Case Law Details
Delhi High Court in the case of Rajiv Tondon vs. ACIT 294 ITR 488 has held that in a case where two donors had absolutely no connection with the assessee and they made gifts to the assessee only because he needed money to buy a house and they wanted to help him. It was held that this was not only quite unusual but also quite unnatural. It was incredible that a complete stranger would want to gift lakhs of rupees to a person only because that person wanted the amount for purchasing a house.
The taxing authorities were entitled to look into the surrounding circumstances, which they did, and come to the conclusion that the gifts could not be said to be genuine. The reason offered by the assessee did not appear to be reasonable, much less acceptable. Therefore, there was no error in the view taken by the Tribunal.
I also find that on the touchstone of the aforesaid judgement assessee’s case is squarely covered. Here also there is no relationship of the donor with the assessee. There is also no occasion for this gift. The taxing authorities have rightly looked into the surrounding circumstances and drawn the conclusion that gift in this case was not genuine.
INCOME TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL, DELHI
ITA No. 1548/Del/2010 – A.Y.: 2000-01
Please become a Premium member. If you are already a Premium member, login here to access the full content.