Nancy Trading Company Vs State of U.P. And 3 Others (Allahabad High Court)
The recent Allahabad High Court ruling in the case of Nancy Trading Company Vs State of U.P. And 3 Others has significant implications for the interpretation of tax compliance under the GST regime. The court addressed the issue of whether the failure to generate an e-invoice constitutes an attempt to evade tax, especially when an e-way bill has been duly generated.
Background of the Case
Nancy Trading Company filed a writ petition challenging the orders passed by the authorities under Section 129(3) of the CGST Act, 2017, which imposed penalties due to the absence of an e-invoice during the transportation of goods. Despite having all other requisite documents, including the e-way bill, the petitioner was penalized for not generating the e-invoice as per Rule 48 of the GST Rules, 2017.
Arguments Presented
1. Petitioner’s Arguments:
- The petitioner argued that the goods were accompanied by all necessary documents such as the tax invoice, goods receipt (GR), and e-way bill.
- There is no provision under Rule 138A of the GST Rules that mandates carrying an e-invoice during transit.
- The e-way bill generation indicates the authorities were aware of the movement of goods, negating any intent to evade tax.
- The turnover requirement for mandatory e-invoicing was reduced from ₹20 crores to ₹10 crores effective August 1, 2022, which was a recent change that the petitioner was unaware of.
- The absence of mens rea (intent to evade tax) should exempt the petitioner from penalty under Section 129(3).
2. Respondent’s Arguments: The authorities have the power to initiate proceedings under Section 129(3) if the tax invoice is not generated as required. Compliance with Rule 48(4), which mandates e-invoicing for specified turnovers, is essential.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.




