Prafful Lalwani


GST will be a game changing reform for the Indian economy by creating a common Indian market and reducing the cascading effect of tax on the cost of goods and services. It will have an impact on the tax structure, tax incidence, tax computation, tax payment, compliance, credit utilization and reporting, leading to a complete overhaul of the current indirect tax system.


The Constitution Amendment Bill for Goods and Services Tax (hereinafter referred to as “GST”) has been approved by the President of India post its passage in the Parliament (by Rajya Sabha on 3 August 2016 and by Lok Sabha on 8 August 2016) and has also been ratified by more than 50 percent of state legislatures. The Government of India is committed to replace all the indirect taxes levied on goods and services by the Centre and States and to implement GST by April 2017.

Salient Features of the proposed Indian GST System:

1. GST is defined as any tax on supply of goods and services other than on alcohol for human consumption.

2. Taxes would be subsumed under this regime as per follows:


3. Petroleum and petroleum products, i.e., crude, high speed diesel, motor spirit, aviation turbine fuel and natural gas, may be subject to GST – if changed, the date shall be notified by the GST Council.

4. Provisions will be made for removing imposition of entry tax / Octroi across India.

5. Entertainment tax, imposed by states on movie, theatre, etc., will be subsumed in GST, however taxes on entertainment at panchayat, municipality or district level will remain unchanged.

6. GST may be levied on the sale of newspapers and advertisements.

7. Stamp duties, typically imposed on legal agreements by states, will continue to be levied.

8. Administration of GST will be the responsibility of the GST Council, which will be the Apex policy making body for GST and it shall comprise of Central and State ministers in charge of the finance portfolio.

9. GST is a value-added tax levied at all points in the supply chain with credit allowed for any tax paid on input acquired for use in making the supply. It would apply to both goods and services in a comprehensive manner, with exemptions restricted to a minimum.

10. Since, India is federal State, it is proposed that GST will be levied concurrently by the Centre (CGST) and the states (SGST). It is expected that the base and other essential design features would be common between CGST and SGST across SGSTs for individual states. Both CGST and SGST would be levied on the basis of the destination principle. Thus, exports would be zero-rated, and imports would attract tax in the same manner as domestic goods and services. Inter-state supplies within India would attract an Integrated GST (aggregate of CGST and the SGST of the destination State).

11. In addition to the IGST, in respect of supply of goods, an additional tax of up to 1% has been proposed to be levied by the Centre. Revenue from this tax is to be assigned to origin states. This tax is proposed to be levied for the first two years or a longer period, as recommended by the GST Council.

Federal structure of taxation:


Scheme of levy

GST is levied on Supply of goods or services. Concept of sale is not relevant in GST regime and definition of supply as given u/s 3 of the GST is inclusive under GST regime.

1. GST law also provides for tax on reverse charge.

2. Imported goods would be liable to custom duty along with IGST (equivalent to IGST on similar goods in India).

3. Small scale exemption applies to a person carrying on business and having turnover of Rs.10 lakh or less. This limit is not applicable in case of reverse charge.

4. Composite scheme is also provided in the law as an option to the dealer whose turnover doesn’t exceed Rs.50 lakh. However, this option is not available to person making inter-state supply. The person buying goods and services from a dealer who has opted composite scheme can’t take credit of taxes levied under the scheme.

5. Supply without consideration is also liable to be taxed under GST and the sum on which tax will be charged, be determined as per valuation rules of the GST.

6. Transaction between Principle-Agent will be liable to tax.

7. Provisions relating to job work u/s 43A of the GST are almost similar to the current regime (notification 214/86 dated 25 March 186).

8. Specific provision made for e-commerce dealers (named aggregators in the GST law) under Chapter -XIB.

9. Section 12 and Section 13 of the GST provides when supply of goods & services will be deemed to have taken place for determining tax liability on supply of goods/services under the GST.

