DCIT Vs Kay Bouvet Engineering Limited (ITAT Pune)
Survey Statement Alone Can’t Sink Purchases: Pune ITAT Upholds Deletion of 2% “Commission” Addition u/s 68
In a significant ruling, the Pune Bench of the ITAT dismissed Revenue’s appeals and upheld deletion of addition of ₹3.60 crore made u/s 68 on account of alleged bogus purchases, holding that additions based merely on third-party survey statements u/s 133A, without independent enquiry, cross-examination & rejection of books, are unsustainable.
The Assessee, Kay Bouvet Engineering Limited, engaged in manufacture of sugar mill & special purpose machinery, had duly recorded purchases, maintained audited books, quantitative stock records & supported transactions with invoices, e-way bills, GRNs, transport documents & bank payments. The AO reopened assessment based on survey findings in the case of a third party alleging accommodation entries and treated purchases as bogus, estimating 2% commission income.
CIT(A)/NFAC deleted the addition after detailed examination of documentary evidence, noting that:
-
Books were audited & never rejected
-
Quantitative records & stock consumption were not disputed
-
Payments were through banking channels
-
E-way bills & transport documents established movement of goods
-
No adverse material was brought on record by AO except third-party survey statement
The Tribunal affirmed the deletion, reiterating that:
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.




