Essae Suhagraja Private Limited Vs DCIT (ITAT Bangalore)
AO Cannot Blow Hot & Cold—TDR Allowed; Penalty Deleted; Interest Disallowance Gone-
Contradictory Stand by AO on TDR Cost—ITAT Directs Allowance; Penalty u/s 270A Deleted; Interest Disallowance u/s 36(1)(iii) Also Reversed
AY 2018-19 – TDR Cost of ₹5.45 Cr
Assessee claimed cost of Transferable Development Rights (TDR) as business expenditure.
AO disallowed it in reassessment holding:
- No sale of flats in FY 2017-18 → TDR must be capitalised into WIP
- Deduction allowable only when flats are sold
However, in AY 2020-21 assessment, the same AO held that TDR pertains to AY 2018-19 & disallowed it as prior-period expenditure.
Thus, assessee was denied deduction in both years.
Tribunal held:
- AO “cannot blow hot & cold”—once AO states TDR belongs to AY 2018-19, he must allow it in AY 2018-19.
- TDR cost is undisputedly incurred for business.
Held: AO directed to allow full TDR deduction of ₹5.45 crore in AY 2018-19.
Appeal partly allowed.
AY 2021-22 – Penalty u/s 270A on Keyman Insurance Premium
AO disallowed ₹46.46 lakh (investment portion of Keyman policy premium) & levied 200% penalty u/s 270A alleging misreporting.
Tribunal held:
- Allowability of Keyman premium is a debatable issue with judicial support (e.g., Shri Nidhi Corporation, P&H HC rulings).
- Penalty cannot be levied where the underlying issue is debatable.
- AO failed to specify under which limb of s.270A penalty applied—contrary to Delhi HC in GE Capital US Holdings (2024).
Held: Penalty of ₹23,38,610 deleted.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.




