DCIT Vs Eskag Sanjeevani Pvt. Ltd. (ITAT Kolkata)
Unsecured loans not bogus – ITAT Kolkata upholds deletion of ₹ 4.04 Cr u/s 68 & interest addition- Full documentation saves ₹ 4 Cr loan – Repayment through banking channels proves genuineness – Shell-company theory rejected – Burden shifts to AO after assessee’s proof – Reopening based on old statement struck down
Revenue filed appeals against CIT(A)’s order dated 28.05.2024 deleting an addition of ₹ 4,04,50,000 made u/s 68 towards unsecured loans taken from Asha Apartments Pvt Ltd & ₹ 31.27 lakh interest thereon.
A search was conducted on 05.02.2021 on the Eskag Healthcare Group, in which Assessee company was a related entity. During A.Y. 2019-20 Assessee had received ₹ 4.04 Cr as unsecured loan from Asha Apartments Pvt Ltd & paid ₹ 31.27 lakh interest. AO held that the lender had negligible income & no real credit-worthiness; notice u/s 133(6) was unanswered; & relying on the Manohar Lal Nangalia investigation statement (2014) treating the lender as a shell entity, AO treated the loan & interest as unexplained credits u/s 68.
CIT(A) deleted both additions after noting that Assessee had filed:
– PAN, confirmation, audited accounts, MCA data, ITR copies, & bank statements of the lender;
– ledger accounts showing loan receipt & repayments through banking channels; &
– evidence that the entire loan was repaid in later years (FY 2023-24).
CIT(A) found that AO had not disproved these documents nor shown any fund-flow evidencing that the money originated from Assessee. The statement of 2014 could not taint the 2018-19 transaction. Relying on Iris Clothings Ltd v. DCIT (ITA 1015/Kol/2023), PCIT v. Sreeleathers (143 Taxmann.com 435 Cal HC), & PCIT v. Ambe Tradecorp (P) Ltd (145 Taxmann.com 27 Guj HC), he held that once identity, credit-worthiness & genuineness were evidenced & the loan repaid, no addition u/s 68 could stand.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.