Goods u/s 12 Reverse charge – Goods u/s 12 Services u/s 13 Reverse charge – Services u/s 13
Earliest of the following-

1. When goods are removed by supplier.

2. When goods are made available to the recipient.

3. When supplier issues invoice.

4. Supplier receives the payment.

5. Recipient shows receipt in his books.

Earliest of the following-

1. Receipt of goods.

2. Date of payment.

3. Date of receipt of invoice

4. Date of debit in books.

1. Earlier of date of issue of invoice or receipt of payment (if invoice issued within prescribed period)

2. Earlier of completion of service or receipt of payment (if invoice issued within prescribed period)

3. Date shown by recipient in his books

4. Specific provisions made for continuous supply of services.

Earliest of the following-

1. Receipt of goods

2. Date of payment

3. Date of receipt of invoice

4. Date of debit in books

Classification of Goods Vs Services: Controversy is expected to end!

At present there exists an ambiguity over classification of some transactions (practice varies from state to state) over goods & services and the GST is expected to neutralize the difference of tax incidence between the same. Some of the controversial aspects are as follows-

1. Currently software is taxed as goods as well services and classification of the same remain controversial. Draft GST law has classified software as Services.

2. Under the existing regime, both VAT & Service tax is charged on work contract. Some states provide for deduction of tax at source in case of work contract. Draft GST law provides that work contract will be classified as service.

3. Permit to use intellectual property (IPR) is now classified as service.

4. Activity of leasing of goods classified as service.

Chronology of utilizing credit

1. GST was expected to facilitate seamless credit of inputs and input services however the draft law doesn’t provide so and there are certain technical aspects under Cenvat which have been carried in GST regime also. It may have cascading effect.

2. Credit of capital goods can now be taken in one year as against 50-50 rule under Cenvat Credit. Definition of capital goods remains more or less same under GST also.

3. Credit of Inputs and Input Services can be taken only when these are used or intended to be used by a supplier for making an outward supply in the course or furtherance of business. This condition can lead to denial of credit in various cases.

4. existing Cenvat Rules; however conditions of receipt of services may pose practical challenges as services are intangible in nature.

5. Credit is not available after one year from the date of issue of tax invoice. Additionally tax credit for any financial year (“FY”) can’t be taken after 30th September or date of filing of return whichever is earlier (due date for filing of annual return is 31st December of next FY). Accordingly company management has to ensure that invoices are received and accounted in a timely manner.

6. Inputs or input services which are used for personal consumption (e.g. canteen rent, medical insurance, outdoor catering etc.) will continue to be disallowed under GST regime also.

Transition of credit existing as on last date of existing scheme

Cenvat credit or VAT credit as per the last return would get transferred to “GST electronic credit ledger account” of the taxpayer. If any amount is not claimed in the last return then it can’t be claimed under GST regime.

Scheme of distribution of IGST credit among center and state

GST is a destination based consumption tax in which, the state where goods/services are consumed, will be the ultimate beneficiary for taxes paid by its residents. Transfer of credit among centre and states will happen through GSTN. For instance, Mr. A from Tamil Nadu sells goods to Mr. B of Tamil Nadu who in turns sells it to Mr. C from Mumbai and the applicable CGST is 12% and SGST is 14% then credit will be distributed in the following manner:

Mr. A (Tamil Nadu)

Mr. B (Tamil Nadu)

Mr. C (Mumbai)

Mr. A sells goods to Y for Rs. 10 lakh Mr. B sells goods to Z for Rs. 10.5 lakhs Mr. C sells goods to customer for Rs. 11 lakh (final customer)
CGST @12% = Rs. 1.2 lakh SGST @14% = Rs. 1.4 lakh Output tax payable by Mr. B- IGST @26% = Rs. 2.73 Lakh Output tax payable by Mr.C- CGST @12% = Rs. 1.32 lakh SGST @14% = Rs. 1.54 lakh
Input credit taken by Mr. B

CGST = Rs. 1.2 lakh

SGST = Rs. 1.4 lakh

Input credit taken by Mr. C IGST = Rs. 2.73 lakh
Amount payable in cash after adjusting the input credit Rs. 2.6 lakh = Rs. 13K Amount payable in cash after adjusting the input credit Rs. 2.73 lakh = Rs. 13K

State of Tamil Nadu will transfer Rs. 1.2 lakh to Centre which is used as credit by Mr. B for paying IGST.

GST Network will transfer the SGST of Rs. 1.26 lakh to Mumbai which was used by seller in Mumbai as input credit (IGST credit).

