Advertisement
Advertisement
Skip to content
Follow Us on
Advertisement
TOP STORIES
Excise Duty

Delhi HC Dismisses Petition; IMFL Excise License Rejection to be Appealed

Case Law Details

TaxGuru Citation
2023 taxguru.in 4585
Case Name
Pernod Ricard India Private Limited Vs Government of NCT Of Delhi & Anr (Delhi High Court)
Appeal Number
Premium Access
Date of Judgement/Order
Premium Access
Subscribe to download.

Already Upgraded? Log in.

Advertisement

Pernod Ricard India Private Limited Vs Government Of NCT of Delhi & Anr (Delhi High Court)

Delhi High Court dismissed the petition as not maintainable in matter rejection of licence for Indian-Made Foreign Liquor (IMFL) as statutory provision which permits the Petitioner to approach the Appellate Authority in terms of section 72 of the Excise Act, 2009.

Facts- The Petitioner – Pernod Ricard India Pvt. Ltd. has filed the present petition challenging the impugned order passed by the Office of the Commissioner Excise, Entertainment and Luxury Tax, GNCTD (‘licensing authority’) by which the L-1 License application made by it before the Respondent No.2 – Department of Excise, Government of NCT of Delhi has been rejected.

The Petitioner is a private limited company. It is engaged in the manufacturing and bottling of Indian Made foreign Liquor (IMFL) and has a substantial market presence across India, especially in the NCTD. It was stated from 1993-till 2021 the Petitioner held valid licenses for the sale of liquor in NCTD. It held licenses for its different units located at various locations in India including units located in Uttar Pradesh, Punjab, Madhya Pradesh etc.

The Petitioner last held a valid L-1 License issued by the GNCTD for its two units namely, M/s Gwalior Alcobrew Pvt. Ltd (Gwalior Unit) and Village Haripur Hindu, Derabassi, Distt. Mohali, Punjab (Mohali Unit) till 16th November 2021.

The Delhi Excise Policy, 2021 (Excise Policy, 2021) was notified by the GNCTD and brought into effect on 17th November 2021. The Excise Policy, 2021 put in place various modifications and amendments about the eligibility criteria, procedures for application and grant of licenses, and license fees payable for L-1 Licenses and brand registration.

Accordingly, since the Petitioner was undertaking liquor manufacturing activities in different states, it was ineligible to hold L-1 Licenses under the Excise Policy, 2021. Consequently, the Petitioner did not undertake wholesale vending of Indian/ foreign liquor under the Excise Policy, 2021.

Thereafter, the GNCTD vide notification dated 2nd August 2022 issued a new policy specifying terms and conditions for issuance of L-1 Licenses for the licensing year 2022-2023 w.e.f. 1st September 2022. Under the new policy, the disqualification imposed on manufacturers from applying for L-1 Licenses, under the 2021 policy was lifted. Thus, even liquor manufacturers could apply and obtain an L1 license under the L1 Policy, 2022.

Accordingly, the Petitioner on 24th August, 2022 applied to Respondent No. 2 for the grant of L-1 Licenses for financial year 2022-2023 for its business in NCTD through the Mohali Unit and the Gwalior Unit.

A reasoned order being the impugned order has now been passed rejecting the L-1 License application of the Petitioner on the ground that documents have been received from investigating agencies alleging the participation of the Petitioner and its employees in what is now commonly referred to as the “Delhi Excise Policy Scam”.

Conclusion- The entire matter shall have to be thrashed out in a substantive appeal which is maintainable under Section 72 of the Excise Act, 2009. Therefore, the question whether or not the Petitioner is entitled for grant of L-1 license under the provisions of Excise Act, 2009 and Rules therein is left open to be decided by the Appellate Authority.

Held that the present writ is not maintainable in view of the express statutory provision which permits the Petitioner to approach the Appellate Authority against the impugned order dated 13th April, 2023 in term of section 72 of the Excise Act, 2009.

FULL TEXT OF THE JUDGMENT/ORDER OF DELHI HIGH COURT

1. This hearing has been done through hybrid mode.

2. The Petitioner – Pernod Ricard India Pvt. Ltd. has filed the present petition challenging the impugned order dated 13th April, 2023 passed by the Office of the Commissioner Excise, Entertainment and Luxury Tax, GNCTD (hereinafter, ‘licensing authority’) by which the L-1 License application made by it before the Respondent No.2 – Department of Excise, Government of NCT of Delhi has been rejected.

