAA as it does not satisfy the ‘make available’ clause envisaged therein.
FULL TEXT OF THE ORDER OF ITAT DELHI
The appeals filed by the assessee are directed against the orders dated 11.10.2017 and 27.07.2018 of the Ld. Assessing Officer (“AO”) passed under section 143(3) r.w.s.144C(13) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (the “Act”) pertaining to Assessment Year (“AY”) 2014-15 and AY 2015-16 respectively. Since the issue involved in both the appeals is common, the same were heard together and are being disposed of by this common order.
2. The assessee has raised the following grounds of appeal:-
AY 2014-15
“1. The Assessing Officer (‘AO)’/Dispute Resolution Panel (‘DRP’) grossly erred in holding Rs. 4,67,60,000/- to be Fees for included services (‘FIS’) under Article 12(4)(b) of the India-US DTAA.”
AY 2015-16
“1. The Assessing Officer (‘AO)’/Dispute Resolution Panel (‘DRP’) grossly erred in holding Rs. 57,12,000/- to be Fees for included services (‘FIS’) under Article 12(4)(b) of the India-US DTAA.”
3. Assessee has also raised an additional ground vide its application for admission of additional ground dated 12th December, 2022 as under:-
“ 1. WITHOUT PREJUDICE TO THE OTHER GROUNDS OF APPEAL.
a. The Learned Deputy. Commr. of Income Tax (IT) 2 (2) (1), Delhi (AO) erred in computing tax on the assessed Income @ 20% including applicable surcharge and education cess.
b. The appellant respectfully submits that having regard to the provisions of section 115A, the tax rate on the income in the nature of ‘fees for technical services shall be 10% as may be increased by the amount of surcharge and education cess.
c. The appellant respectfully submits that the amount of tax computed by the Learned DCIT should be rectified accordingly.
2. The assessee prays for appropriate relief.
3. The assessee craves leave to add, alter or amend the grounds of appeal at the time of hearing.”
4. The Ld. AR submitted that the above additional ground is purely a legal ground and all necessary facts are already on record. The plea raised in the additional ground was raised before lower authorities. However, inadvertently the said ground was omitted to be taken in the original grounds of appeal filed before the Tribunal. The said omission was noticed by the assessee while preparing for the appeal and hence it has now been raised. The Ld. DR had no objection to the admittance of additional ground.
5. We have heard the Ld. Representative of the parties and carefully considered their respective submissions. We are conscious that the judicial consensus is that the Tribunal has to exercise its power vested in it under Rule 29 of the Income Tax (Appellate Tribunal) Rules, 1963 by applying its judicial mind as the said power is given with a view to doing substantial justice between the parties. Hon’ble Bombay High Court in its Full Bench decision in Ashok Vardhan Birla vs. CWT 208 ITR 958 (Bom) (FB) has held that the powers of the Tribunal are similar to those of the assessee. The Tribunal can permit additional grounds to be raised. In National Thermal Power Co. Ltd. vs. CIT 229 ITR 383 (SC) the Hon’ble Supreme Court observed that a question of law arising out of facts found by the authorities and which goes at the root of the jurisdiction can be raised for the first time before the Tribunal. Following the principle of law enunciated in the decisions (supra) we have admitted the additional ground taken by the assessee before us.
6. Briefly stated, the facts are that the assessee is a privately held multifaceted and multi-discipline firm headquartered in Princeton, New Jersey, USA. The firm provides design services for its clients all over the world including India. The assessee is a tax resident in USA. During AYs 2014-15 and 2015-16 the assessee provided certain specified services to one of its clients in India, AOP (formed by Turner Project Management India Pvt. Ltd., Meinhardt India Pvt. Ltd., Michael Graves & Associates Inc.) under an agreement executed on 19.08.2013. The assessee received Rs. 4,67,60,000/-in AY 2014-15 and Rs. 57,12,000/- in AY 2015-16 in consideration of rendering services to AOP. The scope of services contained in the agreement between the assessee and AOP is as under:-
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.