Procedural aspects

1. Registration –

Registration is mandatory for dealers having turnover over the specified limit. Dealers who are already registered with state VAT/sales tax authorities would be granted temporary registration number automatically under the GST regime and they have to get the permanent registration number within 6 months from the date GST becomes effective.

Dealers would be allotted PAN based 15 digit alpha numeric registration number and separate registration is required for each state in which dealer is having business.

2. Returns and their periodicity-

Various returns are required to be filed with authorities (through GSTN) on prescribed frequency.Payment of taxes- Payment over Rs.10,000/- will be made through online banking by accessing GSTN for challan generation. Following process will be followed for payment of taxes-

1) Visit the GSTN and create draft challan

2) Upon creation of the draft challan, the taxpayer will fill in the details of the taxes that are to be paid. The challan page will have sets of mandatory fields, which the user has to provide. The tax payer will have the option to pay CGST, IGST, Additional Tax and SGST concurrently. Generate the final challan after filling all the details.

3) The challan so generated will have a 14-digit (yymm followed by 10-digit) Unique Common Portal Identification Number (CPIN).

4) Select the bank for making the payment. GSTN will share the relevant details (like GSTIN, CPIN, challan amount, relevant state etc.) on a real time basis with bank.

5) After successful payment, challan identification number (CIN) will be generated against CPIN.

Refund of taxes-

It is recommended that option to procure duty free goods for exports to be discontinued and exporter should claim refund of taxes paid on inputs. Refund claim will be processed online and theoretically process & timeline of getting the refund is expected to streamline.

Refund will be given in cases like export, unutilized credit, completion of assessment etc. In case of refund relating to input/input services used for export, the time limit for filing refund claim is one year from the date of export and the refund claim has to be certified by a chartered accountant. Principle of unjust enrichment is applicable in case of all refunds.

3. GST returns and Due date of filling the returns:

GST Return particulars

Due Dates

GSTR 1– Sales Register 10th of the next month.
GSTR 2– Purchase Register 15th of the next month.
GSTR 3– Monthly return form 20th of the next month.
GSTR 4– Quarterly return for compounding dealers On and before 18th of the month after the quarter.
GSTR 5– Periodic return by Non-Resident Taxpayer within 18th day after end of the month.
GSTR 6– Return for Input Service Distributor (ISD) 15th of the next month.
GSTR 7– Return for Tax Deducted at Source 10th of the next month.
GSTR 8– Annual Return On or before 31st December of next FY.


Tax payers need to be GST compliant to be able to test system changes in time. Depending on the operating geographies, size and sector, changes would be substantial and may require proactive planning with a time-bound action plan.

(The author is Prafful Lalwani, qualified Company Secretary. His areas of specialization includes Corporate law and Taxation and offering all type of consultancies. Should you have any query/ clarification feel free to contact him, he can be reached at

More Under Goods and Services Tax

Posted Under

Category : Goods and Services Tax (5571)
Type : Articles (15270) Featured (4122)
Tags : goods and services tax (4102)

3 responses to “ONE INDIA, ONE TAX – Goods and Service Tax (GST)”

  1. raj says:

    at present there are number of govt offices and manpower covering various existing indirect tax laws. areas of mining and land revenue, stamp duty & registrations acts related to above laws within central and state govt also is a critical area. also safety and credits of online payments of e-commerce trust and reliability also need focus since most of the tax payers clear their tax dues through tax consultants and advocates in practice. They will give payments to brokers/middlemen and gaps can create. what will happen to huge govt offices infrastructure covering number of offices and one office requirement for gst hence lot of manpower, vehicles and buildings will get the center and state tackling this issues be highlighted.

  2. J.P.SINGHI says:


  3. ANSHUMAN A S says:

    Sir, You have said that GST Network will transfer the SGST of Rs. 1.26 lakh to Mumbai which was used by seller in Mumbai as input credit (IGST credit). Section 35(5a) states that the amount of input tax creit on account of IGST… should first be utilised towards payment of IGST, and the amount remaining, if any, may be utilised towards payment of CGST and SGST in that order.
    Hence, C has to utilise 1.32 lakhs towards CGST out of the IGST of 2.73 and the remaining 1.41 towards SGST. So, GSTN will transfer SGST of Rs. 1.41 lakhs to Maharashtra. Kindly confirm.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *