Case Law Details
Netgear Technologies India Private Limited Vs The Assistant Commissioner GST Delhi East Commissionerate (Delhi High Court)
In a noteworthy verdict by the Delhi High Court, it was ruled that the GST Department cannot deny a refund on zero-rated supplies merely due to the intention of filing an appeal. This decision came in the case of Netgear Technologies India Private Limited vs The Assistant Commissioner GST Delhi East Commissionerate and sets a crucial precedent for GST refund policies, particularly with regards to zero-rated supplies.
The heart of this dispute lies in the petitioner, Netgear Technologies, exporting services without paying Integrated Goods and Services Tax (IGST) during October 2017 to March 2018. These services, as claimed by Netgear, were zero-rated supplies and therefore, entitled for a refund of the input tax credit. However, the GST department denied this refund, which led to a lengthy legal dispute.
The key takeaway from this case is the firm stand by the Delhi High Court that a legitimate refund on zero-rated supplies cannot be dismissed simply because the GST Department wishes to appeal against it. In this instance, Netgear Technologies was denied their rightful benefits for over two years, which the court deemed to be unacceptable.
This judgment is particularly impactful as it echoes previous verdicts by the court on similar matters, indicating a legal consistency in favour of businesses being assured of their refunds under the GST regime.
Please become a Premium member. If you are already a Premium member, login here to access the full content.
