The Tribunal set aside reclassification of imported penetrating oil as adulterated diesel. It held that failure to meet diesel BIS standards and lack of proof of adulteration defeated the Revenue’s case.
High Court held that a final assessment order passed without awaiting DRP directions violates section 144C. Such non-compliance rendered the assessment order non est and liable to be quashed.
The Tribunal examined whether a penalty could survive despite an allegedly vague notice. It held that since the assessment order and later notices clearly specified furnishing of inaccurate particulars, the penalty was valid.
The High Court set aside GST assessment and appellate orders where the date for personal hearing was fixed on the same day as the reply deadline. It held that such procedure violates principles of natural justice.
The High Court allowed restoration of GST registration cancelled for six months’ non-filing of returns. It held that authorities must consider revocation if the taxpayer clears dues with interest and late fees as per Rule 22(4).
The Court dealt with a GST dispute where the appeal period had expired due to uncertainty over Section 168A proceedings. It condoned the delay and allowed the appeal to be heard on merits without limitation objections.
The court ruled that invoking an inapplicable statutory provision vitiates revision. Proper identification of the governing section is mandatory before exercising revisional powers.
The High Court upheld the Tribunal’s decision restricting disallowance on alleged bogus purchases to 6 percent. It held that the issue was already settled in the assessee’s own earlier year and raised no substantial question of law.
The issue was whether religious objects alone could defeat an 80G claim. The Tribunal ruled that compliance with the 5% expenditure limit requires fresh examination.
The Court dealt with an ex parte GST order passed without a reply to the show cause notice. Holding that natural justice was violated, it remanded the matter for fresh adjudication with hearing.
