Tribunal cannot rectify its order for different view by other tribunal in similar case

P.T. Manuel And Sons Vs CIT (Kerala High Court)

We are of the view that the reasoning of the Tribunal is erroneous. A decision taken subsequently in another case is not part of the record of the case. A subsequent decision, subsequent change of law, and/or subsequent wisdom dawned upon the Tribunal, are not matters that will come within the scope of ‘mistake apparent from the record’ before the Tribunal. The different view taken by the very same Tribunal in another case, on a later date, could be relied on by eit

Please become a Premium member. If you are already a Premium member, login here to access the full content.