Sponsored
    Follow Us:

All ITAT

Reopening U/s. 148 without service of reasons to the assessee before the expiry of period of 6 years renders reopening invalid

January 29, 2011 13675 Views 1 comment Print

As the issuance of the s. 148 notice and the communication and furnishing of reasons go hand in hand, the reasons have to be supplied to the assessee before the expiry of period of 6 years. If this is not done, the validity of the s. 148 notice cannot be upheld. In any proceeding, whether civil or criminal, a summons issued without a copy of the plaint or complaint has to be construed as if no valid service of notice has been effected upon the defendant or respondents.

Transfer Pricing – Reimbursement of incentive paid to employees through Indian co.

January 29, 2011 1346 Views 0 comment Print

The TPO in his order held that the payment of incentive to employees is towards technical services rendered by the assessee to the AE and that the AE has entered into such transaction to avoid paying a mark-up on the payments. In the transfer pricing documentation, since the assessee had shown its operating profit margin at 27.95% (OP/TC), the TPO considering such margin, notionally imputed a markup on the said sum of `10,66,08,194 being the payment of incentive to employees by the associated enterprise and accordingly proposed an adjustment of `2,97,96,990.

Document seized must not only be a ‘speaking one’ but also be prima facie ‘incriminating one’ for attracting sec. 153C

January 28, 2011 2101 Views 0 comment Print

Sinhgad Technical Education Society vs. ACIT (ITAT Pune) -Though section 153C of the Income Tax Act confers jurisdiction if the Assessing Officer is ‘satisfied’ that ‘documents’ seized belong to a person other than the person referred to in section 153A so as to be able to assess that other person, the document must have prima facie incriminating information. The document seized must not only be a ‘speaking one’ but also be prima facie ‘incriminating one’ for attracting section 153C. If the impugned documents merely contain the notings of entries which are already recorded in the books of account or subjected to scrutiny of the AO in the past in regular assessment u/s 143(3) of the Act, such document cannot be said to be containing the incriminating information so as to confer jurisdiction u/s 153C.

Depreciation on assets acquired out of foreign currency loans

January 26, 2011 3369 Views 0 comment Print

The assessee has stated that additions to the fixed assets include loss of foreign exchange rates at the year-end which is added to the written down value of the block of assets. This adjustment pertaining to fixed assets i.e. (premises) acquired in India out of foreign currency loans. The assessee was asked as to why such claim should not be disallowed. The assess

The CIT must give reasons and basis for his conclusion that the order sought to be revised is erroneous

January 26, 2011 405 Views 0 comment Print

The assessee is mainly engaged in the business of rendering rating, advisory, and research and information services, and the assessee also has a unit registered under the software technology park scheme which is granted approval for “development and export of computer software, information technology and enabled services”. During the course of asse

Profit on frequent purchase and sale of shares in short period by assessee has to be treated as `income from business’

January 26, 2011 871 Views 0 comment Print

The activity of frequent buying and selling of shares over a short span of period has to be treated as business being adventure in the nature of trade and the income has to be treated as business income and not as capital gain.

Payment made for renewal of DOT licence should not fall under section 35ABB as it would fall more appropriately u/s 37

January 26, 2011 2609 Views 0 comment Print

The DOT licence fee paid by assessee is not in the nature of capital expenditure falling under section 35ABB, but the same is revenue in nature, allowable under section 37(1)

Pass- through costs that are incurred for non value- added purposes should not form part of the cost base while determin

January 26, 2011 5801 Views 0 comment Print

The ruling upholds and reiterates the OECD position on pass -through costs that are not incurred for value-added purposes. It will provide clarity and guidance to taxpayers and tax administration alike on the issue of determination of cost base in si

Purchase price of generic unpatented APIs from associated enterprises can be benchmarked against the price of same APIs

January 26, 2011 654 Views 0 comment Print

Purchase price of generic unpatented APIs from associated enterprises can be benchmarked against the price of same APIs sold by other independent producers despite difference in quality The Mumbai bench of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (Tribuna

Transfer Pricing – Super-normal profit cos must be excluded from comparables. DRP must not pass cursory / laconic orders

January 26, 2011 736 Views 0 comment Print

It is undisputed that these three companies have shown supernormal comparable profits as compared to the other comparable. There exclusion from the list of comparable is quite correct. By excluding these three companies from the comparables and showing the computation on the basis of TPO data the arithmetic mean of OP/OC to 17.15% which falls within the +-5% range as permitted by section 92(C)(2). Hence, we find considerable cogency in the arguments of the ld. counsel of the assessee in this regard. We further find that assessee has made voluminous submissions including paper books before the DRP who has passed a very cursory and laconic order without going into the details of the submissions. We find that this is quite contrary to the mandate of section 144C of the IT Act.

Sponsored
Sponsored
Search Post by Date
August 2024
M T W T F S S
 1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031