Excise due cannot be demanded on mere presumption without any evidence

Supermax Personal Care Pvt. Ltd. Vs Union of India (Bombay High Court) In the order in original dated 20.11.2019 the adjudicating authority had recorded a clear finding that the only presumption for the demand was that because the maximum retail price of the goods manufactured at Una, Himachal Pradesh and those manufactured elsewhere by the petitioner, which included excise duty, were the same, therefore the maximum retail price of the goods manufactured at Una, Himachal Pradesh included central excise duty which were collected from the ultimate consumers but not deposited in the government tr...