This article is about how trading in derivatives & Intra-day trading is to be treated under the Income tax.

We will briefly discuss the following:

1. Basic understanding of the concept

2. Computation of income- F&O & Intra-day trading

3. Calculation of turnover- F&O

4. Set-off & Carry forward of losses

5. Applicability of tax audit

A basic understanding

Derivatives are the instruments whose value is derived from an underlying asset. Its value is based on an underlying asset. The most popular derivatives are futures and options.

Futures is a contract to buy or sale an underlying asset on a specified date at a pre-determined price. On expiry of contract, futures are executed by delivering the underlying asset or through payment.

Options is a contract same as future, except in option, one party of the contract has an option (right).

Intra-day trading deals with buying and selling of stocks on the same day, during the trading hours such that all positions are closed before the market closes for the trading day.

Now let’s understand the treatment of income from above, under Income tax Act

Income derived from derivatives (i.e. futures & options) as well as from Intra-day trading are classified as business income.

Further, income from business can be classified as income from speculative and non speculative business.

Speculative Business Income is the income earned from intra-day equity, stocks or currency trading

Non-speculative business Income is the income derived from trading through derivatives, both intraday and carry-forward.

Income from speculative and non-speculative business are taxable at the slab rate and thus these incomes has to be added to all your other income like salary, rental income, other incomes etc.

However, Income tax act treats income from speculative & non-speculative businesses separately, when it comes to setting off & carrying forward losses.

Now, we know that tax rates on speculative or non-speculative are the same, we need to now see how the income is computed for futures & options and Intraday trading.

Computation of income

Like a normal business, computation of income in case of F&O transactions or Intra-day trading would broadly be: Turnover – Purchases – other expenses

Further, income from F&O trading can also be computed using the presumptive scheme u/s 44AD, which essentially presumes the income to be 6% (in case of 100% electronic transactions)

Though the catch here is calculating the turnover in case of F&O transactions, so let’s see how it has to be done

Calculating turnover- F&O

Turnover in case of F&O trading is determined as follows:

  • Total of favorable and unfavorable differences
  • Premium received on sale of options is to be included in turnover
  • In respect of any reverse trades entered, the difference thereon, forms the part of the turnover

It makes no difference whether the difference is positive or negative, it is aggregated to the turnover in either way.

For instance: Mr. A bought 200 units of futures @ Rs. 4,00,000 and sold them at Rs.4,50,000 (Profit:50,000). He also bought 100 units of options @ Rs. 2,50,000 and sold it @ Rs. 1,90,000 (Loss: 60,000).

Total turnover shall be calculated as: Rs.50,000 + Rs.60,000 = Rs.1,00,000. And, if any premium is received on sale of options, it is added to the turnover.

How are income/loss from speculative & non-speculative business different

While the basic methodology of arriving at income & taxes are same in both the cases, it is their treatment in set-off & carry forward of losses, which is different.

In case of non-speculative business, losses can be set off against any head including income from speculative business but excluding income from salaries. If any such loss is not set off in the current year, then such loss can be carried forward for a period of 8 subsequent assessment years.

While, in case of speculative business, losses can only be set off against income from other speculative business in that assessment year. If any such loss is not set off in the current year, then such loss can be carried forward for a period of 4 subsequent assessment years.

Applicability of Tax Audit

Tax audit for any business is required, when the turnover exceeds Rs 1crore in a financial year.

Further, a tax payer having turnover up to 2 crores can opt for presumptive taxation scheme under Sec 44AD. This scheme exempts the taxpayer from the tax audit (if the scheme is opted). However, this section also requires tax audit when the profits are less than 8%/6%* (*in case of 100% electronic transactions) of the turnover.

So, to summarize tax audit would be required in the following scenarios:

1. If your trading turnover is more than Rs. 2 Crores:

Tax audit is mandatory as presumptive scheme is not available.

2. If your trading turnover is between Rs. 1 Crore and Rs. 2 Crores:

Tax audit is required, if you are not opting for the presumptive scheme.

3. If your trading turnover is less than 1 Crore:

Tax audit is not required. However, if you are under losses or your income is less than 8% of the turnover and your ‘total income’ is greater than the basic exemption limit. (eg: in situations where you have salary income along with your trading loss/ income) and you wish to claim such lower profit in your ITR, tax audit would be required.

Disclaimer: The above post is only for the purpose of academic discussion and should not be construed as any legal opinion in any matter whatsoever.

(The author is a CA in practice at Delhi and can be contacted at: E-mail: abhinandansethia90@gmail.com, Mobile: +91-9811741451)

Author Bio

Qualification: CA in Practice
Company: Abhinandan Sethia & Associates
Location: west delhi, New Delhi, IN
Member Since: 26 May 2018 | Total Posts: 39
I am a Practicing Chartered Accountant with over 5 years of professional service experience. My professional services experience include specialization in #GST compliance #Risk based Internal Audits #Risk Management, #business process reviews, #Fraud Investigations etc. among other services View Full Profile

My Published Posts

More Under Income Tax

12 Comments

  1. Amol says:

    Nice article Abhinandan Sethia.
    I need clarification on following 2 points related to declaration of speculative income in ITR3.
    1. In ITR3 P&L I cannot find a way to declare speculative income under 44AD (section 61) so that it can be kept separate from non speculative.
    2. Is it correct to say that income from “speculative business” cannot be claimed under 44AD and has to be declared under 65?
    Thanks in Advance

  2. Sou says:

    For the financial year 2018-19 an individual had loss from futures & options trading which was claimed in the ITR which was filled within the due date but the Income Tax Department has not considered the loss from futures & options trading and raised a demand by adding back the same to the total net income, as it was not mentioned in the P/L. As the individual has audited his accounts hence any change in turnover is not possible in P/L. Hence, it will be kind if anyone can guide me with a solution that in which schedule if the ITR its to be mentioned show that IT department allows the same asap.

  3. PRAMOD KUMAR UPADHYAYA says:

    I had five Future trades. Out of five, I made loss in three and profit in two. The five trades aggregated in a net loss. Should I add all the five numbers to calculate the turnover or should I take the aggregated net loss from future trades for calculating the turnover ?

  4. Sharma says:

    What number of ITR for 2019-20 should be filled for shares trading income from short term capital gain ,long term capital gain ,intraday gain without audit of accounts.

  5. Rajesh Maheshwari says:

    The article was very good. Can you mention the Section under which it has been provided to treat the difference as turnover ?

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Search Posts by Date

November 2020
M T W T F S S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30