3. This is the second round of litigation before this Court. In the first round, in writ petition being W.P.(C) 4057/2023 titled Pernod Ricard India Private Ltd. v. Government of National Capital Territory of Delhi & Anr., the Court had considered the contentions of the Petitioner that the Respondent No.2 had not taken a decision on its L-1 License application i.e. “wholesale vend of Indian liquor license”. In the said petition on 29th March, 2023, the following order was passed:

“8. Initially, the license period was to be only till 31st March, 2023, the same extended circular dated 24th March, 2023 to 30th September, 2023. Thus, it is the submission of Mr. Akhil Sibal, ld. Sr. Counsel that the Petitioner is suffering due to non-issuance of the license by the Respondents as it is unable to sell its products within the territory of Delhi.

9. Considering the fact that the Petitioner has now complied with all the directions and submitted the requisite police verification, there ought not to be any delay in considering the application for the grant of an L­1 license to the Petitioner.

10. Accordingly, it is directed that the decision of the grant of the L-1 license and in respect of the representation dated 13th December, 2022 be taken within a period of two weeks and the same be communicated to the Petitioner. The same shall be a reasoned order. All remedies, if required, are left open and to be availed of in accordance with law.”

4. At that stage, the reason cited by Respondent No.2 for not taking a decision on the L-1 License application of the Petitioner was that some documents relating to the police verification of the directors of the Petitioner, were submitted belatedly. In the said order dated 29th March 2023 the Petitioner’s stand that it had submitted the requisite Police Verification Certificates (PVCs) was duly recorded. In view of the said submissions, the Court had directed Respondent No.2 to take a decision on the L-1 License application within two weeks with a reasoned order. Pursuant to the said order, the impugned order dated 13th April 2023 was passed by the Excise authorities Licensing Authority, rejecting the L1 license application of the Petitioner. It is this impugned order that is under challenge in this petition.

Brief Facts

5. The Petitioner is a private limited company incorporated on 3rd September 1993, and is registered with the Registrar of Companies, Delhi. It is engaged in manufacturing and bottling of Indian Made foreign Liquor (IMFL) and has substantial market presence across India especially in the NCTD. It is stated from 1993-till 2021 the Petitioner held valid licenses for the sale of liquor in NCTD. It held licenses for its different units located at various locations in India including units located in Uttar Pradesh, Punjab, Madhya Pradesh etc.

6. The Petitioner last held a valid L-1 License issued by the GNCTD for its two units namely, M/s Gwalior Alcobrew Pvt. Ltd (Gwalior Unit) and Village Haripur Hindu, Derabassi, Distt. Mohali, Punjab (Mohali Unit) till 16th November, 2021.

7. The Delhi Excise Policy, 2021 (hereinafter, “Excise Policy, 2021”) was notified by the GNCTD and brought into effect from 17th November, 2021. The Excise Policy, 2021 put in place various modifications and amendments in relation to the eligibility criteria, procedures for application and grant of licenses, and license fees payable for L-1 Licenses and brand registration. Pursuant to Clause 3.1.1(iii) of the Excise Policy, 2021, the entities undertaking manufacturing of liquor anywhere in the country were ineligible to hold L-1 Licenses in NCTD. Accordingly, since the Petitioner was undertaking liquor manufacturing activities in different states, it was ineligible to hold L-1 Licenses under the Excise Policy, 2021. Consequently, the Petitioner did not undertake wholesale vending of Indian/ foreign liquor under the Excise Policy, 2021.

8. Thereafter, the GNCTD vide notification dated 2nd August, 2022 issued a new policy specifying terms and conditions for issuance of L-1 Licenses for the licensing year 2022-2023 w.e.f. 1st September, 2022 (hereinafter, “L1 Policy, 2022”). Under the new policy, the disqualification imposed on manufacturers from applying for L-1 Licenses, under the 2021 policy was lifted. Thus, even liquor manufacturers could apply and obtain a L1 license under the L1 Policy, 2022.

9. Accordingly, the Petitioner on 24th August, 2022 vide applications nos. ARN0000069880 and ARN0000070043, applied to Respondent No. 2 for the grant of L-1 Licenses for financial year 2022-2023 for its business in NCTD through the Mohali Unit and the Gwalior Unit. The applications were submitted online pursuant to the L1 Policy, 2022.

10. The L-1 License registration was sought in respect of the following brands of the Petitioner:

Want to Read the Complete Judgment?

You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.

Read on with Premium
Goes straight to payment. GST invoice included.

One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.

Advertisement

Join TaxGuru's Network for the latest updates on Income Tax, GST, Company Law, Corporate Laws and other related subjects.